Nintendo has won this generation well beyond console sales.

Topic started by oldschool on June 5, 2009. Last post by AgentJ 5 months, 2 weeks ago.
Post by HandsomeDead (5,262 posts) See mini bio
1424 ACH / 27465 P

Loading...
It's threads like this that really make me hate Nintendo.


Post by CrossTheAtlantic (25 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
Um, I like all the systems? And am generally just a fan of games. You know, I play what sounds fun and/or interesting regardless of some arbitrary competition which will all be reset in a few years anyways.

So, uh, what line do I get in?


Post by oldschool (4,468 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@ArbitraryWater said:
" I don't agree with you, but I will not bother to argue because you have made your opinion about how awesome you think Nintendo is painfully clear, and if I use the "doesn't have many good games" argument you or Al3xand3r will be more than willing to show me a list of obscure 3rd party titles that I have never heard of to prove your point. I got tired of debating after an unfortunate PM exchange around the subject of video game boobs. So please continue with whatever kind of ire you are trying to inspire in this topic. "
It is kind of sad you feel that way.  I jsut ask questions rather than argue.  I find that more satisfying. 

I think you oversell my point on Nintendo being awesome though.  I think games are awesome, sm e more than others.  I just see the value of Nintendo but do not remove the value of having Microsoft and Sony - competition.  

If anyone sees me as a fanboy, then it is simply to activate their own view at the expense of mine.

@rateoforange said:
" Many of your oldschool's points are salient (if not original), but what he fails to appreciate is how the concept of 'winning and losing' a generation is obsolete. The Wii's blue ocean strategy created a new customer base rather than attempting to cannibalize a competitor's customer base. The market moved from zero-sum to non-zero-sum. In a non-zero sum game, there may be multiple winners and losers. "
I could just flippantly say that your comment is 'loser talk', but I won't [or I suppose I did  :-) ] 

You see my use of the word 'winner' andl'loser' (i don't think I used that word) too literally.  Winner simply means sales.  It is a non personal term, just a statistical one.  It is a bit like saying Nintendo lost the last gen, yet was the most profitable.  It is the only profitable one this gen so far.  You stray too far from my point.

It is amusing though that fans of Sony or Microdoft have rewritten the rules on the words winner and loser.  They had to.  Old definitions no longer suited them.  They were wrong to iuse them that way in the first place.


Post by Bigandtasty (1,336 posts) See mini bio
716 ACH / 15135 P

Loading...
@CronoXtream said:
" Nintendo=EPIC FAIL "
Now there's a compelling argument.

Anyway this blog isn't always agreeable but it has a point: Nintendo did something right that other companies are trying to emulate, and it won this generation ("winning" meaning sales and profit) handily. The interesting question is whether or not they'll retain their lead.


Post by Pibo47 (1,737 posts) See mini bio
3095 ACH / 62245 P

Loading...
@CronoXtream said:
" Nintendo=EPIC FAIL "
I agree, after the N64...i just dont know what they have done to themselves.


Post by oldschool (4,468 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@HandsomeDead said:
" It's threads like this that really make me hate Nintendo. "
Why?  Does their success bother you that much?

@CrossTheAtlantic said:
" Um, I like all the systems? And am generally just a fan of games. You know, I play what sounds fun and/or interesting regardless of some arbitrary competition which will all be reset in a few years anyways.

So, uh, what line do I get in?"
And so am I.  It is the most sensible place to reside.  We are in the same line, so we can chat there  :-)

However, not everyone can afford all 3 systems, so choices will be made.  The ones who argue the most are usually those he feel they have to justify their decision (not always).  I also enjoy my iMac for PC gaming and truly love the DS the most of all consoles.  They all offer strengths.  The blog isn't about that though.  It is about the impact Nintendo have had on the market and its competitors as displayed at E3.




Post by Lowbrow (432 posts) See mini bio
498 ACH / 10285 P

Loading...
Nintendo didn't really win over this generation in my view. They managed to market to and capture an audience who previously did not play games.


Post by oldschool (4,468 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@Bigandtasty said:
"@CronoXtream said: 
" Nintendo=EPIC FAIL "
Now there's a compelling argument.

