#1 Posted by Jolly_Lolly (3537 posts) -

i like pie better

#2 Posted by Batman (1016 posts) -

Pie, unless it is a chocolate cake with peanut butter icing.

#3 Posted by Oriental_Jams (3063 posts) -

Cake sometimes. Though I really do like pork pie.

#4 Posted by Zoidy (187 posts) -

Cheesecake>>>All

#5 Posted by Kevin (369 posts) -

I'm pretty sure this is the 5th thread covering this.

and pie.

#6 Posted by ExSpectator (10 posts) -

NOBODY RESPOND TO THIS TERRIBLE GAMESPOT-ESQUE THREAD PLEASE.

#7 Posted by Tridgen (120 posts) -

cake FTW!

#8 Posted by Apollo (471 posts) -

Gotta go with the cake.

Its a lie you know...

#9 Posted by Metamorphic (383 posts) -

Fresh pie

#10 Posted by Jolly_Lolly (3537 posts) -
ExSpectator said:
"NOBODY RESPOND TO THIS TERRIBLE GAMESPOT-ESQUE THREAD PLEASE.
"
...what?

look, if you don't like pie it's ok....just don't touch me
#11 Posted by Apollo (471 posts) -
ExSpectator said:
"NOBODY RESPOND TO THIS TERRIBLE GAMESPOT-ESQUE THREAD PLEASE.
"
Yes, because GS is the only place that has Pie vs Cake topics...
#12 Posted by ThaMilkMan (343 posts) -

ok it's simple CAKE =GOOD PIE = OK

Good beats O.K. anyday so Cake wins by default any questions? *Cricket Chirps* didn't think so

#13 Posted by Xelloss (213 posts) -

I like Cake better.

#14 Posted by Jolly_Lolly (3537 posts) -

Tridgen said:
"cake FTW!"
why do you hate me :'(
#15 Posted by Termite (2398 posts) -

Not one of these again...

Pie

#16 Posted by Black_Raven (1759 posts) -

How about a pie fulled with cake?

#17 Posted by Arsenal99 (29 posts) -

cake

#18 Posted by Clean (2356 posts) -

apple pie mmm pie

#19 Posted by Jolly_Lolly (3537 posts) -
Black_Raven said:
"How about a pie fulled with cake?
"
O_O

you, good sir, have just blown my mind
#20 Posted by Apollo (471 posts) -
Black_Raven said:
"How about a pie fulled with cake?
"
Or one of those giant cakes that strippers come in filled with pie...

Thats another reason Cake > Pie. you never get Strippers in a pie.
#21 Posted by henjin (829 posts) -

Cake...Cheesecake..Must I say more?

#22 Posted by TanKLoveR (333 posts) -
Black_Raven said:
"How about a pie fulled with cake?
"
Epic win.
#23 Edited by 111GREEN_RANGER111 (169 posts) -

im goin to go with the awsomeness of the pie filled with cake.  the lies now inside O_o

#24 Posted by hazelnutman (1097 posts) -
Black_Raven said:
"How about a pie fulled with cake?
"
Give this man an internets!
#25 Posted by DaWhiteAsian (230 posts) -

this is a dumb fucking question

#26 Edited by NlGHTCRAWLER (1215 posts) -

@Batman said:

Pie, unless it is a chocolate cake with peanut butter icing.

I also choose Pie.

PS How would I go about stealing this guy's username? It's not like he uses it any more... and what kind of weirdo likes peanut butter icing? I didn't even know that was a thing.

#27 Posted by Godlyawesomeguy (6388 posts) -

Ice cream cake, yo.

#28 Posted by SexualBubblegumX (542 posts) -

I have to say it.... Can I have both cause I'm a fat bastard?

#29 Edited by ComradeKhan (687 posts) -

I like to have my cake... and eat it too. 
 
EDIT: but Pie is of course the real answer to this question (Key Lime to be exact)

#30 Posted by TehJedicake (878 posts) -

Pie kicks cakes ass.

#31 Posted by GloriousDinosaur (433 posts) -

Pie - so many more varieties... aople pie... blackcurrant pie... steak and mushroom pie

#32 Posted by i69edUrGpa (586 posts) -

Big juicy meat pies

#33 Posted by egg (1450 posts) -

Pie is better because it's actual food, cake is not.

#34 Posted by hoossy (932 posts) -

Pie... because pizza pie, and because pecan pie

#35 Posted by Natedogg2 (446 posts) -

Cake. Not a huge fan of pie. Unless it's a chocolate pie.

#36 Posted by devilzrule27 (1239 posts) -

@hoossy said:

Pie... because pizza pie, and because pecan pie

Wait if pizza counts as pie then it's a hands down winner. I'm just gonna pretend it doesnt so therefore all types of cakes are better then any type of pie. Cheese cake, cup cake, pound cake, ice cream cake, white cake, red velvet cake, chocolate cake, fruit cake, pancake, beefcake,

#37 Posted by Bell_End (1208 posts) -

i prefer a flan

#38 Posted by NlGHTCRAWLER (1215 posts) -

@i69edUrGpa said:

Big juicy meat pies

Lemon Pie...

@Bell_End said:

i prefer a flan

Flan? The Dane Cook of desserts?