Root Canal or Pulled Tooth?

Topic started by METALM1LITIA91 on July 29, 2009. Last post by skrutop 3 months, 3 weeks ago.
Post by METALM1LITIA91 (166 posts) See mini bio
1090 ACH / 20756 P

Loading...
I go to the dentist for what I thought was a chipped tooth. He informed me that it was rather bad and I need a root canal. He said pulling the tooth would do the trick but he recommends a root canal.

Have any of you had either a root canal or pulled tooth? What do you recommend.

I've heard root canals are bad so I don't know if thats what I want to do


Post by CL60 (5,730 posts) See mini bio
1752 ACH / 33623 P

Loading...
Get a root canal, I had to get like 7 when I got hit in the face with a golf club, and they are not bad at all. If the dentist knows what he is doing of course.


Post by FrankCanada97 (1,440 posts) See mini bio
86 ACH / 1450 P

Loading...
I think you should trust the trained professional.


Post by SirPsychoSexy (135 posts) See mini bio
924 ACH / 14675 P

Loading...
Ive heard root canals are painful but ive never had one, but i have had several teeth pulled which wasnt bad at all.


Post by CL60 (5,730 posts) See mini bio
1752 ACH / 33623 P

Loading...
@SirPsychoSexy said:
" Ive heard root canals are painful but ive never had one, but i have had several teeth pulled which wasnt bad at all. "
Root canals are less painful then teeth being pulled.


Post by Osaladin (876 posts) See mini bio
339 ACH / 6915 P

Loading...
I had a bad experience with my root canal. First off, the dentist missed my gum with the anesthetic and injected my tongue. Then he forgot to re-administer the anesthetic when it wore off (the root canal took about 4 hours), before he put the false metal root into the nerve. I can honestly say that when he drove the metal root into the nerve, it was the most painful thing I've ever felt, and I've broken my wrist, and ruptured my ACL, tore my meniscus, and shattered my knee bone.


Post by CL60 (5,730 posts) See mini bio
1752 ACH / 33623 P

Loading...
@Osaladin said:
" I had a bad experience with my root canal. First off, the dentist missed my gum with the anesthetic and injected my tongue. Then he forgot to re-administer the anesthetic when it wore off (the root canal took about 4 hours), before he put the false metal root into the nerve. I can honestly say that when he drove the metal root into the nerve, it was the most painful thing I've ever felt, and I've broken my wrist, and ruptured my ACL, tore my meniscus, and shattered my knee bone. "
All of my root canals have been quick and easy. An hour max. Most of the time less then that. No pain what so ever. I think you should get a new dentist :P


Post by TheGamerGeek (1,234 posts) See mini bio
2176 ACH / 43782 P

Loading...
I have had 2 root canals and they indeed do suck but they're not as bad as you think. I'd say Root Canal.


Post by Osaladin (876 posts) See mini bio
339 ACH / 6915 P

Loading...
@CL60 said:
" @Osaladin said:
" I had a bad experience with my root canal. First off, the dentist missed my gum with the anesthetic and injected my tongue. Then he forgot to re-administer the anesthetic when it wore off (the root canal took about 4 hours), before he put the false metal root into the nerve. I can honestly say that when he drove the metal root into the nerve, it was the most painful thing I've ever felt, and I've broken my wrist, and ruptured my ACL, tore my meniscus, and shattered my knee bone. "
All of my root canals have been quick and easy. An hour max. Most of the time less then that. No pain what so ever. I think you should get a new dentist :P "
Yeah, that was about 6 years back, I think the dentist that I went to actually went to jail for illegal selling drugs(medicinal) on the streets.


Post by CL60 (5,730 posts) See mini bio
1752 ACH / 33623 P

Loading...
@Osaladin said:
" @CL60 said:
" @Osaladin said:
" I had a bad experience with my root canal. First off, the dentist missed my gum with the anesthetic and injected my tongue. Then he forgot to re-administer the anesthetic when it wore off (the root canal took about 4 hours), before he put the false metal root into the nerve. I can honestly say that when he drove the metal root into the nerve, it was the most painful thing I've ever felt, and I've broken my wrist, and ruptured my ACL, tore my meniscus, and shattered my knee bone. "
All of my root canals have been quick and easy. An hour max. Most of the time less then that. No pain what so ever. I think you should get a new dentist :P "
Yeah, that was about 6 years back, I think the dentist that I went to actually went to jail for illegal selling drugs(medicinal) on the streets. "
Hmm, seems like a bad dentist. :P


Post by natetodamax (7,037 posts) See mini bio
1386 ACH / 27902 P

Loading...
I heard root canals hurt bad, and when you have teeth pulled you don't feel anything. The only pain is when they stick that needle into your gums so you don't feel anything when you have them yanked out.


