tylea002's Gone Home (Steam) (PC) review

  • Score:
  • tylea002 wrote this review on .
  • 11 out of 14 Giant Bomb users found it helpful.
  • tylea002 has written a total of 3 reviews. The last one was for Gone Home (Steam)
  • This review received 1 comments

A True Interactive Story

There is a piece of paper on a cabinet. You read it, it reveals itself to be an exam from days gone by. The exam has one question, a simple biology task: re-arrange these sentences to form a coherent story about the reproductive cycle. The answer is nothing of the sort. It’s long, a full two page story with character, excitement and passion. It is the writing of a child, so you’d be hard pressed to call it good, but the cheek of it makes you smile. It makes you laugh.

Underneath there is a teacher’s note, written in red: See Me.

This moment comes mere minutes into Gone Home, before you’ve even crossed into double digits. It lasts maybe ten seconds. It is inconsequential, it gains you no XP, it yields no key for locked doors, it is a dead end. And yet, it is everything. That paragraph contains not even half of the information, the character development that you will glean from that one, everyday object. And the object is one of hundreds that you will find. Gone Home is environmental storytelling perfected, a masterclass in level design.

This isn’t to say Gone Home is a revolution in gameplay mechanics, breaking new ground and blowing you away with every click. In fact, it’s the opposite – most games have had you press buttons to move a character, and many games allow you to pick up items. That is the extent of the gameplay on offer in Gone Home. You never escalate to fighting off demons or solving mini-game esque adventure puzzles. You merely walk, look and look closer.Ostensibly, Gone Home is the story of Katie and her sister Sam — Katie (the PC) arrives home after a year travelling in Europe, but when she gets there, she finds a note on the door. No one is home. Your goal is to find out why. From these opening minutes, you’d be positive that a you are about to play a horror game, where the supernatural mystery gets deeper and more terrifying at every time. Gone Home is not interested in such easy categorisation.

And yet, the effect is magical. Imagine if someone made an entire game out of the saferoom scribbles from Left 4 Dead, except the saferoom was your old house and the scribbles were just “things.” Characters that you never meet have fully realised arcs lasting in the decades. Even the house itself tells it’s own tales. Nothing is irrelevant – every scrap of paper reveals something about someone. You could spend hours just peeling away the layers. It is a true interactive story – not in that you interact to change a story being told to you, but that the story is entirely framed through interaction.

A mainline narrative exists too, of course. From the second you find that note on the door, there is a question in your mind, a mystery to solve. In fact, scratch that. To even describe it as a mystery is disingenuous. Gone Home lays it’s cards on the table early, it doesn’t hide them up it’s sleeve, in fact there’s no narrative slight of hand of any kind. It’s not based on plot twists or backstory or mythical exposition, it is a character driven story, which is primarily concerned with emotional honesty. In a video game. I know!

This story unfolds linearly as you search the house, which is easily the most impressive aspect of the game. For all the emotion (which is excellent) and simple environmental storytelling (which is also excellent), nothing impresses as much as the level design. The game is essentially an open-world which you can explore at your own leisure, and yet it contains an entirely linear story in which you travel from point A to B. These two goals seem completely at odds but the way in which the house is designed is simultaneously completely natural and perfectly constructed. It is an obviously authorial and intentionally designed game, but you’d be hard pressed to describe it as “gamey.”

Gone Home isn’t a beacon of true and pure perfection – the few puzzles can draw you out of the experience if you get stuck, having missed the one crucial piece of paper. And the scary atmosphere whilst impeccably formed, can be at odds with certain emotional beats, reducing their effectiveness – but they’re really nitpicks in the scheme of things. Gone Home is fantastic. Through commitment to simple mechanics, it allows you to experience a story with emotional themes that didn’t fit in the medium until now. Any negatives are outweighed by the fact that you are seeing, playing, and feeling something new.

1 Comments
Edited by Substance_D

I do agree the game's sound design and overall design didn't mix well with the emotional, touching story of Sam's relationship. I was terrified within minutes of playing after I listened to that voicemail message on the home's phone and read the note taped to the door outside. I actually had to pause the game from fright and stopped playing a few times because the game plays into psychological horror way more than most games I've played. This game scared me more than Amensia...

It almost seems like the game was designed with more horror elements in mind earlier on, then that part of the story was scrapped for something more heartfelt and relatable. Or maybe their sound designer is just too damn good at making that thunder storm seem real!

Other reviews for Gone Home (Steam) (PC)

    An Ending that was Gone 0

    ***Spoilers ***There is something to be said about Gone Home, it is a well made interactive story rather than an actual game. This to me was not the problem with the game. The mechanics of the game work and I enjoyed walking around the house finding different clues and secret rooms etc. a whole lot. The build up was fantastic but there this falls short is the ending. After I found out what happened(I'll get to that) I was like, huh, well that makes sense. The ending was not revolutionary or even...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    The Emperor has no clothes 0

    I am baffled. Absolutely, totally baffled by the critical reception that this game has received. I find it unfathomable that anybody over the age of about 15 could find the story in this game to be deep, complex, or endearing. Gone Home is a short experience that is worth nowhere near the $20 price tag that it carries on Steam. I bought it on sale for 66% off and it wasn't even worth it then. It lasts about two hours, which is about an hour and 45 minutes too long. The game's exploration and le...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.