MGS4 or LBP? Which to get?

Topic started by NickM on July 2, 2009. Last post by AzureSupernova 4 months, 3 weeks ago.
Post by NickM (785 posts)

Poll: MGS4 or LBP? Which to get?

  • Metal Gear Solid 4
  • LittleBigPlanet
Post by NickM (785 posts) See mini bio
2444 ACH / 50979 P

Loading...
So, I'm getting a PS3 bundle with KZ2, and I can't decide which second game to get. I could have thrown a coin, but that would have been to simple. Quick, GB! You're my only hope!


Post by KillaMaStA (509 posts) See mini bio
410 ACH / 6600 P

Loading...
I think metal gear is something you need to play, LBP you can watch from youtube. I liked both a whole lot though.


Post by Ineedaname (1,907 posts) See mini bio
406 ACH / 4515 P

Loading...

Online Now

MGS, as the dude with the creative name above me said, you can watch alot of LBP and get an idea for it, although the create a level is pretty cool, but be warned you have to be prepared for cut scene after cut scene in MGS, however I feel that's more of a game than LBP, LBP was fun but still, and I got bored of it after a while.


Post by shadows_kill (1,839 posts) See mini bio
126 ACH / 1645 P

Loading...
since your wanting mgs4 im guessing you have played the other ones and know the story. if you havent then i think you should go for lbp because mgs is very story driven and if you dont know it then i dont think you will like it as much.


Post by get2sammyb (4,191 posts) See mini bio
46 ACH / 725 P

Loading...
You should really, really get both. But go with Metal Gear first and then come back for Sackboy.


Post by FLStyle (391 posts) See mini bio
2 ACH / 0 P

Loading...
@KillaMaStA said:
" I think metal gear is something you need to play, LBP you can watch from youtube. I liked both a whole lot though. "
I'll just add to this that when you create a level on LPB it rarely gets played no matter how good it is. Someone will vote it down, it'll fall off the front page and it'll never be played again.


Post by Kohe321 (1,712 posts) See mini bio
474 ACH / 4636 P

Loading...
@get2sammyb said:
" You should really, really get both. But go with Metal Gear first and then come back for Sackboy. "
Agreed


Post by dcpc10 (2,245 posts) See mini bio
139 ACH / 1965 P

Loading...

Online Now

@Kohe321 said:
" @get2sammyb said:
" You should really, really get both. But go with Metal Gear first and then come back for Sackboy. "
Agreed "
Seconded, LBP is a unique expierence, but MGS4 absolutely stunning in ever aspect.


Post by NickM (785 posts) See mini bio
2444 ACH / 50979 P

Loading...
@dcpc10 said:
" @Kohe321 said:
" @get2sammyb said:
" You should really, really get both. But go with Metal Gear first and then come back for Sackboy. "
Agreed "
Seconded, LBP is a unique expierence, but MGS4 absolutely stunning in ever aspect. "
Just got back from the store! The PS3 is being updated right now. I managed to get both, since they were pretty cheap.


Post by Kohe321 (1,712 posts) See mini bio
474 ACH / 4636 P

Loading...
You got two awesome games to keep you occupied this summer, then! Enjoy :D


Post by fugie7 (315 posts) See mini bio
1515 ACH / 28690 P

Loading...
get mgs4


Post by get2sammyb (4,191 posts) See mini bio
46 ACH / 725 P

Loading...
@NickM: Congrats on getting both. Excellent choices. May I also recommend flower and Wipeout HD from the store if you still have some change left in your bank account.

Like Kohe said though, you've just guaranteed yourself an amazing summer.


Post by CL60 (5,731 posts) See mini bio
1752 ACH / 33623 P

Loading...

Online Now

You will love them.


Post by Diamond (4,802 posts) See mini bio
2748 ACH / 51430 P

Loading...

Online Now

I love LBP too, but I voted MGS4.


Post by TheJollyRajah (922 posts) See mini bio
191 ACH / 2795 P

Loading...
Woo have fun!


Post by Matthew (629 posts) See mini bio
195 ACH / 2205 P

Loading...
Good points above and all.  I do have both games, but the thing is are you a social gamer?  Meaning, do you have people coming over, and maybe just start some Rock Band or something?  Because maybe a fellow person who does games for a hobby can get into you playing MGS4, but the normal people out there will be able to actually partake in LBP.  And get a laugh out of it.


Post by angelkanarias (929 posts) See mini bio
278 ACH / 2525 P

Loading...

Online Now

LBP is good, but, MGS is over the line.


Post by NickM (785 posts) See mini bio
2444 ACH / 50979 P

Loading...
Thanks for all replies guys, but you didn't have to give me advice. I know what both the games are about. I just needed to pick one randomly, so I decided to get the one that has the most support from my Giant Bomb homies :) 

Well, thanks anyway! Hopefully I'll make a blog post about the PS3 and all the stuff I bought during last week.


Post by Akeldama (1,980 posts) See mini bio
974 ACH / 13645 P

Loading...
have you played the other metal gear games?


Post by Out_On_Bail (1,247 posts) See mini bio
1243 ACH / 21602 P

Loading...

Online Now

Honestly, you should get both.  I voted MGS4 - but in the end you'll be happy with both games.  They are so different, yet so fun.  You can't go wrong either way really.  And they've both been out long enough to where you might be able to get them both used.  Although I'm not sure how much you'd save by doing that. 

EDIT- and then I scrolled up and noticed you took my advice 8 hours before I gave it. Impressive. ;-)


Post by KingBroly (587 posts) See mini bio
2131 ACH / 38910 P

Loading...
Metal Gear Solid 4

It's a longer game with lots of free DLC via the in-game menu and it costs $30 while LBP costs $60.


Post by Snail (3,626 posts) See mini bio
533 ACH / 6160 P

Loading...
LittleBIGPlanet.


Post by Snail (3,626 posts) See mini bio
533 ACH / 6160 P

Loading...
LittleBIGPlanet.

@KingBroly said:
" Metal Gear Solid 4

It's a longer game with lots of free DLC via the in-game menu and it costs $30 while LBP costs $60."
What the fuck are you talking about?
We're talking about MGS4, not MGSO.


Post by Subject2Change (1,180 posts) See mini bio
750 ACH / 6810 P

Loading...
MGS4; not a huge fan of LBP personally.


Post by NickM (785 posts) See mini bio
2444 ACH / 50979 P

Loading...
Oh, by the way, feel free to add me as a friend, my PSN tag is: SgtMacBadass. We'll play some killzone, lbp or wipeout sometime. see you online!


Post by c1337us (2,570 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
LittleBigPlanet is pretty good, but it isnt nearly as good as Metal Gear.


Post by SJSchmidt93 (1,794 posts) See mini bio
1306 ACH / 13125 P

Loading...
Both good. MGS4 is better, however.

@Snail said:
" LittleBIGPlanet.

@KingBroly said:
" Metal Gear Solid 4

It's a longer game with lots of free DLC via the in-game menu and it costs $30 while LBP costs $60."
What the fuck are you talking about?We're talking about MGS4, not MGSO. "
There the same fucking game are they not? Just because MGO has it's own start screen doesn't mean anything. They're both on the disc. Plus, MGS4 has plenty of DLC too. Pointless DLC, sure, like music and camouflage, but it still has it.

I didn't like MGO, but that comes from a console online shooter hater.


Post by chililili (639 posts) See mini bio
724 ACH / 9390 P

Loading...
Both are very nice, but I find it much much better to play MGS4.


Post by EVO (420 posts) See mini bio
320 ACH / 3975 P

Loading...
@NickM said:
"I managed to get both."
Awesome. Next up: Uncharted.