• 99 results
  • 1
  • 2
#1 Posted by nohthink (1370 posts) -
#2 Posted by nohthink (1370 posts) -

So I had a "debate" with my friend over this. I believe Whopper is waaaay better than BIg Mac. I like the artificial grill flavor. But my friend says Big Mac sauce is incomparably better. So I turn to you guys!! What do you guys think? Which one is better?

#3 Posted by Phatmac (5919 posts) -

Dude really? The Whopper is way better.

#4 Posted by RE_Player1 (7946 posts) -

Big Mac all day every day baby.

#5 Posted by Baillie (4584 posts) -

I prefer the meat on the Whopper, but Big Macs are overall better tasting I think. Burger King's burgers are just too dry to fully enjoy.

#6 Posted by Rafaelfc (1779 posts) -

This is a no brainer, Big Mac all the way.

#7 Edited by Jams (3043 posts) -

Fuck all those places. Carl's Jr. is the best (though In & Out is equally the best! YES BOTH).

Edit for Super Star with Cheese or Double Double with onions and cheese.

#8 Posted by devilzrule27 (1241 posts) -

Give me a double quarter pounder over any of those options.

#9 Posted by _Chad (999 posts) -

Whopper. The Big Mac is fucking tiny nowadays.

#10 Posted by Strife777 (1730 posts) -

I've only been to Burger King once and I remember the Whopper not tasting much, same for Wendy's. I admit it was a long time ago, I need to go there again. So for now I say Big Mac but also... A&W;! That place makes some tasty burgers.

#11 Posted by StarvingGamer (9078 posts) -

Big Mac, but that might be a lot of my childhood talking. I don't eat either though since they're a rip-off. Dollar Menu all the way!

#12 Posted by Ravenlight (8057 posts) -
@Jams said:

Fuck all those places. Carl's Jr. is the best (though In & Out is equally the best! YES BOTH).

Edit for Super Star with Cheese or Double Double with onions and cheese.

This man speaks truth. Amen!
#13 Posted by ShadowConqueror (3279 posts) -

I don't think I've ever had a Big Mac (the extra bun seems excessive), so I guess Whopper. Really though, Wendy's.

#14 Posted by laserbolts (5444 posts) -

I'll take the Baconator over a Big Mac or Whopper anyday. I don't even like Whoppers to the point that if someone gave me one I wouldn't eat it.

#15 Edited by Happenstance (491 posts) -

Dont like either the Big Mac or the Whopper but its definitely Burger King over Macdonalds for me.

#16 Posted by NakAttack (1329 posts) -

fucking fiveguys burger.

#17 Posted by thedj93 (1260 posts) -

fuckin whopper bro, it fits in your hands like a real burger should. shit is like the whole dinner plate and shit gotdamn is this even a question

#18 Posted by Labman (295 posts) -

Shoot! I clicked Big Mac by mistake, but I definitely like the Whopper better. Actually, the Double Whopper with cheese and no pickles...yeah, that's the stuff!

#19 Posted by Hunkulese (2968 posts) -

I think the Big Mac does a better job of covering up the taste of the disgusting burger than the Whopper does but I voted for Wendy's.

#20 Posted by Subject2Change (2971 posts) -

None, no more fast food for me unless I am super drunk and it's White Castle.

#21 Posted by Superkenon (1556 posts) -

Those aren't burgers, son!!

#22 Posted by localhost (21 posts) -

Le Big Mac. Every time.

#23 Posted by TheSouthernDandy (4011 posts) -

Whopper, son. Only thing I get at McDonald's is double cheeseburgers. 2 for under 5 bucks. Bananas!

#24 Posted by living4theday258 (692 posts) -

you forgot the thick burger...........

#25 Posted by LordXavierBritish (6652 posts) -


#26 Posted by Landon (4134 posts) -

The Whopper doesn't have Big Mac sauce, so... yeeeaahh....

#27 Posted by Maajin (1142 posts) -

I'll go for a Stacker.

#28 Posted by Silvergun (298 posts) -

As far as fast food burgers go, I think Carls Jr. is definately the best. Western Bacon Cheeseburgers are amazing (they're huge, and there is a Double Western Bacon Cheeseburger!). If it's down to Big Mac vs. Whopper though, it's Big Mac all the way.

Nothing compares to home made though. I use a mix of 2/3 lean ground beef and 1/3 breakfast sausage in my patties, top them with sharp cheddar, diced white onion and light bbq sauce (mostly to get the onions to stick) and served on a sliced sourdough roll with shallot butter. They're incredible.

#29 Posted by mbr2 (590 posts) -

@Baillie said:

I prefer the meat on the Whopper, but Big Macs are overall better tasting I think. Burger King's burgers are just too dry to fully enjoy.

