• 78 results
  • 1
  • 2
#1 Posted by Chewii101 (820 posts) -

The long battle of Pie vs. Cake can be decided on these grounds! 

My fellow giantbomb users, let us unite behind the awesomeness that is the Pie!
#2 Posted by jakob187 (21662 posts) -

Cake > pie...unless it's my grandpa's chocolate pie...

#3 Posted by MattyFTM (14363 posts) -

Crumble > Cake > Pie

Moderator
#4 Posted by ReTarDedFisHy (1062 posts) -
Pie > Cake

...Yum.
#5 Posted by jakob187 (21662 posts) -
ReTarDedFisHy said:
"Pie > Cake

...Yum."
REALLY?!?!?!  You always struck me as a cake person.  Hrmm...
But seriously, how can anyone deny a good spice cake with tasty white buttercreme icing?
#6 Posted by banned8921 (1246 posts) -

cake > pie.

#7 Posted by Verdugo (2001 posts) -

Cake...is....awesssome.

But....Pizza Pie is king.

ARGH, CANT DECIDE.

#8 Posted by jakob187 (21662 posts) -
SuperMooseman said:
"I just don't understand how people can like pie more than cake. I JUST DON'T GET IT, GLORIA!!
Yeah."
My point exactly.  It's so soft and moist.  However, the only downside...is whipped icing.  -_-  That shit is disgusting!!!
#9 Posted by TeflonBilly (4713 posts) -
jakob187 said:
"unless it's my grandpa's chocolate pie..."
This sounds dirty
#10 Posted by jakob187 (21662 posts) -
TeflonBilly said:
"jakob187 said:
"unless it's my grandpa's chocolate pie..."
This sounds dirty"
Of course someone would say that.  *ugh*
He uses a homemade crumble crust with a bag of semi-sweet chocolate chips mixed in with a molasses-based filling.  It's the most delicious thing on the PLANET!!!  How delicious, you ask?  Well, when Thanksgiving or Christmas comes around...he has to bake four pies minimum.  That's not for me, my parents, and my two brothers.  That's for the 25+ people that come over to our house each holiday JUST to eat the pie.
#11 Posted by RHCPfan24 (8609 posts) -

No one has said it yet, so I will

The cake is a lie.
#12 Posted by BiggerBomb (6944 posts) -

Agree to disagree, but your opinion is wrong.

#13 Posted by dsplayer1010 (2227 posts) -

Cake>Pie

I HAVE SPOKEN!!!
#14 Edited by BiggerBomb (6944 posts) -
RHCPfan24 said:
"No one has said it yet, so I will
The cake is a lie.
"
Too many people use that line out of context. She isn't saying that cake doesn't exist, she is saying that it isn't a reward for test subjects. But since she stresses so greatly on how much cake means to the test subjects, (not to mention the numerous cake-based achievements) she is clearly making a statement that there is no higher goal than to eat cake.

in ur fase :)
#15 Posted by Absurd (2934 posts) -

I love both but I love Pie more.

#16 Posted by ZombieHunterOG (3530 posts) -

CAKE 

#17 Posted by BD (251 posts) -

Cake will always prevail, it's been scientifically proven.

#18 Posted by ReTarDedFisHy (1062 posts) -

Okay 'kay 'kay,
Pie = crusty crumbly goodness
Cake = soft melt-in-your-mouth sensation

...ReTarDedFisHy is now left undecided after really thinking about it.

#19 Posted by Gameboi (653 posts) -

Cake is greater than pie, unless said pie is of the Oreo cookie variety.

#20 Posted by TeflonBilly (4713 posts) -
jakob187 said:
"TeflonBilly said:
"jakob187 said:
"unless it's my grandpa's chocolate pie..."
This sounds dirty"
Of course someone would say that.  *ugh*
He uses a homemade crumble crust with a bag of semi-sweet chocolate chips mixed in with a molasses-based filling.  It's the most delicious thing on the PLANET!!!  How delicious, you ask?  Well, when Thanksgiving or Christmas comes around...he has to bake four pies minimum.  That's not for me, my parents, and my two brothers.  That's for the 25+ people that come over to our house each holiday JUST to eat the pie.
"
Oh, I'm just yanking your chain :P
That does sound awesome though.

