brokenbrute's From Dust (Xbox 360 Games Store) review

How God looked down upon its people, and smited them with poor AI

So summer comes along and game developers forget gamers exist. Microsoft’s solution to this drought is Summer of Arcade. A yearly assortment of Xbox Live Arcade titles, giving you a reason not to venture outside. 

Ubisoft’s, From Dust is one of these titles, the aim is simple; adventure across the land with your tribe, build settlements, avoid the elements, and move on. Each area is its own little sandbox - a little slice of island paradise - more than likely plagued with tsunamis, flash flooding or it’s own lava flow. Using ‘The Breath’ players can collect sand, water or lava from the world, re-purposing these materials to make sand dunes, put out fires and create walls of rock.

Both technically and artistically, From Dust over performs. Waves realistically crash and roll with foaming surf and fluid movement, lava slowly crawls down the shallow cliff sides, but barrels down steep plains. The sea reflects with just the right amount of bloom and the greenery renders so beautifully that you could almost feel bad when it inevitably ignites. Audio, whilst sparing, sets a perfect tone, of one part adventurer on an African safari to two parts journey into the unknown. 

Seeing your tribes men expand around the map, with foliage and animals around them on what was once a bleak and baron patch of sand is truly satisfying. You won’t find yourself failing often - as this requires loss of your entire tribe - though you’ll more than likely be restarting levels when you find yourself trapped with no route to continue.

The first few hours, as you’re learning the ropes, whilst receiving new powers to play with and guiding your Lemming like tribe around the map - feels different, even original - then the pattern is broken. No longer giving you new toys to play with, such as generating infinite sand or swallowing up multiple elements at once, gameplay just becomes frustrating. 

From a measured challenge, based on planning ahead, From Dust turns into a mad dash to protect your settlements against a timer, counting towards freak weather. You’ll stop experimenting with powers and the environment and just send your men to their doom in the hope a few get through before the next round of meteorological mayhem. 

Poor pathfinding of your tribe doesn’t help either. Your men on occasion will refuse to pass hazard-free ground or retrace their steps only to make the same mistake. 

Story is largely presented through text, rather than being integrated into the action. The ‘Memory of the Tribe’ explains details about the world you're playing in, details which could have made the world richer and more alive if incorporated into gameplay. 

Additional challenges, which similarly to the final levels focus on timing; saving a village from fire, migrating across perilous terrain or similar boring tests, all of which feel like filler.

From Dust starts with such an original concept, though disappointingly wonders off from its core which made the early sections so satisfying. Under the bad decisions there is good gameplay, just a shame that poor story telling decisions, frustration and poor AI makes this game a grind at its end.

Posted by Uncle_Tbag

Appreciate your review, and agree with you on the frustrations with path-finding. But I don't think the cessation of new powers every level is a bad thing at all. Given new powers at every turn, I think the game would be much more gimmicky. I think the real enjoyment comes from the consequences your actions on one part of the environment affect another, making it a sort of ecological chess game IMO. 
Also, on harder levels I like to start it out doing nothing but surveying the land and planning a series of moves, then restarting the level,. Maybe that's a cheap way to play but I like how it lessens time-pressure. 

Posted by brokenbrute
@Uncle_Tbag: I couldn't agree more. When the maps work they're brilliant, as you said "ecological chess", though when they don't, (Movement : rain/volcano level) they feel like frustration combined with blind luck rather than an opportunity to show genuine skill.  
Similarly, do you agree that the challenge levels don't work? As you summed up, part of the enjoyment that comes in From Dust is seeing how combinations of elements interact with the terrain, whilst the challenges seek to do the opposite. 
P.S. Thanks for reading.
Posted by WolfGangS

Very nicely written review.

Other reviews for From Dust (Xbox 360 Games Store)

    Visually impressive but gameplaywise dissapointing 0

    As a software engineer I have to give Kudos to the development team and especially to the physics-guys as the water in this game is just stunning and hauntingly beautiful. The gameplay on the other hand kinda disappointed me. Its not the core mechanics though because these are beatifully implemented. It's the variety in gameplay and the given scenarios. I kinda lost interest in the game after the first half because I had the feeling that the game started to repeat itself. That is basically all. ...

    2 out of 3 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.