I'm a Christian and I'm not a fan of Bill, but it was pretty damn funny. If you are looking for a thoughtful documentary, look somewhere else. But if you want a light, comedic, and bias movie , then go for it.
So I Finally Saw Religulous.....
I liked the movie quite a bit. Though I don't agree with some of Bill Maher's more outlandish statements, I think he's a really entertaining guy. I agree with you on the point that had he spoken to less radical Christians he may have gotten the information he was looking for. Or maybe he wasn't looking for any to begin with.
Yea, I'm sure (that I saw it, not that I'm high).
It's hard watching a documentary that doesn't eventually lead to a conclusion or even inform you on anything that you didn't already know; that being said, it was funny at times, despite Good Ol' Bill's Bias. That whole part with the guy in Israel building machines to trick the Sabbath, that was great.
Well the only thing thoughtful in the movie was at the very end, even then it did not actually hammer in a message good enough. Kind of like how Bruno absolutely failed in what it tried to do.
"Haha, that's what I was about to say.@lilburtonboy7489 said:"" If you are looking for a thoughtful documentary, look somewhere else.Are you high? The last statement in that movie is about as serious as it gets. Are you sure you watched the whole thing?
"
"RELIGION MUST DIE."
Doesn't get moar serious business than that.
It was ment to be something that sheds a bit of comedic light on a subject (aka the "organized religion is bullshit" subject.) not thought of or discussed very often in documentaries.
I have a feeling though that the reason why bill interviewed such weird people was only because he couldnt find many devout religious people who were willing to do an interview.
I havent seen this yet, although I want to. I wonder why it seems that more religious people saw this move then not. I figured they would be put off by it.
I thought it was a good movie, because while Bill has a bias, as do we all, he presented it in a pretty practical manner.
It wasn't really until the end where he hammered his message of letting organized religion and blind radicalism heavily influence things, that it should not. (see=govt). And that we can have serious consequences that can arise from such actions.
I also liked his take that it is alright to question documents written thousands of years old verbatim. A concept that he, and I, agree is sheer lunacy.
But he did this all quite eloquently, and I never thought he was being belligerent or combative like other documentaries I've seen. (see=certain scenes in films by Michael Moore.)
To be quite honest: I'm surprised there are not more films like this one. I highly recommend it, and I was incredibly surprised by it.
" I've wanted to see it for a while now but I have a feeling if any of my family found out I watched it they'd be upset. "I wouldnt worry about it, a couple of my christian friends hacve watched it along with me and none of them were offended by it.
Also, if your atheist, you should not care what your family thinks of you, your beliefs (or lack of) are exactly that, YOURS.
" It was ment to be something that sheds a bit of comedic light on a subject (aka the "organized religion is bullshit" subject.) not thought of or discussed very often in documentaries.I have a feeling though that the reason why bill interviewed such weird people was only because he couldnt find many devout religious people who were willing to do an interview. "I think a lot of people would have been willing to do interviews with him. But I think a lot of people would have embarassed Bill. That's probably why he chose retards.
" I've wanted to see it for a while now but I have a feeling if any of my family found out I watched it they'd be upset. "Yea, I know what that's like.
I don't really care for Bill Maher. With that said, I also don't really care for someone who wants to bash on religion just because they don't believe in the same shit. Sure, there are extremists out there, but there is also a vast majority who are good and honest people. My parents are Christians, but they are still awesome people. I can still sit down and watch Zack and Miri Make a Porno with my mom and dad and we'll all laugh our asses off. It's just that now, they say after the film "oh, I'm gonna have to pray after watching that". They still enjoyed it, though.
" I don't really care for Bill Maher. With that said, I also don't really care for someone who wants to bash on religion just because they don't believe in the same shit. Sure, there are extremists out there, but there is also a vast majority who are good and honest people. My parents are Christians, but they are still awesome people. I can still sit down and watch Zack and Miri Make a Porno with my mom and dad and we'll all laugh our asses off. It's just that now, they say after the film "oh, I'm gonna have to pray after watching that". They still enjoyed it, though.You cant have a conversation/documentary/debate about religion without bias, it just doesnt happen. Your either offended by the fact that he bashes religion or not.Therefore, the only thing holding me back from this movie IS the bias."