I'd have to go with cake, but that is mainly cause I'm good at making cakes. I suck at making pies.
My specialty is this awesome apple and cinnamon cake which is a recipe from my great grandmother.
#21 Posted by KamasamaK (2409 posts) -

Pie

#22 Posted by Dalai (7016 posts) -

Good Lord, the cake vs. pie argument again.  What a waste of time this is.

And I expect a crazy high number of negative ratings for this post... so don't disappoint me, Giant Bomb!

#23 Posted by LiquidPrince (15896 posts) -

You need to specify what kind of cake and pie!

#24 Posted by MadMatr07 (200 posts) -

Pie is better than cake. Apple Pie any day.

#25 Posted by clarke0 (1077 posts) -

Dude. Cake.

#26 Posted by Bellum (2944 posts) -

Cake eating fools! Everyone knows pie is superior in versatility and goodness, and that cake gives you a small penis and makes you unable to spell.

#27 Posted by CreamyGoodness (1086 posts) -

dq ice cream cake> jesus or pie combined

#28 Posted by lordofultima (6228 posts) -

Cake. Seriously.

#29 Posted by pirate_republic (1117 posts) -

Pie >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Cake.

#30 Posted by Karmum (11517 posts) -

Let me ask you this fellow bombers -- is there an apple cake? NO.

Apple Pie wipes the floor with cake.

#31 Posted by Deathawk (280 posts) -

Cake. seriously dude have some ice cream cake. this isn't even an argument.

#32 Posted by KamasamaK (2409 posts) -

I thought it was settled that ice cream cake doesn't count. I also don't think cheesecake counts. If they do, I might need to reconsider my position.

#33 Edited by jakob187 (21662 posts) -
Bellum said:
"Cake eating fools! Everyone knows pie is superior in versatility and goodness, and that cake gives you a small penis and makes you unable to spell."
<INSERT POST FROM BIGGERBOMB HERE>
Karmum said:
"Let me ask you this fellow bombers -- is there an apple cake? NO.

Apple Pie wipes the floor with cake."
Um, yes...there is such a thing as apple cake.
#34 Posted by Jayge_ (10221 posts) -

Pie over cake anytime.

#35 Posted by Chewii101 (820 posts) -

Are we saying that pizza pie is a pie? If it is then come on people! 

Pie > Cake
#36 Posted by ThomasP (1655 posts) -
MattyFTM said:
"Crumble > Cake > Pie"
Apple Crumble Pie FTW. Seriously, I made that shit and it was amazing.
#37 Posted by AndrewGaspar (2418 posts) -
Levio91 said:
"cake > pie."
You have it wrong, Levio. As much as Soulja Boy loves his cake, pie is where it's at. I mean, you've got apple pie, pumpkin pie, cherry pie... the list goes on and on. Cake isn't quite as diverse.
#38 Posted by Kombat (2205 posts) -

Pie > Cake.  Fo'realz.

#39 Posted by snake911 (164 posts) -

kāk > pye

#40 Posted by Red (5994 posts) -

My aunt made me a Chocolate Chip Cookie pie once.

It was incredible.
Plus, after living in Europe for 4 years (where cakes blow) I just have to choose pie.
#41 Posted by Gorillawhat (1259 posts) -

Levio eet teh cake, so I eet teh cake













You should too
#42 Posted by OGCartman (4354 posts) -

Cake > Pie
Cheesecake > All

#43 Posted by Kazona (3063 posts) -

Over here cake means something totally different than it does over there, so pie > cake

#44 Posted by toxicEnchiliada (330 posts) -

Pie>Cake FTW

#45 Posted by The_Ish (481 posts) -

Cheesecake > Apple Pie.

Therefore, Cake wins.

#46 Posted by randiolo (1090 posts) -

pies < cake< cannoli

#47 Posted by Hexpane (1397 posts) -

I'd take a good pecan pie over any cake.  And I am not even southern!

caption
#48 Posted by PureRok (4235 posts) -

I hate pie.

#49 Posted by Chewii101 (820 posts) -

Pie. Pie. And more Pie.

#50 Posted by marc (497 posts) -

the only thing better about pie is that it is not a lie.