Post by CL60 (5,730 posts) See mini bio
1752 ACH / 33623 P

Loading...
@natetodamax said:
" I heard root canals hurt bad, and when you have teeth pulled you don't feel anything. The only pain is when they stick that needle into your gums so you don't feel anything when you have them yanked out. "
As I said multiple times in this topic, root canals do not hurt at all :P

Unless your dentist is terrible at what he does they are painless.


Post by Psyx2 (392 posts) See mini bio
11 ACH / 0 P

Loading...
My dad's had root canals before and he says they're really painful. I've had my own teeth pulled before and I didn't feel anything, even after it was pulled and the numbness went away. Getting your tooth pulled seems like the safer choice to me.


Post by Meltbrain (1,170 posts) See mini bio
1433 ACH / 27530 P

Loading...
What are you afraid of pain or something? Go for the canal treatment, man. Jeez. Only get a tooth pulled when you really have to.


Post by MB (6,004 posts) See mini bio
497 ACH / 8618 P

Loading...

Online Now
Moderator

If you get a tooth pulled you'll need a post and an implant or at the very least a bridge.
 
I had a tooth pulled a few years ago after many different root canals and various problems with it. Having it pulled was the best decision I ever made...years of pain and trouble gone in 20 minutes. I have a titanium tooth and post in there now.


Post by Bucketdeth (4,647 posts) See mini bio
427 ACH / 5145 P

Loading...
@Meltbrain said:
"What are you afraid of pain or something? Go for the canal treatment, man. Jeez. Only get a tooth pulled when you really have to."
Dude I fucking hate the dentist, I don't blame the poor bastard for wondering what it's like, I want to kick the fuckers in the head as soon as they pull out the drills, but I know there only helping me.
@CL60 said:
"Get a root canal, I had to get like 7 when I got hit in the face with a golf club, and they are not bad at all. If the dentist knows what he is doing of course."

You should totally post the story on your Golf Club face massacre, unless your already did.



Post by Sir_Ragnarok (1,892 posts) See mini bio
1366 ACH / 28081 P

Loading...
I have some of the worst teeth for someone of my age range. I've actually had both.

And really, it's all relative, the answer to which is worse. Relative to the tooth's positioning in the gum itself, the severity of cavity, the responsiveness of the tooth's nerve, the ability of the dentist.

Both the root canal and the pulled tooth were molars for me, so the experience can be compared pretty easily. The pulling of the tooth took less time, because there is less of a process (again, strong, healthy teeth are more difficult to remove, however). Ultimately it comes down to how much you trust your dentist. If you've spent some time in the patient's chair and know how deft he is and feel he is capable of doing the job, then the root canal is probably the way to go.

Just food for thought, though: I'd rather have a crowned tooth than no tooth at all.


Post by TheGreatGuero (3,031 posts) See mini bio
1064 ACH / 18651 P

Loading...

Online Now

I'd go with what the doctor advises. A root canal will be more painful, but could be a much better move in the long run.


Post by ArchScabby (2,512 posts) See mini bio
2415 ACH / 47309 P

Loading...
@CL60 said:
" Get a root canal, I had to get like 7 when I got hit in the face with a golf club, and they are not bad at all. If the dentist knows what he is doing of course. "
how?  did you piss off a golfer?


Post by Akeldama (1,980 posts) See mini bio
974 ACH / 13645 P

Loading...
ive had both and trust me, you want a root canal. Less blood.


1691 ACH / 32646 P

Loading...

Online Now

Root canal = keeping whats salvagable in your tooth

Pulled tooth = one less tooth to help you chew, one step closer to being a toothless hilbilly and so much more expensive to implant a new tooth.


Post by Hairydutchman (690 posts) See mini bio
401 ACH / 7031 P

Loading...
@natetodamax said:
" I heard root canals hurt bad, and when you have teeth pulled you don't feel anything. The only pain is when they stick that needle into your gums so you don't feel anything when you have them yanked out. "
That needle in your gum hurts like a motherfucker. It's like they stick a metal piece in there instead of a needle.