Anyway this blog isn't always agreeable but it has a point: Nintendo did something right that other companies are trying to emulate, and it won this generation ("winning" meaning sales and profit) handily. The interesting question is whether or not they'll retain their lead."
In this generation, I can see the lead cut a little towards the end of the cycle, but it will still have a comfortable lead.  As for any point on next gen, I have my point clear that I am not confidant of 2 generations success in a row.  What they did this time, they did very well.  Rpeating it?  I doubt it.  It is no easy task to capture the imagination of the public 2 times in a row.


Post by oldschool (4,468 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@Lowbrow said:
" Nintendo didn't really win over this generation in my view. They managed to market to and capture an audience who previously did not play games. "
I'm sorry?  How is that not winning?


Post by Vinchenzo (3,874 posts) See mini bio
4921 ACH / 120025 P

Loading...
They dragged in a ton of gullible people. To me it's still a gimmick and I'm dissapointed in Sony and Microsoft for not seeing that. While we can't avoid the fact it sells systems (at least the Wii), that doesn't mean the implementation was successful. Almost the entire Wii collection might use motion control, but to no real extent. Waggle the controller? No thanks. If anything Nintendo had amazing timing for the weight-loss games. Everybody wants to lose weight and Nintendo is releasing all the right stuff. Even I sort of want my Wii back to try EA Active.


Post by puck2dag (9 posts) See mini bio
1354 ACH / 28561 P

Loading...
Nintendo makes me cry


Post by oldschool (4,468 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@Vinchenzo said:
" They dragged in a ton of gullible people. To me it's still a gimmick and I'm dissapointed in Sony and Microsoft for not seeing that. While we can't avoid the fact it sells systems (at least the Wii), that doesn't mean the implementation was successful. Almost the entire Wii collection might use motion control, but to no real extent. Waggle the controller? No thanks. If anything Nintendo had amazing timing for the weight-loss games. Everybody wants to lose weight and Nintendo is releasing all the right stuff. Even I sort of want my Wii back to try EA Active. "
I am curious.  Am I a gullible person?

Why would you assume that everyone feels like you.  The first real game I got for the console was Zelda.  I was stunned at how natural it felt.  Controlling was an extension of y arm.  Then I got some shooting action in Metroid and every other shooting game feels inferior after using the Wiimote.  You say gimmick, others say successful controller.  Every time I paly my 360, I constantly pine for the Wiimote to be controlling the game (especially Bioshock).

It is the subtlety in many cases that makes the Wiiote so good.  Sure, lazy developers are shit at implementation, but that is no different to what happened with the DS.  Games are not always perfect with a standard controller either.


Post by DonPixel (40 posts) See mini bio
495 ACH / 8107 P

Loading...
This is the kind of Shit Post that made me leave gamespot an other shitty forums.. where the hell are the moderators?! , this is clearly a provocation to irrational fanboysm..


Post by HandsomeDead (5,262 posts) See mini bio
1424 ACH / 27465 P

Loading...
@oldschool said:
"
@HandsomeDead said:
" It's threads like this that really make me hate Nintendo. "
Why?  Does their success bother you that much?

@CrossTheAtlantic said:
" Um, I like all the systems? And am generally just a fan of games. You know, I play what sounds fun and/or interesting regardless of some arbitrary competition which will all be reset in a few years anyways.

So, uh, what line do I get in?"
And so am I.  It is the most sensible place to reside.  We are in the same line, so we can chat there  :-)

However, not everyone can afford all 3 systems, so choices will be made.  The ones who argue the most are usually those he feel they have to justify their decision (not always).  I also enjoy my iMac for PC gaming and truly love the DS the most of all consoles.  They all offer strengths.  The blog isn't about that though.  It is about the impact Nintendo have had on the market and its competitors as displayed at E3.


"
It has nothing to do with their success, it's your attitude. In fact, if it's anything to do with Nintendo's success, it's that their success breeds insufferable sycophants who can see the light where the rest of us can't and won't shut up about it.


Post by Lowbrow (432 posts) See mini bio
498 ACH / 10285 P

Loading...
@oldschool:

Sorry, I really didn't clarify on this one.

I'm not going to sit here and argue numbers. Obviously at this point Nintendo has enough money to start their own fucking country. They are ultra rich, this I can't argue.

Its not that the console doesn't have any good games, but direction it has taken, the incredible amount of shovelware it's put out... It just seems like this isn't a console for me at all.

I think you'll find people of a similar opinion who love video games and love Nintendo.

They may have won in terms of profits, but they haven't won me over, I'm sure the same is also true for more than just a few of us.