The only thing that has any distinct taste in McDonalds burgers is the sauce so I have no idea what your talking about. Dry? I've had a couple (one just last week) dry burgers at McDonalds (not to mention them being grey slabs of 'unspecified animal product') While BK has really flavorful grilled pieces of meat with a surface that looks like it has actually been introduced to heat, good sauces and a surprising amount of fresh salad and big tomato slices something which I find McDonalds lacks.

#30 Posted by SomeDeliCook (2353 posts) -

I really wish people would stop putting in extra options in polls. The thread title is about big macs and whoppers, and yet theres 2 other options to pick from. I'd rather see results for which one of the two is better, not a stupid third choice

#31 Posted by Hyuzen (537 posts) -

I'm 20 and I've never eaten a Big Mac or Whopper, but if I had to choose I'd probably go with the Big Mac, the one time I've had Burger King had meh tasting food, and it left me feeling a little ill.

#32 Posted by Imsorrymsjackson (866 posts) -

Big Macs are really bad and if you like them you are a idiot.

#33 Posted by wewantsthering (1652 posts) -


#34 Posted by DrDarkStryfe (1281 posts) -

Big Mac isn't even the best burger at Mickey D's.

Whopper all day, every day, and twice on Wednesday's.

#35 Posted by procrasturbate (297 posts) -

Whopper all the way bro. No cheese. Extra pickle. Extra mayo. Side of small fries, large onion rings and Fanta orange softdrink.

#36 Posted by Ben_H (3617 posts) -

Whopper with no mayo. I don't eat Big Macs and only eat BK in a fast food emergency (IE nothing else is around or open). I usually just get a double cheese burger if I get BK. 
A&W over both those options.

#37 Posted by crusader8463 (14744 posts) -

Was never a fan of the Whooper, I love me a Wendy's Baconator but it's one of those things I only want from time to time and I don't really care for anything on the KFC menu. So I voted Big Mac as I just ate one after work today and can consistently eat them more so then the other choices. But as a if I could only eat one for the rest of my life sort of deal, I would go with the Wendy's Baconator.

#38 Posted by Kidavenger (3879 posts) -

@Hyuzen said:

I'm 20 and I've never eaten a Big Mac

I've never had a Big Mac either...

of the poll choices, Wendy's is the best and I used to love it when I did fast food, but fast food burgers overall I think Five guys is the king now.

#39 Posted by NlGHTCRAWLER (1219 posts) -

@wewantsthering said:


{Pretty much this.

#40 Posted by Ghostiet (5587 posts) -

Wendy's bitch. Or even better - Five Guys.

#41 Posted by Nightriff (6312 posts) -

Both are really good but I actually get a Whopper more often than not.

#42 Posted by No0b0rAmA (1511 posts) -

Not even a contest. KFC.

#43 Posted by RenegadeDoppelganger (441 posts) -

Wendy's takes it for me, meat is better, toppings are better and I like the even like the way it comes apart after 2 bites. Big Mac has the edge on sauce, not a huge Whopper fan.

A couple friends and I went to a burger king once around the time the new King Kong movie came out. When we pulled up to order we discovered that Burger King was doing a promotion where they were offering a triple whopper or ' The Kong Burger'.

Kong. Burger. When it finally came time for me to order I was only able get out the words "Hi, I'd like the Kong bu" before the entire car erupted in hysterical laughter. I tried to in vain complete my order but I was laughing so hard I couldn't even utter the words and eventually my buddy who was driving simply had to drive away in embarrassment. We left without even pulling up to pay or get our food.

One of the dumbest and inexplicably funniest moments of my life.

#44 Posted by believer258 (12795 posts) -

Hardee's Thickburgers.

I'll race y'all to a heart attack!

#45 Posted by GodlyOne (153 posts) -

I'd say Whopper but in an ideal world, the correct answer would be a Big Whopper Mac.

#46 Posted by iam3green (14368 posts) -

big mac is better. i think whopper kind of feels sloppy at least for me.

#47 Posted by BraveToaster (12636 posts) -

Red Robin

#48 Posted by That1BlackGuy (219 posts) -

Between the mac and the whop, I'll definitely go with the whop but I actually prefer BK's $menu bacon burgers, those things are like crack lol.

#49 Posted by Halfdeaf (76 posts) -

I don't see why I would want either. Both are shit and not even real burgers. The poll is missing an option for real food.

On the subject of dry burgers, you are both right. It just depends on how long the burgers have been sitting in the hot box. Both are equally "juicy" straight out of the "broiler" but the the time they spend in the hot box will eventually cause them to to lose all 24 percents of fat they stuff inside it.

#50 Posted by ajamafalous (12439 posts) -

Shit I clicked Big Mac on accident, meant Whopper. 
Either way, though, Whataburger's way better.