The rest of it aint so bad. Except the fact that you're drooling blood for a couple of hours.


Post by CL60 (5,730 posts) See mini bio
1752 ACH / 33623 P

Loading...
@ArchScabby said:
" @CL60 said:
" Get a root canal, I had to get like 7 when I got hit in the face with a golf club, and they are not bad at all. If the dentist knows what he is doing of course. "
how?  did you piss off a golfer? "
My cousin is a moron and was swinging a golf club around everywhere and it hit me in the mouth.


Post by CL60 (5,730 posts) See mini bio
1752 ACH / 33623 P

Loading...

@CL60 said:
"Get a root canal, I had to get like 7 when I got hit in the face with a golf club, and they are not bad at all. If the dentist knows what he is doing of course."
You should totally post the story on your Golf Club face massacre, unless your already did. "
I should! Not sure if I did already, I would have to check :P


Post by Shadow (1,693 posts) See mini bio
3900 ACH / 90354 P

Loading...
root canal.  Do you really want to be missing a tooth?


Post by Hilbert (66 posts) See mini bio
697 ACH / 15222 P

Loading...
@METALM1LITIA91 said:
"I go to the dentist for what I thought was a chipped tooth. He informed me that it was rather bad and I need a root canal. He said pulling the tooth would do the trick but he recommends a root canal. Have any of you had either a root canal or pulled tooth? What do you recommend.I've heard root canals are bad so I don't know if thats what I want to do "

Get the root canal, the pain is an old wife's tail. the nervous system in your tooth is completely or half dead so that's why your tooth feels different when you touch it with your tongue. In other words you feel nothing, you don't even need a sedation for it, although to just ease your mind take the needle anyway.


Post by Everyones_A_Critic (1,696 posts) See mini bio
1509 ACH / 31057 P

Loading...

Route Canal. I'd reccomend Dr. Freeman.



Post by CL60 (5,730 posts) See mini bio
1752 ACH / 33623 P

Loading...
@Hilbert said:
" @METALM1LITIA91 said:
"I go to the dentist for what I thought was a chipped tooth. He informed me that it was rather bad and I need a root canal. He said pulling the tooth would do the trick but he recommends a root canal. Have any of you had either a root canal or pulled tooth? What do you recommend.I've heard root canals are bad so I don't know if thats what I want to do "
Get the root canal, the pain is an old wife's tail. the nervous system in your tooth is completely or half dead so that's why your tooth feels different when you touch it with your tongue. In other words you feel nothing, you don't even need a sedation for it, although to just ease your mind take the needle anyway. "
This, but well, without the sedation you will still feel a massive tingling in your gum, I had to change dentists for one of mine and he sucked and barely froze it and it was tingling insanely, but yeah, otherwise..to say they are massively painful is just ridiculous, they don't hurt at all. Getting my wisdom teeth out was 15x worse.


Post by Hilbert (66 posts) See mini bio
697 ACH / 15222 P

Loading...
@CL60 said:
"@Hilbert said:
" @METALM1LITIA91 said:
"I go to the dentist for what I thought was a chipped tooth. He informed me that it was rather bad and I need a root canal. He said pulling the tooth would do the trick but he recommends a root canal. Have any of you had either a root canal or pulled tooth? What do you recommend.I've heard root canals are bad so I don't know if thats what I want to do "
Get the root canal, the pain is an old wife's tail. the nervous system in your tooth is completely or half dead so that's why your tooth feels different when you touch it with your tongue. In other words you feel nothing, you don't even need a sedation for it, although to just ease your mind take the needle anyway. "
This, but well, without the sedation you will still feel a massive tingling in your gum, I had to change dentists for one of mine and he sucked and barely froze it and it was tingling insanely, but yeah, otherwise..to say they are massively painful is just ridiculous, they don't hurt at all. Getting my wisdom teeth out was 15x worse."

Yeah and besides, his name is:  Metalmilitia91 not FluffyBunny6.


Post by skrutop (867 posts) See mini bio
756 ACH / 13427 P

Loading...
I had a root canal done two years ago, and it was no worse than getting a cavity filled.  They might've been horrible 15-20 years ago, but the tools and techniques aren't the same anymore.