It's either your battery or alternator. It can be tough to tell without test equipment. Even though the cold would indicate it must be the battery.
In general (not always), jumping is more likely to help a car with an alternator/voltage regulator (drain/charging) problem (or one where you just left the lights on) than one with a poor battery. So the idea of a bad battery that doesn't respond to jumping is not weird at all.
Some stores will load test your battery for you. You can also do a poor mans (not as good) version of a load test yourself with a volt meter by attaching the volt meter to the battery (be careful!) and measuring the DC voltage when the car is off, on (but not running) and running.
A car with a good battery and good alternator will be 13V or higher at the battery with the car off and on but not running (slightly lower when on but not running) and will be at or above 14.4V when running. It will be a little lower when on but not running than when off.
A car with a bad battery but good alternator will be lower than when the car is on but not running and may even be below 13V when off. The running voltage may be unchanged (14.4V).
A car with a bad alternator will not increase voltage at the battery to 13.8V or higher when the car is running. The other voltages will generally be lower too, but that's really just because the battery isn't getting a charge.
Finally, note that if you run with a bad alternator for weeks, your battery will be permanently damaged too because lead-acid batteries do not like to be left less than fully charged for more than a day or two.
If you can't be bothered to do any testing, then you are rolling the dice. If you roll the dice, just replace the battery. There's an 80% chance given the conditions that this is your battery. Make sure to trade your old battery in, it can cut the cost of the new one in half and with the lead content of car batteries it's difficult to dispose of them legally anyway.
Additional notes: swapping your own battery is often very easy if you can get access to it. It will have clamps bolted to the terminals (Frankenstein-style) and it WILL be bolted down to the car (it is not just sitting in there). Car batteries are very heavy, unless you are in shape you will be tired just from carrying it across a parking lot. If you decide to swap your own battery, check into whether your car radio has anti-theft protection. Many of these radios will deactivate if removed from power and require you to enter some sequence to unlock it. Even if you have a shop change your battery, you likely will have to figure out how to unlock your radio afterwards.
Log in to comment