@forkboy: @walkmanboy: I have to point out that UKIP is "sitting with fascists" as much as they are sitting with Greek communists, since all of those anti-EU parties with elected representatives have an anti-EU agenda. The "common front" that all these disparate parties share is an ability for a minority blocking vote for EU legislation, thusly vetoing unelected commissioners in enforcing European policy on various countries' electorates who have voted not to have it imposed on them.
"Farage had promised that Ukip would not enter any formal alliance with Le Pen's Front National, which he had criticised for "antisemitism and general prejudice", but his comments suggested he was expecting the two parties to find themselves on the same side of many Eurosceptic battles in Brussels."
Surely it is impossible, unless you are being intellectually dishonest, to jump to a conclusion that UKIP are fascist communists. Or is it just less hyperbolic or not as impactful to call UKIP raving communists?
I have to point out that I haven't claimed that UKIP are fascist, only that they are willing to work with fascists. I think they are xenophobic and homophobic and contain a larger proportion of racists than any major party, (& this is worst of all I think, they are responsible for that awful crook and entirely unrepentant crook Neil Hamilton being on television right now) but they are not fascists. They are Thatcherites Plus. That's a world away from fascism, and calling something fascist solely because it's racist does a great disservice to the many racists who believe in rampant neo-liberalism. The BNP & Britain First can be fairly accurately labelled fascist, but I wouldn't say UKIP are.
You also didn't address the whole "sitting with Lega Nord" thing. Because they clearly do that. And Lega Nord are, if not actual fascists they are still a party who has a history of seriously dodgy racial statements. Such as Roberto Calderoli's comments last summer on the then new Minister for Integration; "I love animals, but when I see her I can't help but think of an orangutan." Their leader coined the much-maligned phrase Bongo Bongo Land, later co-opted by the delightful UKIP MEP Godfrey Bloom. Are racists alright by you if they aren't Actual Fascists™? I certainly dislike all racists, regardless of where they fall in the political spectrum.
Euroscepticism is fine. I'm mildly eurosceptic in that I think the idea is solid and has done a lot for European peace these past 50 years, but it's very wasteful and has some exceedingly stupid laws. And is broadly liberal in outlook and focuses on advancing a free market agenda. But you can be eurosceptic without the scaremongering about Romanians & Bulgarians & them forriners taking our jobs.
Also, just for the record, I mean if you want proper fascist communists then I'd direct you towards the rather repellent National Bolsheviks in Russia. Seriously nasty bunch of buggers.
@yesiamaduck: To be completely honest, UKIP is a protest vote. I don't agree with the policies, or the belief that the UK can survive in its current form outside of the EU. But voting for the big three doesn't change anything and neither does the voting for the greens. You might as well spoil your paper.
Opportunities like this to change the status quo don't come around very often, and new parties with popular support are very rare. So yes, my vote for UKIP is purely for change, not ideological agreement.
The reason I'm voting Liberal (not libdem) locally is because they have a long history of being a party that makes a difference locally and actually helps its electorate. If the conservatives did the same, I would consider voting for them as well, but they don't, so my options are limited.
I'm all for change. But I'd rather argue for positive change than change driven by fear and xenophobia. I'm also not really sure that a party full of bankers, stockbrokers, and people who basically are Tories but like Europe even less will be much of a force for change, except on a couple of issues such as Europe and immigration.
And no, voting for the Greens, who are likely to win multiple seats in this country, is not the same as spoiling your ballot. That's nonsense. If I sound patronising again they sorry, but that's a really hard statement to take seriously. The Greens have representatives in both Westminster and Holyrood as well as Brussels, as opposed to UKIP being a total non-entity in both the House of Commons & Scottish Parliament.
Log in to comment