If you've seen the original, what do you think of this? Do you think they will keep the original plot twist? The trailer sort of implies that he knows who his daughter is, but that might not actually be his real daughter and the other girl in the trailer might be his daughter. A twist for the people who already know the twist, and expect it to be changed or something.
The Old Boy remake has a trailer.
First off I'd spoiler most of that stuff since who knows maybe some people will want to watch the original and it's a shame to ruin it for them.
Second - I don't want to completely write this off from the start, although there is no real reason why it should exist. The main actor doesn't really fit with me, seems too clean, too Hollywoodish. Samuel L Jackson should definitely not be in this at all. Who knows maybe it will be alright, I just don't think it should have been remade at all, but the almighty dollar and all that.
I thought he had one station to watch or it was very limited. Also it does seem like the trailer gave away the whole thing. I really wish this wasn't a thing.
It's funny because Jackson already starred in a recent, shameless DTV knockoff of Old Boy.(Down to the big twist and everything.)
@dallas_raines: What was it called?
I don't think that was a good trailer, but maybe the movie will be OK. The original had such great word of mouth and is easily accessible for American audiences, so it feels a little slimy for there to be an American remake. If you've seen the original, Brolin does not seem anywhere close to as good as Choi Min-sik. But my hope is that they try to do something interesting. That cross on the wall and the bible in the trailer stand out so maybe they will incorporate religious themes or something.
I think it would have been smarter to do a trailer that wasn't a such a hodgepodge of various imagery. Something about it seems a little too "Hollywood". I would love to hear what people who haven't seen the original think about this.
I don't really care that they're remaking the movie. I DO care that it seems to be exactly the same movie, only with white people. I don't really feel comfortable with Spike Lee putting his name on it. It'd be like if I took a Queen song, used different instruments, and claimed I wrote the song.
@aegon said:
@nicked: Yeah, Min-Sik is definitely one of the best actors I've ever seen. It took a while into "I Saw the Devil" before I realized the bad guy was him. I figured it out when I paid attention to his eyes.
MIn-Sik is amazing, he has easily become one of my favorite actors and he was great in I Saw the Devil. My friend and I walked out of that movie and could not stop talking about him and his performance in it and other movies.
I don't see the point of remakes when all they seem to do is recreate the old movie shot for shot. Why not just watch the original at this point?
I enjoy my remakes when they go crazy and try different things. I have way more respect for something like Total Recall, which wasn't great, but at least didn't feel like the exact same thing.
The plot seems slightly altered from the original movie - but at every point of that trailer, I feel like they are missing the point of it. It doesn't have the tone which made the original work so well.
@slashdance said:
I don't see the point of remakes when all they seem to do is recreate the old movie shot for shot. Why not just watch the original at this point?
I enjoy my remakes when they go crazy and try different things. I have way more respect for something like Total Recall, which wasn't great, but at least didn't feel like the exact same thing.
There's a lot of people who simply don't watch movies in other languages, and there are pretty legitimate reasons for that. This just allows those people to experience the story too, nothing wrong with that.
@anothersomebody said:
I never saw the original, so I thought this looked pretty cool. I guess that makes me uncultured or something.
Just watch the original. It's fucking demented.
@andorski said:
Wait, I'm confused. The trailer shows him seeing his daughter grown up giving an interview on TV. Doesn't that completely conflict with how the events unfold throughout the rest of the film? Or is that a trick his capture employs so that he thinks he knows what his daughter looks like?
The latter, I assume. They're mixing in a redemption sub-plot rather than the movie just being about revenge.
@andorski said:
@anothersomebody said:
I never saw the original, so I thought this looked pretty cool. I guess that makes me uncultured or something.
Just watch the original. It's fucking demented.
Or don't, because it's fucking terrible.
OPINIONS
@humanity said:
@dallas_raines: What was it called?
The Samaritan, it's also named Fury in some countries.
It pissed me off. I saw this trailer yesterday.
Mainly because I don't believe good movies need to be remade.
But who knows, maybe it will be good. I mean, they have good actors. Josh Brolin is a good actor- although I always think of Goonies when I see him haha
I don't know. Old Boy is an amazing film.
Edit: Also, I am going to bet they get rid of the "slept with his own daughter" part of the story. This movie looks like it wants a bigger audience so I feel like they may take it out.
OldBoy is my favourite movie. I won't be going to see this. I feel fucking angry that this remake even exists. Leave perfection alone, Trashywood.
I think the trailer was fine. I'm interested to see it solely because Josh Brolin is fucking awesome.
Moreover, while everyone is saying "oh, they are gonna get rid of the original ending where he sleeps with his own daughter," we're talking about Spike Lee. He's never been one to shy away from damn near ANYTHING. Therefore, I can see them keeping it intact.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment