chilipeppersman's Grand Theft Auto IV (PC) review

Underwhelming

I have been playing the GTA games for a very long time. I think everyone remembers the first time they played the very first GTA, being able to really do whatever you wanted in a goofy, top-down view world. We have come a long way since then. GTA 4 came out in '08 for consoles, but wasnt released on the PC until one year later, and it was a fun, if flawed experience.
 
The initial impression, gameplay wise, was very positive for me. I very much enjoyed the first half of the game, being able to cruise around liberty city, blasting my own hand picked tunes from Indepence FM, going on dates, getting drunk, playing pool, stealing cars, assassinating targets, eating, and watching comedy shows that were actually kindve funny. The cars handle a lot better than in previous GTA games, feeling like they have weight and momentum. The damage modeling system in GTA4 is even better than before, and gives very accurate damage modeling on different parts of the car. The physics engine as well is very well done, and  you can really destroy an environment and watch the beautiful explosion. There were a few times when I tossed a well placed  Grenade, and dudes flew all over the screen. The combat in this game is overhauled compared to previous GTA games that  put you in the center view, opposed to GTA 4's over the shoulder view, which works a lot better. YOu can be a lot more precise, and can even use cover this time around, making fights a lot more tactical and require more skill then just running and gunning. 
 
Liberty City really feels alive, with people having their own agendas, and you have many choices throughout the game that change the course of the story, much like an RPG, which i thought was a nice touch, even if it was very simplistic, giving you a "do this or that "situation. Once you get past all the innovation and intersting things Liberty City has to do, the problems start to show,  espcially on the PC version. 
 
I dont know what Rockstar has been putting in their PC crews' drinks in the past couple years, but ever since the port atrocity that was  Bully, Rockstar has been spitting on PC users. First it was Bully( Didnt even run on my system, it was so buggy), then it was Manhunt 2(I dont know why Rockstar made a PS2 quality game so late), and then it was GTA 4. At least GTA 4 ran on my system, but all the things you have heard about the general slowness of the PC version are true, unless you have a really good video card with at least 1GB of memory. For those who havent heard, its pretty bad. The indoor sequences are very smooth surprisingly, but once you go outside, the graphics take a u-turn. The framewrate, even when i dropped it to the lowest settings, still didnt exceed 25 FPS.  A lot of pop in textures, washed out parts of the city, and horrid looking water are just some of the graphical things that upset me about this game.  i bet this game looks absolutely tits when its on high settings, but unfortunately for me, since my video card is only 512mb, i could only max out shadows and water effects.  
 
Now for the gameplay, it all starts to get pretty repetitive after about halfway through the game, which is as ive said, the point in this game that I started to enjoy it less and less as the game went on from there. The combat was the only thing that kept me playing this game to be honest, because everything else in this game was definitely starting to feel very tired. By the end of the game, I was so sick of this game I felt playing any other game besides an open world game, and the ending felt very abrupt and was a big let down for me. I thought I had at least another 5 hours or so left, because I looked at my Stats before the last 2 missions, and it said 65% complete.  So Overall, I really expected a better, enjoyable experience from GTA 4, and it all wore off very soon after i started playing. The performance Issues and gameplay redundancies add up to a game i wouldnt recommend unless you are a die hard fan of open world/ GTA games. For everyone else, this game is a waste of time. Your not missing anything, trust me.
 
Now there is also a mutliplayer component that I thought was very enjoyable and overdue. Being able to drive around a free roaming city trying to kill other players is more fun then it should be ;) I havent played the Mulitplayer as much as I have played the story, but I think its definitely something I will come back to. There are a buttload of modes too, probably the most I have ever seen in a multiplayer game.Very fun overall

2 Comments
Posted by JJWeatherman

Add pictures bro. It helps readability tremendously. Also, maybe a bit harsh there at the end when you say "You're not missing anything, trust me". I know it's your review and your opinion but it did win game of the year by like a thousand different critics back in 2008. 
 
Pretty good though. I was looking at some of your past reviews and this one is WAAAAY better.  :P 
Keep 'em comin'.

Posted by chilipeppersman

thanks for the input man. Ill try and add pics in the future for sure. And for the game of the year awards, I can understand where you are coming from, but I have played many games before that were high rated, but when I played them, I felt otherwise. im going off to college pretty soon, and then my reviews will be few and far between, so dont expect me to be writing much more. Ill be doing plenty of writing in my classes to compensate :)

Other reviews for Grand Theft Auto IV (PC)

    A Step Back into the 'NextGen' 0

    The very moment that encapsulates my opinion on GTA IV comes when I am on a heli-tour, cruising along the long stretch of a highway hugging the coastline with a beautiful sunset reflecting off of the ocean stretching to the far horizon. A beautiful sight to behold, so impressive that the Rockstar developer may have been compelled to include the feature of aerial sightseeing in the first place. There is no ulterior or snide tongue-in-cheek motives here; just pure technical wizardry that translate...

    0 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    Kinda sad about PC version release outcome 0

    I never thought Rockstar would do it but they really f***ed up this time. Lets get something clear from the start : the game has addicting gameplay and awesome story - everything previous GTA games had. Except that you can't run it on PC.  Not unless you have a PC that belonged to the Almighty himself. OK hardware isn't so expensive these days, hell, it isn't even that pricy in my country but COME ON - MINIMUM : dual core 2 GHz ( really, i mean really ????) , 1.5 Gb ( i mean i have that much and...

    0 out of 1 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.