@lilburtonboy7489 said:
" @Gunner said:The documentary wasnt set up as "LOOK YOUR STUPUID FOR BELEIVING GAWD ALWL", it was just him asking people questions that he didnt really know the answer to to try and get an explanation." It was ment to be something that sheds a bit of comedic light on a subject (aka the "organized religion is bullshit" subject.) not thought of or discussed very often in documentaries.I have a feeling though that the reason why bill interviewed such weird people was only because he couldnt find many devout religious people who were willing to do an interview. "I think a lot of people would have been willing to do interviews with him. But I think a lot of people would have embarassed Bill. That's probably why he chose retards.But that's why I enjoyed the movie. The people he interviewed were funny as hell."
He wasnt really trying to make a fool out of anyone or vice versa as a lot of his interveiws with normal intellegent religious people showed.
Maher interviews a number of intelligent religious people in the movie. The interviews with the Senior Vatican Priest and the Vatican Astronomer answer Maher's questions with prose and rationale. Maher is just asking questions that need answering and in doing so, he exposes alot of idiocy and hypocrisy that permeates religion. But he also shows that there are smart, sensible people in the religious world.
Is it biased? Yes. But it's not set up the way you think. This isn't like that Ben Stein movie about intelligent design. It's not completly one-sided.
I recommend you see it. If it offends you, just close your ears when it talks about your religion, be it Christianity, Evangelism, Catholicism, Judiasm, Orthodox Jews, Muslims, Mormons, or what have you. But there is a message to this movie.
At the very least, it's funny. You get to see some stupid people say stupid shit. And that, at the end of the day, is all the motivation you need to watch.
@lilburtonboy7489 said:He wasn't actually looking for answers. If you want intelligent answers to hard questions, you go a professor, not a trucker church service held in the back of a semi-truck." @Gunner said:The documentary wasnt set up as "LOOK YOUR STUPUID FOR BELEIVING GAWD ALWL", it was just him asking people questions that he didnt really know the answer to to try and get an explanation. He wasnt really trying to make a fool out of anyone or vice versa as a lot of his interveiws with normal intellegent religious people showed. "" It was ment to be something that sheds a bit of comedic light on a subject (aka the "organized religion is bullshit" subject.) not thought of or discussed very often in documentaries.I have a feeling though that the reason why bill interviewed such weird people was only because he couldnt find many devout religious people who were willing to do an interview. "I think a lot of people would have been willing to do interviews with him. But I think a lot of people would have embarassed Bill. That's probably why he chose retards.But that's why I enjoyed the movie. The people he interviewed were funny as hell."
He wasn't actually looking for answers. If you want intelligent answers to hard questions, you go a professor, not a trucker church service held in the back of a semi-truck.This isn't about the professor, this is about the numerous "trucker church services", which do much more damage than anything else. The movie was about the danger of extremism in religion, and the potential of danger it has in our culture. But it wasn't just about the "southern baptist" (David Cross reference).Bill was trying to show how many Christians are so devoted to something they barely understand themselves and can't even begin to defend it. That's true for most. But there are many people who can answer any of his questions, and he didn't interview them. The reason is obvious: He wanted to make an entertaining film. He suceeded. If he would have been looking for serious answers, it would have been a very boring film.With that said, I'm glad he wasn't a militant prick. He was really nice to the people he talked to and asked good questions."
" Haven't seen it yet. As a fan of George Carlin, would anybody recommend this to me? "Well if you're looking for a Carlin type of laugh, you will be disappointed. It's not THAT good.
" @Kajaah117 said:Well, I've always thought that Bill Maher isn't nearly as funny as George, but almost as intelligent. I'll check it out anyway." Haven't seen it yet. As a fan of George Carlin, would anybody recommend this to me? "Well if you're looking for a Carlin type of laugh, you will be disappointed. It's not THAT good. "
I'm not a Christian...in fact I'm pretty much atheist. I loved the movie, you gotta understand I live in the south where NOONE agrees with my beliefs and I can't talk openly to anyone about what I really think about religion, otherwise I'd be offending people and I don't like doing that for no reason. I know plenty of devout Christians and they're mostly nice people so I prefer to avoid the topic as much as possible. I didn't watch the movie to get a laugh, I watched it to feel sane, thinking "yes, there is someone out there who agrees with me."
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment