Which would be the most fun Offline Co- op? Based on Replayability!!!

Out of those four? I haven't played two of the four (Resistance 2 and SF IV, respectively), but RPG games are meant to be played over and over, so I'll go with Fable 2.

i'd say gears of war 2, providing that you have a big tv, but street fighter IV is great too.

Fable 2 or Gears of War 2.

Depending on the type of game you like.

Edit: If the thread was any game you could think of then i'd say Gauntlet on the N64. Always. BEST co-op RPG I have ever played.

Fable 2's co-op is unplayable due to the horrid lack of camera control, and given the fact that it actually tends to focus on player 2 which makes no sense at all.

For replayability alone I'd say SFIV. Gears has also a very fun coop mode.

Street Fighter if you play against somebody as good (or bad) as you.

Out of those, Fable 2.

Either Gears 2 or SFIV.....just depends on whether you are into shooters or fighting games.  I've been told Fable 2 co-op sucks and I would choose gears 2 over resistance 2.

Out of the games mentioned...I would probably say Fable 2 (though I haven't tried it myself). I'm a bit confused as to why SFIV in on that list...that's not really co-op, but versus.

killzone 2 if they had it

Out of those I say gears of War, but L4D is way better.

I didn't find Fable 2's co-op much of a problem tbh - I think that was a stock criticism in reviews, but I found it totally workable and fun. It wasn't 'perfect', in that you couldn't bring your own character into another person's game, which obviously would be the absolute ideal, but at least the xp carried over.

No, it wasn't a stock criticism I'm just ripping from the pages of other people's reviews, it's a real fucking annoying problem. You simply have no control over the camera whatsoever when in co-op and the camera follows player 2 more closely than player 1, in both offline and online co-op modes. How do I know these things? I was dumb enough to try! Fable 2 is awesome, but the co-op sucks!

I would usually choose the RPG, but Fable's co-operative camera sucks. Go with Gears.

Fable II has terrible co-op...

Gears 2 if you include the local multiplayer with bots.