Warning, crazy amounts of nit-picking and over-analyzing a TV show coming up:
Being someone that grew up on this, I couldn't help but nit-pick the entire time but I'll totally give this another few episodes. My issues?
1. Audience participation is next to none and the few things that were done with 'the help of the audience' were done prior to the show. 'Scenes from a Hat' were always done this way, but grabbing people or items from the audience was always part of the show.
2. Celebrities guests taking the place of audience members. It was always a treat to be in the audience of Whose Line, because you know there was that chance that you might be picked to participate. They typically used the same audience for 5-6 recordings at a time, so chances were alot higher than most would think. So far the celebs have either seemed overly auditioned or completely out of place and lacked any of the hype factor that came with a random person.
3. Hashtags... I don't know if this is something that Tyler brought aboard like the Ubisoft conference or if CW is trying to force the show to be more 'social', but having those on the screen, especially for older viewers, confused the balls off of them. I had to have a 40min conversation about what Twitter was with my uncle lol.
4. Comedic Editing. While the original UK series and the American series seemed fairly raw and unedited, they did make sure to edit out mistakes or side conversations between the host and the comedians when it wasn't needed or funny. This wasn't nearly as well done with tonight's episodes. At one point Cohan (from Walking Dead) nearly knocked over Colin, and while it was pretty funny, they could have snapped to a shot of Tyler and cut out the 'Sorry.' and the resulting 5 seconds of her trying to find her spot while Tyler commanded 'First Position!' Clearly they thought it was going to come off as funny, but it was just weird.
Things I liked?
1. The Crew's Back and Colin still doesn't have any hair. I'd really like to see some oldies like Brad come back on once in a while.
2. Tyler seems like a competent host and once she's done with her explanation of 'This used to be a really good show, here's how it goes, hope you keep watching.' and gets into her own, she fits right in. Her jokes, while inappropriate for a Ubisoft conference, (still the best fucking conference though) hold up against the sexual jokes being thrown around on a minute by minute basis. She actually managed to shock the cast for a few and she owned every second of it.
3. Letting celebs get into it if they want. Though it seemed auditioned, the song Wayne did with McHale (from Glee) was something if not purely amazing.
4. The sideways 'skit'. Didn't get the name of this one, but it was new and amazing. Though it looked like Colin was about ready to pass out with how physical it got. I would like to see this on a regular basis, the skit, not Colin ready to pass out.
Log in to comment