Edited 11 months, 24 days ago

Poll: Which group of Video games would you rather have? (88 votes)

Group1 63%
Group2 38%

#1 Edited by jumpstart55 (4 posts) -

Group 1 (PS3)

BioShock 1 and 2

Marvel vs. Capcom 3: Fate of Two Worlds

Street Fighter IV

Dragon Ball: Raging Blast

Star Wars: The Force Unleashed

Final Fantasy XIII 1and 2

The Entire God of War series 2006-2013

Shadow of the Colossus

Journey

LittleBigPlanet 1 and 2

Batman: Arkham Asylum and Arkam City

Uncharted 1-3

Group:2(XBOX 360)

Spider-Man: Shattered Dimensions

BioShock Infinite

Batman: Arkham Origins

Deadpool

Dragon Ball Z: Ultimate Tenkaichi

X-Men Origins: Wolverine

Marvel: Ultimate Alliance 1-2

Injustice: Gods Among Us

Mortal Kombat

halo 1-3 odst and reach

Afro Samurai

Limbo

Sonic Generations

Gears of War1-3

Mass Effect1-3

#2 Posted by crithon (3340 posts) -

i regret my choice

#3 Edited by PandaBear (1377 posts) -

#4 Posted by jasbir (107 posts) -

Neither

#5 Posted by CaLe (4021 posts) -

I'd rather die than choose one of those groups.

#6 Posted by Flappy (2302 posts) -

Neither. Pawn them all off (or trade them to gamestop for $100)!

#7 Posted by zombiepenguin9 (534 posts) -

Am I to expect these to arrive in the mail?

#8 Edited by Nekroskop (2786 posts) -

They're both piles of shit with gold nuggets in them. It's impossible to decide.

#9 Edited by themangalist (1739 posts) -

To me it reads: Shadow of the Colossus & Journey VS. Mass Effect Trilogy.

#10 Edited by SharkEthic (1057 posts) -

Fuck man, I don't know...a few great games in each surrounded by a ton of games I don't give a fat shit about. Wouldn't re-play a single game in either pile, except for maybe Journey...sooo, group 1 wins?

Edit: Shit, might re-play Limbo as well. It's a tossup.

#11 Edited by Sinusoidal (1661 posts) -

I guess I'll go with group 1 because I already own more of those than group 2...

Ahh, these are used bundles I bet. PS3 for the first batch and Xbox 360 for the second.

#12 Posted by TobbRobb (4752 posts) -

This is a terrible thread, but I'll answer anyways. Group 1 is a landslide winner.

#13 Edited by Capum15 (4930 posts) -

The only ones I care about in those are ones I already have, so neither?

#14 Edited by Brodehouse (10079 posts) -

Mass Effect trilogy, I guess?

Here's a better question directed towards the OP; why?

#15 Posted by ZolRoyce (736 posts) -

I have a lot of why's.

Why is the header image the Video Games Live logo?

Why ask the question/make the topic?

Why break the topic up into two posts that should have just been one post?

Why am I posting here?

Why is anyone posting here?

...

Are you the Tommy Tallarico?

#16 Posted by nutta27 (199 posts) -

Mass Effect trilogy, I guess?

Here's a better question directed towards the OP; why?


I also wish to know the answer to the previous question.

#17 Posted by Godlyawesomeguy (6399 posts) -

I'm not typically one to mini-mod but this really doesn't seem like it has a ton of discussion value. What a weird little thread.

#18 Posted by Jams (2962 posts) -

Neither.

#19 Posted by kaos_cracker (634 posts) -

I played all of them. So, Group 3?

Online
#20 Posted by CynicalBuzzard (240 posts) -

Group 1 appeals to me the most.

#21 Edited by jumpstart55 (4 posts) -

@brodehouse: My cousin is giving away his video games, and he asked me to pick between these two groups.

And heres a question, Why is everyone on giant bomb so doucey?

I posted the exact same question on comicvine and got simple straight forward answers.

All the question on here were just rude, i mean if you dont like the thread then why post at all. I mean to just post for the sake of being seems a bit childish.

I know its the internet in all, but seriously.

#22 Edited by Random45 (1235 posts) -

To me it reads: Shadow of the Colossus & Journey VS. Mass Effect Trilogy.

Pretty much the same here. Shadow of the Colossus is my favorite game of all time, but the Mass Effect Trilogy is fantastic as well.

#23 Posted by Random45 (1235 posts) -

@brodehouse: My cousin is giving away his video games, and he asked me to pick between these two groups.

And heres a question, Why is everyone on giant bomb so doucey?

I posted the exact same question on comicvine and got simple straight forward answers.

