#1 Posted by DarthOrange (3860 posts) -


#2 Posted by DarthOrange (3860 posts) -

I prefer Saints Row 2. It was just the right amount of wacky, and there was so much customization. Saints Row 3 lost a lot of that (in my opinion).

#3 Edited by Yummylee (21615 posts) -

There's (kinda) already a thread for this. And basically close to everyone prefers SRTT besides a small minority, including myself. EDIT: By which I mean I prefer SR2 =X

#4 Posted by Make_Me_Mad (3087 posts) -

I'm honestly not sure. They were both pretty much fantastic, just in... sort of different ways? I think I like Saints Row 3 a little less in Retrospect after having played Saints Row 2, though. While 3 did a little better on the climactic battles and scale of things, 2 felt better during the average missions spent disassembling the rival gangs. Made things feel much better when the time came to actually finish a group off.

I think I have to settle with 2, but if they can combine the mission structure of 2 with the general entertainment throughout 3, I'll be happy.

#5 Posted by DarthOrange (3860 posts) -

@Yummylee: FFFFUUUUU.............

Thanks dude, I have been out of it for a while.

#6 Posted by EvilNiGHTS (1093 posts) -

Saints Row 3 and pretty much every level, although there's something to be said for the design of the world in the second one. I found it weird that even after 30+ hours with that game I was still finding hidden tunnels and shortcuts that hadn't been revealed in any of the missions.

#7 Posted by MikkaQ (10288 posts) -

I used to be bothered by the reduced customization options, but the other improvements made up for that in the end. Like making the activity grind optional. Saints Row The Third really won me over after a while. I like how it's more self-aware too.

#8 Edited by deerokus (542 posts) -

2 had some really dark subplots, the player's character is an out and out psychopath. I think The Third lacked that, somewhat, instead going for all out lunacy. Also, Johnny Gat is hardly in The Third. This series is all about the Gat!

#9 Posted by Redbullet685 (6043 posts) -

I prefer Saints Row The Third by a big margin. Not to say that SR2 is bad, cause I like that game too.

#10 Posted by Jothel (925 posts) -

2, they really gimped 3

#11 Posted by Subjugation (4720 posts) -

I prefer The Third, although I was pretty crushed by the absence of Johnny Gat. I really hope the retcon him into the fourth game somehow.

#12 Edited by Generiko (445 posts) -

2, 3 just felt like a big disappointment

#13 Posted by Leptok (942 posts) -

Jumping in at 3 made we want to play 2 for more Gat.

#14 Posted by spazmaster666 (1967 posts) -

I enjoyed Saints Row 2 quite a lot but found that it just relied way too much on the side activities for longevity/content while also having a pretty lackluster story. I really enjoyed the story missions in Saints Row the Third and found the side missions much more approachable as well. In terms of craziness Saints Row 2 was pretty damn crazy. People who think Saints Row the Third was way over the top probably didn't play Saints Row 2.

#15 Posted by MaxxS (201 posts) -

Saints Row 2 is better than SRTT in terms of customization and the open world being better, but that isn't enough. The shooting and driving mechanics in The Third are so much more satisfying, and the upgrade system helps with that. You feel a lot less obligated to do the activities, which is good because they decided for some reason to bring back fucking Heli Assault. Also I think The Third is much more well written than SR2.

#16 Posted by fugie7 (1109 posts) -

Saints Row the third.

#17 Posted by LD50 (415 posts) -

SRTT had me laughing my ass off.

#18 Posted by adam1808 (1488 posts) -

This is a question you can ask? With a straight face?

#19 Posted by FluxWaveZ (19334 posts) -

I preferred Saints Row 2.

#20 Posted by ahgunsillyo (450 posts) -

I liked Saints Row The Third more, I think, and a lot of that is because I was actually able to finish that game. There was a point in Saints Row 2 where I was just suddenly lost interest. I think it's because I had to do more side missions to unlock the next story mission or whatever (I think that's what happened; it's been a while since I've played 2). I also rather liked how utterly ridiculous The Third was. However, I do think that Saints Row The Third was a little too short, and I really missed the amazing amount of customization that Saints Row 2 had when it came to your character's clothes, but overall, I think The Third was better-made game.

#21 Posted by dcgc (878 posts) -

Saints Row 2. It has more stuff than SR3 and competitive MP. I also prefer the streetgang story. Not only it has its fun moments, but it also has serious moments (which SR3 lacked of).

#22 Posted by ZeForgotten (10397 posts) -

Saints Row 2, without a doubt. 
So much more cray stuff going on that made even a crazy game like SR3 look tame. 

#23 Posted by DeeGee (2123 posts) -

Saints Row 2.

Both great games though.

#24 Posted by dropabombonit (1490 posts) -

SR3 by a country mile, did not like 2 at all but loved the third

#25 Posted by believer258 (11894 posts) -

The second game just feels like it has more in it. Granted, this doesn't make it the better game, but the only thing in SR3 aside from the main quest that stood out to me was the arena games, where you run through an area and shoot guys. I thought those were pretty fun. However, there was a point in SR3 where I asked myself "What else is there to do around town"? and I looked around the map - and there was not a single thing I cared for. Nothing. I didn't want to do any of the side missions because I'd done all the ones I deemed fun, I didn't want to buy anything because there was nothing left to spend my money on, and I didn't want to screw around much either.

On the other hand, Saints Row 2 has a whole lot of good things to go around. There are more clothing options, more options for a home base or whatever, more character customization options, more vehicle options, more weapons, more upgrades, a lot more side missions (although there are some real stinkers here) and just more. Forgetting all of that, there are three individual main storylines which all take some pretty interesting turns. You'd be hard-pressed to beat SR2 in 20 hours; you'd be hard pressed to get more than 20 hours out of a single SR3 playthrough.

Forgetting the sheer amount of stuff, I have to mention one other thing that I liked about SR2 - restraint. Sounds nuts coming from this series, but the wacky stuff in SR2 actually came across as wacky because the game wasn't wearing a huge clown hat all of the time. It didn't take itself seriously, no, but it never felt like it was trying very, very hard to come across as wacky or weird, and this made the wacky all that more entertaining. It just got tiring in SR3.

No, I do not think that SR3 is a bad game and it is worth your money and time - but Saints Row 2 is a better game.

Online
#26 Posted by Rohok (554 posts) -

2 had much more customization. That makes it better.

#27 Posted by Revan_NL (340 posts) -

Saints Row The Third. I miss the customisation options SR2 had but overall I enjoyed The Third alot more. Better gameplay mechanics and a more coherent (although crazy) story.

#28 Posted by Dimsey (954 posts) -

I liked The Third a bit more, but I was pretty bummed when I saw it was lacking in some of the customization options that SR2 had. 

#29 Posted by Sploder (917 posts) -

Three, I think it's better in every way, except for the lack of clothing customisation options.

#30 Posted by JasonR86 (9695 posts) -

Saints Row The Third. Saints Row 2 is boring to me.

#31 Posted by KlUMZeE (318 posts) -

Shit, I accidentally picked SR 2 when I meant to choose The Third, lol. I wish there was a way to change your vote. SR2 had some great ideas and really found the right direction for the franchise but I played it on the Xbox 360 and the framerate and performance issues rendered the game almost unplayable in parts and really sapped the fun out of it. There were definitely things in SR2 that I wish were in SR:TT, and I hope will return in SR4, but overall I think that SR:TT is a better game.