Post by oldschool (4,468 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@DonPixel said:
" This is the kind of Shit Post that made me leave gamespot an other shitty forums.. where the hell are the moderators?! , this is clearly a provocation to irrational fanboysm.. "
Really?  So an analytical dissection of the current state of the console marketplace is fanboyism is it?

Here's a challenge for you.  Find anything in the OP, or anywhere else I have posted on this thread, that criticises Sony or Microsoft other than accepting the reality that they have followed Nintendo.  Get back to me when you find it.


Post by The_A_Drain (3,216 posts) See mini bio
2301 ACH / 51325 P

Loading...
"The first real game I got for the console was Zelda.  I was stunned at how natural it felt.  Controlling was an extension of y arm."

I'm sorry, I love my Wii, and it has some great games on it. But this is complete bullshit. It feels anything but natural, and it a literal replacement for simply pressing a button. If the game were built ground up for the Wii, it would have been different, but all they did for TP was replace a button press with a waggle, and it doesn't even have to be a remotely precise waggle either.

I'm sorry, I just can't take anybody who considers Twilight Princess' combat controls 'natural' seriously.

There is still plenty of profit to be made by all, and given the global recession, I don't tink it prudent to think about te next generation of consoles just yet, Sony and MS have said they have no plans for a new console, and Nintendo have absolutely no reason to build another yet, it would only lose them customers that they have gained with the Wii. It's the gamer in you wanting another upgrade, the casual market the Wii has swept up in the nets by the tonne on the other hand do not look kindly on having to upgrade. Yet, weirdly, they'll buy peripherals by the bucket load.


Post by rateoforange (178 posts) See mini bio
610 ACH / 9422 P

Loading...
Let's try some basic analogy: trying to compare the Wii to the 360/PS3 is like trying to stage a hotdog eating contest between Michael Phelps and Lance Armstrong.


Post by oldschool (4,468 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@HandsomeDead said:
"@oldschool said: 
"@HandsomeDead said: 
" It's threads like this that really make me hate Nintendo. "
Why?  Does their success bother you that much?

@CrossTheAtlantic said:
" Um, I like all the systems? And am generally just a fan of games. You know, I play what sounds fun and/or interesting regardless of some arbitrary competition which will all be reset in a few years anyways.

So, uh, what line do I get in?"
And so am I.  It is the most sensible place to reside.  We are in the same line, so we can chat there  :-)

However, not everyone can afford all 3 systems, so choices will be made.  The ones who argue the most are usually those he feel they have to justify their decision (not always).  I also enjoy my iMac for PC gaming and truly love the DS the most of all consoles.  They all offer strengths.  The blog isn't about that though.  It is about the impact Nintendo have had on the market and its competitors as displayed at E3."
It has nothing to do with their success, it's your attitude. In fact, if it's anything to do with Nintendo's success, it's that their success breeds insufferable sycophants who can see the light where the rest of us can't and won't shut up about it. "
Nothing infuriates more than success does it Dead?  Sorry to spoil your day with facts and opinions.

Just curious though.  I didn't make value judgements on games ot the consoles themselves, so exactly which parts bother you so much?

@Lowbrow said:
" @oldschool: Sorry, I really didn't clarify on this one.I'm not going to sit here and argue numbers. Obviously at this point Nintendo has enough money to start their own fucking country at this point. They are ultra rich, this I can't argue.Its not that the console doesn't have any good games, but direction it has taken, the incredible amount of shovelware it's put out... It just seems like this isn't a console for me at all. I think you'll find people of a similar opinion who love video games and love Nintendo.They may have won in terms of profits, but they haven't won me over, I'm sure the same is also true for more than just a few of us. "
It is true for a lot of people.  It would be foolish to deny that.  I am not going to argue on that point.  Like anything, there will always be those that don't see the enjoyment others get.  It doesn't bother me that you don't like it.

Again, it is about sales and direction of the followers.  No value judgements.  The value judgements are made by those who my points do not suit.


Post by DonPixel (40 posts) See mini bio
495 ACH / 8107 P

Loading...
@oldschool said:
"
@DonPixel said:
" This is the kind of Shit Post that made me leave gamespot an other shitty forums.. where the hell are the moderators?! , this is clearly a provocation to irrational fanboysm.. "
Really?  So an analytical dissection of the current state of the console marketplace is fanboyism is it?