All the question on here were just rude, i mean if you dont like the thread then why post at all. I mean to just post for the sake of being seems a bit childish.

I know its the internet in all, but seriously.

Because everyone here is under a weird impression that the Giantbomb forums are a mature and wonderful place unlike any other forum on the internet, so they've got a superiority complex and everyone feels like they should be an admin.

You'll get used to it if you stick around, but it's very annoying getting used to at first.

#24 Posted by Deranged (1837 posts) -

Group 2 for the ME trilogy is the game(s) to beat and none from the first group come close IMO. By extension, Gears, Halo, Injustice, MUA and Infinite are all fantastic but everything else is relatively meh.

#25 Posted by Sin4profit (2956 posts) -

...the hell?

@random45 said:

@jumpstart55 said:

@brodehouse: My cousin is giving away his video games, and he asked me to pick between these two groups.

And heres a question, Why is everyone on giant bomb so doucey?

I posted the exact same question on comicvine and got simple straight forward answers.

All the question on here were just rude, i mean if you dont like the thread then why post at all. I mean to just post for the sake of being seems a bit childish.

I know its the internet in all, but seriously.

Because everyone here is under a weird impression that the Giantbomb forums are a mature and wonderful place unlike any other forum on the internet, so they've got a superiority complex and everyone feels like they should be an admin.

You'll get used to it if you stick around, but it's very annoying getting used to at first.

i guess Comic Vine doesn't care for a little thing called, "context". Even now, why the hell doesn't your cousin just give away the individual games to the people that want them...why is he bolting them into specific groups?

#26 Posted by Budwyzer (599 posts) -

I would ask for Group 2 then - Seems to be more newer games

Group 1 is mostly older titles that can all be gotten through various deals/sales. IE: I got Bioshock 1&2 for $5 each (probably less. I tend to buy most of my games from Humble Bundle these days, or Greenmangaming

#28 Posted by Sin4profit (2956 posts) -

@jumpstart55: Fair enough, just know that you could have gotten past the "douchey" responses if you added more context to the question.

i would go with group 2 and trade those games in.

#29 Posted by devilzrule27 (1239 posts) -

Get the first group, then go buy the Mass Effect trilogy.

#30 Posted by Blu3V3nom07 (4235 posts) -

Halo, Halo, Halo, 2!

#31 Posted by thefeta (40 posts) -

Mass Effect trilogy is better than anything in Group 1 to me...

#32 Posted by UlquioKani (1137 posts) -

I would love to know the context for these 2 groups as that is a weird set of games to choose from.

#33 Posted by Kidavenger (3582 posts) -

16 games I would play or like in the first group vs 6 in the second.

#34 Posted by 49th (2785 posts) -

Thread usability 4/10 - unergonomic design

Work on UI elements and labelling

#35 Posted by jumpstart55 (4 posts) -

Because i asked him first, And group 1 is just Playstation 3 and Group 2 is Xbox 360.

@jumpstart55: Fair enough, just know that you could have gotten past the "douchey" responses if you added more context to the question.

i would go with group 2 and trade those games in.

Because i asked him first, And group 1 is just Playstation 3 and Group 2 is Xbox 360.

Yea still man, its a simple question. You either answer group 2 or group 1.

If you have no interest in this thread, don,t post at all.

The context shouldn't even matter. What matter is the question being asked. If you have no interest in the question being asked do not post.There is absolutely no reason to act douchey other then for the sake of being a douchebag. I mean most of these comments are bordering on troll level.

#36 Edited by HatKing (6025 posts) -

If I choose Group 2 can I have my Injustice and MK on PS3?

Group 2 regardless. I barely even touch my 360 anymore, but it seems like the slightly better group. Mostly because it has more games I've never played.

#37 Posted by GERALTITUDE (3430 posts) -

Because many people here are lame @jumpstart55, that's why they act so douchey. Don't bother trying to talk to anyone about it though the whole thread will just devolve.

Anyways, I like Group 1 more, but just barely. It's hard. It would be easier to help you decide if I knew what types of games you generally like and also which from both groups you've already played.

#38 Posted by Brodehouse (10079 posts) -

@brodehouse: My cousin is giving away his video games, and he asked me to pick between these two groups.

And heres a question, Why is everyone on giant bomb so doucey?

I posted the exact same question on comicvine and got simple straight forward answers.

All the question on here were just rude, i mean if you dont like the thread then why post at all. I mean to just post for the sake of being seems a bit childish.

I know its the internet in all, but seriously.

Yeah I'm really douchey for asking why. I'm the one overreacting.

#39 Posted by IrrelevantJohn (1083 posts) -

@jumpstart55: Context should matter or the post is practically spam.

#41 Posted by Sin4profit (2956 posts) -