Posted by Aegon (5852 posts) 1 year, 3 days ago

Poll: Your platforming preference: Kirby or Mario? (90 votes)

Kirby 18%
Mario 82%

I think I've only had significant experience with one of each, but the Kirby experience was back when I was a kid. I think I enjoyed it though.

#1 Posted by Ares42 (2800 posts) -

Rayman

#2 Posted by csl316 (9526 posts) -

Mario World is my favorite game of all time.

But Sonic.

#3 Posted by believer258 (12216 posts) -

Donkey Kong Country.

Specifically, the second one.

...OK, OK! Mario is all right. I think I've played a Kirby game once or twice, but I don't actually remember.

#4 Posted by JJOR64 (19071 posts) -

I love both of them, but Mario takes the cake.

#5 Posted by Colourful_Hippie (4504 posts) -
#6 Posted by Quantris (353 posts) -

Kirby because I fell in love with Superstar (Ultra) and I just want another one like that (return to dreamland fell frustratingly short IMO).

#7 Edited by Ezekiel (551 posts) -

I still need to play a Kirby.

Super Meat Boy > Mario (1, TLL, 3, World 2) > Rayman (Origins) > Sonic (trilogy)

#8 Edited by Hunter5024 (5982 posts) -

When I was a kid I had a rom for one of the gameboy Kirby games and I remember liking that a whole lot, but beyond that I don't have much experience with Kirby. I spent some time with Epic Yarn, and the one following it for the Wii and I felt like the gameplay wasn't hard enough or complicated enough for me to derive much enjoyment once the newness had worn off.

I also paid my dues to Super Mario World and Mario 64 when I was a kid, and thought they were amazing at the time, though once I experienced Zelda I think I kind of wrote it off as baby stuff. I distinctly remember Sunshine coming out and acting like I was too good for it (because I didn't have a gamecube). It wasn't until my friends picked up New Super Mario Bros Wii and decided the four of us would play through the whole thing together that my love of Mario was really rekindled. I don't think I would've even agreed if the quick look weren't so good, and yet now I consider that playthrough one of my best gaming memories. I tried going back to the DS one and was kind of unimpressed, so I was ready to write it off as a multiplayer fluke until I played 3d land, once I got to the second 8 worlds that game had its hooks deep inside me. It ended up getting me to go back and play Mario 64 and that holds up way better than it should.

So yeah. Definitely Mario. Those first two Donkey Kong countries are pretty damn good too though.

#9 Posted by Kaiserreich (745 posts) -

Mario, but Kirby has better music.

#10 Posted by Dixavd (1381 posts) -

...Sonic? (I'll just go back to raising my Chao)

#11 Posted by Ezekiel (551 posts) -

@dixavd said:

...Sonic? (I'll just go back to raising my Chao)

Still no Chao game!

#12 Edited by ImmortalSaiyan (4702 posts) -

C'mon now. Super Mario World/64/Galaxy. Kirby games are cute and a fun time but those Mario games listed are exceptional games and all time classics.

#13 Edited by Iodine (550 posts) -

See, I love Kirby more than I can ever love Mario, but in terms of Pure Platforming it's Mario

But Kirby is the illest

#14 Posted by RazielCuts (2987 posts) -

#15 Posted by Dixavd (1381 posts) -

@ezekiel said:

@dixavd said:

...Sonic? (I'll just go back to raising my Chao)

Still no Chao game!

I know, right?!

#16 Posted by Yummylee (22587 posts) -

Crash Bandicoot.

#17 Edited by AMyggen (3698 posts) -

@yummylee: That's barely a platformer!

But seriously, Mario. Come on, this isn't a contest.

#18 Posted by Yummylee (22587 posts) -

@amyggen: Wachu talking 'bout. Crash Bandicoot 2 and Warped are completely valid (and also great) platformers.

#19 Posted by Noblenerf (333 posts) -

I prefer Mario platformers, though I hope Kirby doesn't leave us any time soon.

#20 Posted by Shortbreadtom (867 posts) -

Mario is a better platformer, but Kirby wins in every other respect. Art, gameplay, setting, character... I should play another Kirby game

#21 Posted by AMyggen (3698 posts) -

@yummylee: I was (kinda) trolling. I just think that CB has always been very mediocre, and don't understand the people who want a new game in that franchise. But I guess it's a platformer, but not a good one!

#22 Edited by Yummylee (22587 posts) -

@amyggen: Well I think they're fantastic, and I relatively recently headed back to 'em (and even 100%'d them both again, too), and think that they not only hold up surprisingly well, but are still really fun games with an appealing dose of personality. So... agree to disagree blah blah blah.

#23 Posted by Coafi (1494 posts) -

Both?

