#1 Posted by OutOfBounds9000 (2513 posts) -

 
I cant decide which game im gonna buy this weekend.These are the games i have in mind: 
 
Mafia II 
Red Dead Redemption 
Madden NFL 11 
all for xbox 
 
and a DS game: 
Picross 3D 
 
So which should i buy?Im not good with hard decisions.Please?

#2 Posted by LordXavierBritish (6652 posts) -

Worms: Reloaded

#3 Posted by EpicBenjamin (669 posts) -

Red Dead Redemption.
Online
#4 Posted by 02sfraser (855 posts) -

Well I haven't played any of them but from reviews Red Dead seems to be the way to go. Open world that you will lose hours to is always a good choice

#5 Posted by mylifeforAiur (3475 posts) -

Picross 3D, that game looks bitchin'

Online
#6 Posted by elko84 (1225 posts) -

all of them!

#7 Posted by Dantekiller (231 posts) -

sir you need some 

#8 Posted by pepsicolagirl (201 posts) -

OH DEAR GOD YOU HAVE TO BUY RED DEAD REDEMPTION

#9 Edited by MysteriousBob (6262 posts) -

A mediocre open world game VS one of the best open world games of all time? Whats to decide? Get RDR.

#10 Posted by dyslekt (287 posts) -

RDR! No contest 
 
GOTY contender 

#11 Posted by Bolthor (88 posts) -

If you haven't played RDR I suggest you check it out.

#12 Posted by MooseyMcMan (11934 posts) -
@pepsicolagirl said:
" OH DEAR GOD YOU HAVE TO BUY RED DEAD REDEMPTION "
This. Well, maybe with some !!!'s for good measure. 
#13 Posted by Drakhir (410 posts) -

Red Dead: Redemption. I haven't played Madden or Picross, but from what I know, RDR will keep you entertained for a longer time. I'd say Mafia II is worth a rent.

#14 Posted by c1337us (5877 posts) -

Fuck Madden. I would probably go Red Dead over Mafia II though.

#15 Posted by FlyingRat (1447 posts) -

I hate to be the one who stands out from the crowd, but i'm gonna have to say Red Dead.

#16 Edited by KaosAngel (14251 posts) -

Mafia II - A game of typical hollywood story but not.  It's like GTA but with better graphics and non-open world, pick from there. 
Red Dead - A game for real Americans looking into how the west was won.  It's like GTA but without cars. 
Madden 11 - The old pigskin, the old American past time.  Can't go wrong with the democracy of football, it's like GTA but without the open world and strictly limited to a football field (note I didn't say pitch).

#17 Posted by MattBosten (511 posts) -

Red Dead Redemption hands down.

#18 Posted by Dirty_Harry (714 posts) -

Dead Dead Dedemption

#19 Posted by foggel (2777 posts) -

You haven't bought RDR yet? Well you should.

#20 Posted by TwoLines (3032 posts) -

Red Dead I guess. I didn't like it, but many people did. So go with that.
Or Picross3D, that game is amazing!

#21 Posted by CaptainObvious (2990 posts) -

Red Dead Redemption. Now.

#22 Posted by Gamer_152 (14281 posts) -

Red Dead Redemption. It's had a great critical reception and I'm certainly enjoying it.

Moderator
#23 Posted by AhmadMetallic (19303 posts) -
@MysteriousBob said:
" A mediocre open world game VS one of the best open world games of all time? Whats to decide? Get RDR. "
pretty much sums it up 
 
 
go get RDR you ass !!!!! WHY HAVENT YOU PLAYED IT YET ?
#24 Posted by Cetra (64 posts) -

If you haven't decided yet, definitely Red Dead Redemption. 

#25 Posted by Shirogane (3593 posts) -

Madden, no question about it! 
 
Seriously, Red Dead is the ONLY choice.
#26 Posted by OutOfBounds9000 (2513 posts) -
@elko84 said:
" all of them! "
Are you dumb?Why the fuck should i waste 150-200 dollars on only games?
#27 Posted by OutOfBounds9000 (2513 posts) -
@Dantekiller said:
" sir you need some  "
AHHHH!!NO,PLEASE!
#28 Posted by Yummylee (23193 posts) -
@EpicBenjamin said:
" Red Dead Redemption. "
#29 Posted by PatrickCrider (31 posts) -
@Dantekiller said:
" sir you need some  "
Don't we all???
#30 Posted by Redbullet685 (6184 posts) -
@pepsicolagirl said:
" OH DEAR GOD YOU HAVE TO BUY RED DEAD REDEMPTION "
#31 Posted by Azteck (7416 posts) -
@MysteriousBob said:
" A mediocre open world game VS one of the best open world games of all time? Whats to decide? Get RDR. "
You mean semi-open world? There's nothing to do in the world of Mafia 2 except driving.
#32 Posted by gla55jAw (2763 posts) -

Madden.

#33 Posted by habster3 (3618 posts) -

Red Dead; you won't regret it!

#34 Posted by Valkyr (742 posts) -

 RDR if you can endure it and beat it in one or two sittings (with the stranger sidequests included), if you don't think you can make it go for Mafia 2 and enjoy a fine 10 hours game till you have more spare time to play RDR.

#35 Posted by Atomasist (2793 posts) -

Picross 3D.

#36 Posted by Ravenousrattler (1420 posts) -

Red dead redemption for sure

#37 Posted by ryoma122 (729 posts) -
@OutOfBounds9000: 
avoid mafia like your life depends on it 
but i would strongly recomend red dead and nfl
#38 Posted by Lemoncookie01 (1663 posts) -

RDR son

#39 Posted by EliminatoR (313 posts) -

RDR is the right answer 
#40 Posted by You (26 posts) -

You don't need any of that junk.  :3

#41 Posted by Berezov (556 posts) -

Red Dead Redemption no contest.

#42 Posted by JJWeatherman (14794 posts) -

Picross. Then Red Dead.

#43 Posted by elko84 (1225 posts) -
@OutOfBounds9000 said:
" @elko84 said:
" all of them! "
Are you dumb?Why the fuck should i waste 150-200 dollars on only games? "
Oh ok, so I guess you only own one game for the rest of your life then.  Cause if you were to ever buy more, you'd have to spend money...you know, on games.
#44 Posted by aproposshadows (185 posts) -

Red dead is great gets a little boring in mexico I need to get back into that game

#45 Posted by Ujio (637 posts) -
@OutOfBounds9000:  RDR
#46 Posted by OutOfBounds9000 (2513 posts) -
@elko84 said:
" @OutOfBounds9000 said:
" @elko84 said:
" all of them! "
Are you dumb?Why the fuck should i waste 150-200 dollars on only games? "
Oh ok, so I guess you only own one game for the rest of your life then.  Cause if you were to ever buy more, you'd have to spend money...you know, on games. "
I was talking about the weekend.Not for the rest of my life.
#47 Posted by ChrisHill (78 posts) -

Red Dead definitely

#48 Posted by Labbo94 (166 posts) -
#49 Edited by Milkman (17833 posts) -

Mafia II - Played the demo. HATED it.
Red Dead Redemption - Haven't played it. Other people like it...a lot.
Madden 11 - Currently playing it. Having a whole lot of fun with it.
Picross 3D - Also haven't played it. But Picross 2D is the shit!