Not taking into account Jeff's opinion/review, almost everyone else seemed extremely disappointed with that game. Alex, Brad, Patrick, Vinny (I think) all came away with a middling response. Honestly, even Jeff didn't sound super enthused when reviewing/talking about it (he sounded more enthused when talking about SR4, and he gave that a lower score).
Which is why I ask, could this possibly be their most disappointing game of 2013 (assuming they have that award this year)? Ass Creed 3 was given a 4/5 and still came away with it. Honestly, I don't think the review score is a major factor anyway. The overall consensus given by the team seemed to be middling, and since it had a huge amount of hype around it, that leads me to believe this is a possibility