lifesabeachh's Gone Home (Steam) (PC) review

It's an oddly compelling story, with not much gameplay and some great atmosphere at times

What constitutes as a game? In 'Gone Home', you can walk around and click on things but are these controls just an afterthought to a story the developer wanted to tell? Why, in this medium, is it important to tell this story? I suspect that indie games are the new 'cool' thing, so maybe this was a way to cash in on a growing niche market as well as a massive social debate.

The lone gameplay mechanic this game has which I wish other games would adopt is the ability to put an item back in the same location where you found it. Seriously, it's brilliant. That being said, there's NOTHING in this game--be it atmosphere, storytelling, or any semblance of difficult puzzles--that couldn't be said in another medium. In fact, the story that so many people keep going on about is told entirely through audio files that pop up spontaneously.

It's lazy--the developers are cashing in on an "indie darling" niche that some people (such as the GB reviewer that absurdly gave this game a 5/5) eat up in an effort to stand out or feel good about themselves (i.e. the game snobs).

It's overpriced--regardless of whether you find fun in having a narrative spoonfed to you or not, the most amount of time you can spend on this game is around 2 hours. If that's a value proposition you can live with, fine!

I will say that this pseudo-game does have its moments. Despite an unnecessary side narrative surrounding a ghost that never really goes anywhere, there is a fairly good story being told here. Also, there's a lot of well-crafted details that were put into it. Small details like 80's-themed duotang folders and 90's alternative rock mixtape cassettes are a nice touch. The problem I have, unfortunately, is that this game combines afterthoughts together to create what I consider a semblance of a real game. Is it an experience? Yes, certainly. But it doesn't have enough to constitute as a game if you ask me.

Edited by Substance_D

I don't know which part of this review to shake my head at disaprovingly first.

If you consider certain interactive experiences to "not be games," why did you buy it? You seem to have an issue with a game that doesn't give you a clear goal with a carrot on a stick to motivate you to keep playing, so was it just the "indie hype" that made you purchase it? I think this game's narrative is overrated, but if you honestly don't consider this a game or call it a "pseudo-game," you might want to think about what makes something a video game in the first place:

  • The experience changes based on interaction from the player
  • The player feels empowered and engaged as a result of their interaction with the game

"Video game" is an outdated, silly term in the same way "moving pictures" was for films back in the early 20th century. It's interactive art. Proteus is a game. Flappy Bird is a game. Angry Birds is a game. Get OVER IT.

Other reviews for Gone Home (Steam) (PC)

    A Disappointingly Shallow Experience 0

    Gone Home is a thorough and well-designed experience that absolutely squanders itself on a lack-luster main story. In a game that touts itself as a narrative tour-de-force, it is absolutely tragic that it inevitably falls into the tropes of fairy-tale fantasy of yore, and not in the warm fuzzy nostalgic fashion one might expect.Incredibly ironic in fact, as it makes an excellent representation domestic living in it's time period. A lot of care and love went into designing the house that players ...

    4 out of 4 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.