• 101 results
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
#1 Posted by skyline7284 (505 posts) -

So, i've been wondering lately, what is everyone's favorite flavor of Pop Tart? (Toaster Strudel's just aren't the same!)  
My personal Favorite: Frosted Cherry.

#2 Edited by Driadon (2997 posts) -

Strawberry. It used to be smores back in the day, but that's WAY too sweet for me now.

#3 Posted by sopranosfan (1935 posts) -

Apple cinnamon.

#4 Posted by Geno (6477 posts) -

Damn, I haven't hard pop tarts in a long time, gotta get some. Thanks for reminding me. 

#5 Posted by FizzleNizzleBear (335 posts) -


#6 Posted by BillyMethers (149 posts) -

Strawberry is always the best flavor of pop tart. Unless you want a different tone of flavor. Then go for cinnamon.

#7 Posted by RJPelonia (855 posts) -

Strawberry. Definitely strawberry.

#8 Edited by luce (4045 posts) -

Strawberry, Cherry or Blueberry are all awesome. Also spongebob poptarts 
Btw, I've tasted toaster strudels and they should be hanged for making something so blasphemous!

#9 Posted by ZenaxPure (2569 posts) -

Anyone remember those Pokemon pop tarts from a longggggg time ago? Those are my favorite, can't remember what they called the flavors.

#10 Posted by Mikemcn (6980 posts) -

Cookies and Cream


Mixed berry being close second

#11 Posted by Megalon (1392 posts) -

I'm a blueberry man.

#12 Posted by Akeldama (4244 posts) -
@BillyMethers said:
" Strawberry is always the best flavor of pop tart. "
#13 Posted by natetodamax (19191 posts) -

Blueberry is pretty good.

#14 Posted by Assassin_Saint (23 posts) -

S'mores for sure

#15 Posted by Hot_Karl (3309 posts) -

Apple Cinnamon, followed by Strawberry and the S'mores one. 
Do they still have those Oreo Cookies & Cream ones? Those were fucking delish. Sweet as hell, but delicious.

#16 Posted by chstupid (806 posts) -
@RJPelonia said:
"Strawberry. Definitely strawberry. "

#17 Posted by Snail (8594 posts) -

They all suck.

#18 Posted by LaszloKovacs (1141 posts) -

The ones involving chocolate.
The fruity ones taste terrible, I don't know why you guys like 'em so much.

#19 Posted by Whisperkill (2969 posts) -


#20 Edited by HatKing (5882 posts) -

Wildberry.  They are somewhat rare but they are my favorite.  Aside from that it is a four way tie between cherry, strawberry, blueberry,and cinnamon.
#21 Posted by iBePeRFeCT (396 posts) -

Chocolate Chip and Apple Cinnamon.  Eat some for breakfast nearly every morning.

#22 Posted by Grilledcheez (3946 posts) -

Basically any one that has frosting on it.  Strawberry and blueberry mainly :)

#23 Posted by deathstriker666 (1337 posts) -

Pop-tarts taste like shit 
I hate them all

#24 Posted by roofy (1005 posts) -

pop tarts taste chalky, not something i want in the morning (or ever really)
the original is strawberry and its the only one that makes them bearable to eat

#25 Posted by Video_Game_King (36272 posts) -

Strawberry, toasted. None of that "I'll skip the toaster, I'm in a hurry" crap, I'm a Pop Tart Purist!

#26 Posted by Raven_Sword (3444 posts) -

Brown Sugar Cinnamon.
#27 Posted by ThePhantomnaut (6197 posts) -

Strawberry, frosted or not, also not toasted.

#28 Posted by bombHills (632 posts) -

the brown sugar

#29 Posted by Toxin066 (3276 posts) -
@Raven_Sword said:
" Brown Sugar Cinnamon. "
Seriously. I'm surprised it took this long for Brown Sugar to come up in this thread.
#30 Posted by BigBoss1911 (2434 posts) -
@Toxin066 said:
" @Raven_Sword said:
" Brown Sugar Cinnamon. "
Seriously. I'm surprised it took this long for Brown Sugar to come up in this thread. "
agree, my favorite also.
#31 Posted by iam3green (14390 posts) -

s'mors is the best out of them.

#32 Edited by PenguinDust (12491 posts) -
Frosted Strawberry is what I have in my cabinet right now (fav!), and S'mores are okay too.  My 2nd favorite is Frosted Chocolate Fudge.  Those things are like candy!
#33 Posted by Disengage (429 posts) -

Chocolate goddamn Fudge

#34 Posted by HandsomeDead (11863 posts) -

The Cookies and Cream ones I had were really nice. In England, all you can get are Strawberry and Chocolate. So dull.

#35 Edited by Tearhead (2160 posts) -

Cherry. Blueberry is a very close 2nd though.

#36 Posted by fakemeat (110 posts) -

None. Shit's gross.
Pop Tarts are like cardboard filled with/covered in nasty, artificial tasting goo.

#37 Posted by trophyhunter (5800 posts) -

pop tarts are awful and your bad person for liking them

#38 Posted by teh_destroyer (3566 posts) -

Its been almost 4 years since my last pop tart D:. 
Back in the day I liked Unfrosted Strawberry, i would toast it and then put some butter on it, bound to cause a mouth orgasm.

#39 Posted by Bellum (2944 posts) -
@Snail said:
" They all suck.  THERE I SAID IT. "
Yeah. Poptarts aren't exactly great. They're to eat when you don't have time to eat anything better.
If I had to choose, I'd go with chocolate.
#40 Edited by Bigbombomb (677 posts) -

Forget Pop Tarts! (Pillsbury) Toaster Strudels are where its at!

Also, Strawberry frosted and flavored pop tarts my favorite.
#41 Posted by Vinchenzo (6192 posts) -

Chocolate fudge, but I haven't had Pop Tarts in a long time. Don't plan on eating them anytime soon, either.

#42 Posted by GamerGeek360 (1959 posts) -

Smores all the way. Mint is good if frozen but otherwise it's crap. I also like strawberry.

#43 Posted by JonathanMoore (1858 posts) -

Chocolate, old school and awesome.

#44 Posted by Sinatra (213 posts) -

Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptarts are the best. 

#45 Posted by ArchV1le (232 posts) -

Brown Sugar Cinnamon all the way

#46 Posted by Brunchies (2484 posts) -

Smores is the only one I truly like.

#47 Posted by Vinny (1724 posts) -

True story, I have a 1.5" scar on the inside of my wrist from a hot Pop Tart that landed sugar side down on my arm. My little brother was too absorbed in a Super Mario World session to hear my cries for help, so this must be around 15-20 years ago. I try not to go near them anymore...but Strawberry were my favorites. If you see me at PAX or something, I'll totally show you the scar.

#48 Posted by ArchScabby (5809 posts) -

Brown Sugar and cinnamon.  Sorry, but if you say anything else you're just wrong.  just wrong man.

#49 Posted by Chaser324 (6405 posts) -

Strawberry without frosting is my go to Pop Tart variant, but I've been known to get the brown sugar and cinnamon from time to time.

#50 Posted by SinGulaR (2291 posts) -

It's been so long since I ate my last pop tart I can't even remember. But I loved strawberry.