I think it'll get 4.5.
What do you think?

-Orakk

The impossible 6 star rating?

The E3 demo looked really damned good. So I'm expecting GOTY material out of this.

I don't think they give half stars, so my guess is 5.

A fair, justified score.

Hulk expect Giant Bomb give Gears 2 what Gears 2 deserve.

I don't like to speculate about how a game will be rated before it has been released.

P.S. Kudos to Hulk for his commitment.

I think Gears 2 can get a perfect rating.

they gave bad company a 5/5, im sure gears 2 will be better

What it deserves!

I bet it will be five stars.

"I think it'll get 4.5.
What do you think?

-Orakk
"

"I think Gears 2 can get a perfect rating.
"

I'm sure it will get a prefect score... all mindless "fun" games do, regardlessly of quality or substance.

OMFG CHAINSAWS!!!11

Prove me wrong, I dare ya...

5/5

Well, Gears 2 looks to be even better than Gears 1, and that game was awesome, so.

To answer your question, probably 5/5.

"I think it'll get 4.5.
What do you think?

-Orakk
"

Right now? At this very moment?

Hopefully a zero seeing as it's not out yet. Or perhaps a 15.257 zebras out of 225 maple leaves. That would make me happy.

i expect they'll give it 5 stars

I think they will give it 5 stars. They gave Battlefield a 5 and I believe Gears 1 was better than Battlefield.

5/5

"I think they will give it 5 stars. They gave Battlefield a 5 and I believe Gears 1 was better than Battlefield.
"

hahaha

you can tell how long the OP has been on Giantbomb

they dont give out half stars

5/5

Probably 5 stars because it is even better than the original which was five star quality.

a 6 star.
5/5

yeah easily a 5

I love Gears and I expect them to give it what they think it deserves.

I love Gears and I expect them to give it what they think it deserves.

theres a lot of crystal balls in this thread.

do me a favour and hook me up with one so I win the lottery this Sat:)

I think 3/5 is more likely though

Gamespot, IGN, and Gametrailers will give it an 11/10 and Giant Bomb will give it a 6/5.

It will be that good. :P

"

theres a lot of crystal balls in this thread.

do me a favour and hook me up with one so I win the lottery this Sat:)

"

I'm saying 5/5

Yeh im going with 4-5 stars some where round there.

umm whatever the games worth. Its kind of not out yet, hard to make an assumption.

Being a fan I obviously hope for a 5 star.

If they gave Bad Company a 5, then Gears 2 already has a 5 even before it comes out

I think there going to give it 5 Old Matches out of 7 Tomato Cans

Depends how good it actually is :P

"I love Gears and I expect them to give it what they think it deserves."

I'm going to guess 5/5 since 5/5 is pretty much saying the game is worth trying for anyone, and it can be a great experience, not that the games perfect.

An easy 5 stars.

Probably 5

considerring they only use a 5 point scale, my guess is a 5/5

Resistance 2 5/5
killzone 2 5/5
LBP 5/5
Fable 2 5/5
Fallout 3 5/5
Resident Evil 5 5/5

5..

It's a tough call.  My own impressions of the game lead me to believe it to be a 5 star. It won't be perfect, but it will be more of the same with a whole lot of tweaks and new hitches. Considering how great the first game was, that is pretty much what I want the game to be in the first place though. I think Giant Bomb staff will rate it the same. That or a 4.5 for the above mentioned reasons, if seen as a flaw.

Although I don't see much of a point in trying to guess what someone else will think of the game. All that matters in the end is what you think of the game.

5/5 I think.

they will give it a 5/5 rating

If Gerstmann reviews it, then a 5.

One of the others, which won't happen, then you never know.