Here's a challenge for you.  Find anything in the OP, or anywhere else I have posted on this thread, that criticises Sony or Microsoft other than accepting the reality that they have followed Nintendo.  Get back to me when you find it.
"

Give me a break..  you said something that has being said like a zillion times allready.. plus you made your post so damm anoying with all those ridicoulous over statments speaking of truth you are clearly not giving a chance for discussion, that`s provocation. Discussion starts with an open mind and a disposition to hear other "truths" and negotiate them...

There`s no much point to discuss with someone who comes with "enlighted truth" ... that would be like trying to argue with a Nazi or a Religious Fanatic.. what`s the point ? would they lissen...? nooooo


Post by rateoforange (178 posts) See mini bio
610 ACH / 9422 P

Loading...
Oh, before I get back to work:

"Nintendo has won this generation well beyond console sales."

Then, later:

"Winner simply means sales."

I haven't seen a retreat like that since Napoleon invaded Russia.


Post by oldschool (4,468 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@The_A_Drain said:
" "The first real game I got for the console was Zelda.  I was stunned at how natural it felt.  Controlling was an extension of y arm."I'm sorry, I love my Wii, and it has some great games on it. But this is complete bullshit. It feels anything but natural, and it a literal replacement for simply pressing a button. If the game were built ground up for the Wii, it would have been different, but all they did for TP was replace a button press with a waggle, and it doesn't even have to be a remotely precise waggle either.I'm sorry, I just can't take anybody who considers Twilight Princess' combat controls 'natural' seriously.There is still plenty of profit to be made by all, and given the global recession, I don't tink it prudent to think about te next generation of consoles just yet, Sony and MS have said they have no plans for a new console, and Nintendo have absolutely no reason to build another yet, it would only lose them customers that they have gained with the Wii. It's the gamer in you wanting another upgrade, the casual market the Wii has swept up in the nets by the tonne on the other hand do not look kindly on having to upgrade. Yet, weirdly, they'll buy peripherals by the bucket load. "
Just because you don't find it natural and I do, doesn't make it bullshit.

What made it totally natural was the fact that I didn't even think about what I was doing - I was just doing it.  Simple, fluid and natural.  


Post by HandsomeDead (5,262 posts) See mini bio
1424 ACH / 27465 P

Loading...
@oldschool said:
"
@HandsomeDead said:
"@oldschool said: 
"@HandsomeDead said: 
" It's threads like this that really make me hate Nintendo. "
Why?  Does their success bother you that much?

@CrossTheAtlantic said:
" Um, I like all the systems? And am generally just a fan of games. You know, I play what sounds fun and/or interesting regardless of some arbitrary competition which will all be reset in a few years anyways.

So, uh, what line do I get in?"
And so am I.  It is the most sensible place to reside.  We are in the same line, so we can chat there  :-)

However, not everyone can afford all 3 systems, so choices will be made.  The ones who argue the most are usually those he feel they have to justify their decision (not always).  I also enjoy my iMac for PC gaming and truly love the DS the most of all consoles.  They all offer strengths.  The blog isn't about that though.  It is about the impact Nintendo have had on the market and its competitors as displayed at E3."
It has nothing to do with their success, it's your attitude. In fact, if it's anything to do with Nintendo's success, it's that their success breeds insufferable sycophants who can see the light where the rest of us can't and won't shut up about it. "
Nothing infuriates more than success does it Dead?  Sorry to spoil your day with facts and opinions.

Just curious though.  I didn't make value judgements on games ot the consoles themselves, so exactly which parts bother you so much?

@Lowbrow said:
" @oldschool: Sorry, I really didn't clarify on this one.I'm not going to sit here and argue numbers. Obviously at this point Nintendo has enough money to start their own fucking country at this point. They are ultra rich, this I can't argue.Its not that the console doesn't have any good games, but direction it has taken, the incredible amount of shovelware it's put out... It just seems like this isn't a console for me at all. I think you'll find people of a similar opinion who love video games and love Nintendo.They may have won in terms of profits, but they haven't won me over, I'm sure the same is also true for more than just a few of us. "
It is true for a lot of people.  It would be foolish to deny that.  I am not going to argue on that point.  Like anything, there will always be those that don't see the enjoyment others get.  It doesn't bother me that you don't like it.