#24 Posted by crithon (3458 posts) -

kriby games always feel to come out of no where. So they feel like a delightful surprise, because everyone is going to say canvas curse and not Kirby 64 as games they enjoy playing

#25 Posted by Zeik (2788 posts) -

Neither, but even with my limited Kirby experience I've enjoyed that series more than any Mario I've played.

#26 Edited by JackSukeru (5967 posts) -

Mario. I'm not sure I'm into the feel of the controls or the design of many of the Kirby games anymore. It's kinda hard to explain but a lot of the time I just don't find the copy-powers satisfying to use.

I did like Epic Yarn though, it did away with the slow flying and the copy powers and generally played pretty well, I think.

#27 Posted by Vuud (2035 posts) -

Kirby is just too easy. He's a little too chill for me. Mario isn't afraid to get gangsta.

#28 Posted by StarvingGamer (8560 posts) -

Can the carefree floating in Kirby games honestly be considered "platforming"?

#29 Posted by CooVee (146 posts) -

Mario games are far more interesting as far as platforming goes but I must admit I haven't played too much of Kirby games over the years. Perhaps I should check out that upcoming 3DS game as it seems pretty faithful to past games.

#30 Posted by GunstarRed (5486 posts) -

Kirby is just fine, but there's no contest really. Mario.

#31 Edited by TheMasterDS (2154 posts) -

Kirby is more about fucking about with fun powers. It's almost what you'd get if a brawler and a platformer had a baby. Sort of. I would say I generally prefer the tighter platforming of a pure platformer. That said I would not say Mario, Mario's a bit crap. Not as crap as Sonic, but not exactly top of the line. Modern Rayman or Donkey Kong Country's where it's at.

Donkey Kong Country.

Specifically, the second one.

Right on man. You know your platformers. Clapper's Cavern.

#32 Posted by Steadying (1481 posts) -

Mario. I find almost every Kirby platformer to just be completely boring.

#33 Posted by ripelivejam (4925 posts) -

mario inside of kirby

#34 Posted by ArbitraryWater (12138 posts) -

Kirby is only a platformer in the most literal sense of the term, and while I still appreciate that series' light and breezy nature, it's not even comparable to Mario.

Online
#35 Posted by Yesiamaduck (1238 posts) -

Rayman (y)

#36 Posted by Guesty_01 (382 posts) -

Mario.

Every.Single.Time.

#37 Edited by President_Barackbar (3474 posts) -

@amyggen said:

@yummylee: I was (kinda) trolling. I just think that CB has always been very mediocre, and don't understand the people who want a new game in that franchise. But I guess it's a platformer, but not a good one!

Well, take this into consideration. I am someone who's first real game console was a Playstation (my dad had a Saturn that I played before but it wasn't like I was buying Saturn games). As such, Crash Bandicoot and Spyro were the first two platformer franchises I played. I never owned an N64 or a Gamecube, and as such had very little contact with Mario, even though I did own Nintendo handhelds. Mario doesn't really do a lot for me since I do not have any sort of nostalgic backing. That's not to say Mario games aren't well made, but without any kind of nostalgia for that series, I see them just as I see any other well made game. Nothing more and nothing less. Super Mario Bros, Mario 3, and World are fantastic games, but Mario 64 to me doesn't really hold up at all to me as some classic of the ages or end all be all platformer. Without nostalgia for first party Nintendo titles, I have never had a reason to buy a Nintendo console. I think the original Spyro and Crash trilogies are excellent, and well worth being remembered alongside Mario 64 and Ocarina of Time.

All that aside, I think Kirby is the game series I have personally had more fun with than Mario. Mario is fine, but its not all that special to me. Kirby has a lot of personality and pizzazz.

#38 Posted by Gamer_152 (14113 posts) -

I mean Kirby's cool, but the Mario games are such fantastically made platformers that there's no competition for me.

Moderator
#39 Posted by Nottle (1915 posts) -

I love Kirby but I feel like Mechanically they have never topped Super Star for the SNES? Granted, I haven't played a new Kirby game since Canvas Curse and it seems like every other Kirby game is a "nontradtional" Kirby game where you aren't absorbing powers.

Has a Kirby game had as much Depth as Super Star? Some of 64 was cool withe fusion of abilities, but I often find that his abilities will do like 1 thing now days or it's a game about whip attacks/ drawing lines/ mass of kirbys.

Mario I'd say is overall better, but I'd like to like Kirby more. It's just that Super Star was too good.

#40 Posted by Budwyzer (635 posts) -

I am unaware if there is a multiplayer Kirby game. So Mario wins in the game contest.

As far as TV Shows go though, The Kirby cartoon, easily wins over anything Mario. Except for maybe Super Mario Bros

#41 Edited by DaddyCabinet (225 posts) -

#42 Posted by Humanity (10145 posts) -

I love da Kirbster. He rides a giant hamster, he's the man!