Again, it is about sales and direction of the followers.  No value judgements.  The value judgements are made by those who my points do not suit.
"
Success is great. Holier than thou opinions from holier than thou posters are not though. No one asked you to make a thread like this where you basically brag about Nintendo's success on their behalf and no one is really interested in seeing it either.


Post by The_A_Drain (3,216 posts) See mini bio
2301 ACH / 51325 P

Loading...
@oldschool:

Well whatever, there's fuck all difference between that and a button press, you don't think any more or less... Except for the part where you can't always get a forward trust when you want it, and the extra time delay added onto attacks having to be adjusted for consciously. Either you never played a videogame before, or you're playing a different version of TP from the rest of the planet if you seriously think it feels 'completely natural'

Other games and I might be in agreement, or I might not, depends on the game. But Twilight Princess? Your out of your gourd.


Post by oldschool (4,468 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@rateoforange said:
" Oh, before I get back to work:"Nintendo has won this generation well beyond console sales."Then, later:"Winner simply means sales."I haven't seen a retreat like that since Napoleon invaded Russia. "
Seriously?  You can't see them are seperate and different points?   Copying two seperate points and somehow connecting them is a failure in logic 101.  Let me spell it out for you:

It is a winner in sales.  Simple.  Winner in the context of someone arguing that it didn't or isn't winning is refuted by the fact that sales say it is the winner.

Winning beyond console sales is another point whereby the competitors capitualing, simply copy and follow Nintendo.  The mark Nintendo has left on this generation is only now becoming apparent due to announcements at E3.  That is how it goes beyond and transcends sales alone.


Post by The_A_Drain (3,216 posts) See mini bio
2301 ACH / 51325 P

Loading...
@oldschool:

You can't have two contradictory statements that cover all bases and ward of all reciprocation. That's not how an argument works. Either sales dictate the winner, or they don't They can't dictate the winner, and have your argument based on more than sales.

At least with sales you can argue hard facts and figures, and noone would disagree (in their right minds) But the rest is just opinion and conjecture, yet you peddle them as if they were fact anyway.


Post by Al3xand3r (7,080 posts) See mini bio

Loading...

Online Now

You make no sense Drain. He said they won in sales, and that's a clear fact. Then he goes on to say he believes they win in more than sales (and in the first post makes it very clear it's his opinion) and bases that on other facts and how they can be interpreted, like the very recent E3. But it's still his opinion and he doesn't try to force it as a fact, though simply "no u suk and nintendo sux" as he has been getting in return isn't enough I'm afraid. You can have a different opinion yourself, but that doesn't make his any less valid, so try and discuss rationally if at all.


Post by oldschool (4,468 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@HandsomeDead said:
Success is great. Holier than thou opinions from holier than thou posters are not though. No one asked you to make a thread like this where you basically brag about Nintendo's success on their behalf and no one is really interested in seeing it either. "
Someone needs a hug  :-)

Just in case you were not aware of it Dead, the internet is full of people posting opinions and people agreeing and disagreeing.  I take comfort in the fact that you would spend your time simply trying to shoot the messenger  ;-)

@DonPixel said:
"Give me a break..  you said something that has being said like a zillion times allready.. plus you made your post so damm anoying with all those ridicoulous over statments speaking of truth you are clearly not giving a chance for discussion, that`s provocation. Discussion starts with an open mind and a disposition to hear other "truths" and negotiate them...There`s no much point to discuss with someone who comes with "enlighted truth" ... that would be like trying to argue with a Nazi or a Religious Fanatic.. what`s the point ? would they lissen...? nooooo "
A zillion times?  So, there have been a zillion threads and posts about the impact of Nintendo as diplayed by the new direction of Sony and Microsoft following E3?  Enjoy our party with Dead going for the messenger rather than the message.

When you want to tell me which parts are wrong, come back.  Just for you I will repeat the 2 points again though:
  • The Wii has won the sales of consoles this generation
  • The Wii's influence transcends it sales success by the legacy it leaves behind with the 2 comptitors following them.


Post by francesthemule (69 posts) See mini bio
695 ACH / 12100 P

Loading...
Nintendo is like an friend I've known for my whole life, had our ups and downs, but remained close.
And then one day I came over and Nintendo's trying to hookup with my Mom!
Friendship Over!!!


Post by CrossTheAtlantic (25 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
So have you guys seen Metroid: Other M? Looks pretty sweet, right?