Pick up the bottle in the sand. Leave the shipwreck to the left and you'll be taken to the island map. As before on Puerto Pollo, most locations are labelled with a question mark. Visit the building in the middle. This is the Goodsoup hotel. Enter the building and pick up the cushion from the leftmost bar stool. Talk to the bartender and he'll tell you he has a terrible hangover. Pick up the recipe book on the bar and then examine it. It reads that to cure a hang over you need an egg, a pepper and hair from the dog that bit 'ya. Leave the hotel and go back to the map.

The windmill
Go to the location on the far left of the island, the windmill. Once there, pick up the pepper which is to the right side of the windmill. Return to the map.
Go to the cemetery, found below and to the left of the hotel. Walk past the crypts until you come out next to a small shack. Pick up the mallet and chisel infront of the carved tombstone. Give the half-eaten maggoty biscuit from your inventory to the old dog. He will bite you, so now pick up some smelly dog hair. Leave the cemetery and to the map.
For the final ingredient, the egg, go to the beach near the shipwreck. Use the cushion with the rocks, then use the mallet with the rubber tree. The egg will fall down and Guybrush will pick it up along with the cushion. Leave and return to the inside of the hotel.
Give the pepper, smelly dog hair and egg to the bartender in turn. He'll mix up and dose and spring back into life, and will then give the rest to you. Ask for a drink, and order a big, fruity drink with an umbrella in it. Guybrush will automatically pick up the umbrella. Drink the drink, then go open the door at the back of the room. Pick up the refrigerator magnet, and then use the chisel with the wheel o' cheese to take a chunk. Return to the bartender and order another drink. Use the chisel with the Head-B-Clear to open it, then pour some into the drink. Drink the spiked drink and it will be assumed Guybrush has died.
Use the chisel with the coffin that Guybrush is in (bottom right). Now use the chisel on the coffin in the middle to let Stan out. Pick up the coffin nails that border the outside of the coffin Guybrush was in. Leave the crypt and return to the hotel. Walk upstairs and open the door on the left. Guybrush will enter. Use the mallet with the nail hanging out of the wall to push it in. Open the door again to leave, then pick up the portrait and nail from the floor. Use the laminated business card that Stan gave you to unlock the door on the right. Open the door and walk in. Pull down the bed from the wall, then use the coffin nails with the bed, and then use the nail you just picked up with the bed. Pick up the book from on top of the skeleton. Go back downstairs.
Talk to the bartender about everything you can to learn about the Goodsoup family history. Ask him why you weren't burried with Minnie Goodsoup, and then assure him that you are a member of his family. Pick any name you want. End the conversation and go back upstairs. Use the portrait with the door on the left, then enter the room. Look through the porthole, and the bartender will see you and mistake you for a family member. Open the door and go back downstairs. Talk to Goodsoup, the bartender, and ask him if you look just like a Goodsoup. He'll agree that you do bear resembalance, and then continue by telling him you could talk about the family history all day. Order another drink, then use the Head-B-Clear with it. Drink the spiked drink.
Guybrush will emerge from the coffin. Walk to the left and talk to the ghost bride. Cover all topics to learn about her history. Stop talking and walk to the left. Pick up the crowbar on top of the coffin, then walk around it. Murray will fall down to try and scare you. Pick him up, then look through the crack in the wall. Open your inventory and combine the skeleton arm with the paste. Use the skeleton arm with the lantern on the table. Place the lantern on the coffin lid, then use Murray with the lantern. He will "do his stuff", and Mort will open the crypt. Leave and return to the hotel.

Stan's new business location
Enter the back door and pick up the death certificate infront of the wheel o' cheese. Go to Stan in the cemetery. Talk to him and tell him you want to buy his insurance. Offer him the authentic pirate tooth to cover the costs. Give him the certificate, and in return he'll give you the insurance money. Go to the island map.
Go to the strange lights near the volcano. Pick up the measuring cup from the small table. Leave the village and go to the beach. Use the measuring cup with the seawater. Open your inventory and bite the bottle to take out the cork. Combine the pin with the refrigerator magnet, then use the pin with the cork. Finally use the cork with the measuring cup, and you'll have a compass.
Return to the hotel and pick up the mirror to the left of Goodsoup. Put the face you cut out from the portrait earlier into the mirror frame. Pick up the empty jar from the side of the counter. Talk to the fortune teller and get her to tell your fortune. Pick up the tarot card she places on the table. Get her to tell your fortune four more times until you have five cards in total. Go upstairs and back into the room with the skeleton on the bed. Use the crowbar with the boarded hole, then use the crowbar with the bed. After a small cutscene, Guybrush will enter the crypt. Pick up the engagement band on the floor, then leave the crypt and watch another cutscene. Leave the cemetery and to the island map.
Go to the windmill. Use your umbrella with the windmill blades. Use the empty jar with the barrel to fill it with sugar water. Get down from the windmill and return to the map.
Visit the small clearing to the left of the shipwreck to visit Elaine. Use the jar of water with the stump, and all the fireflies will flock into it. Open your inventory and use the chisel with the jar lid to poke holes in it. Now put the jar lid on top of the jar with the fireflies in. Guybrush will automatically pick up the jar. Leave the clearing to go back to the map.
Visit the final '?' on the map, the lighthouse at the front. Use the mirror in your inventory with the one in the lighthouse. Put your lantern on the lantern post and the lighthouse will start working again.
Return to the beach and you'll see a mysterious figure sitting in a boat. Talk to him, and he'll tell you he is the Lost Welshman, the ferryman between Blood and Skull Island. Ask for a ride out to Skull Island, and Guybrush will give him the compass that you made earlier. He will take you to Skull Island.
Talk to the winch operator and he'll lower you down to the smuggler's cave. When Guybrush starts falling, look in your inventory and use the umbrella. If you're not quick enough then you can go back to the cliff top and try again. When inside the smugger's cave, tell them you have so much money it's almost embarrassing. Guybrush will then tell you he wants the diamond. Tell him you can make a deal and you'll play poker with them. When they are looking at their cards, give the five tarot cards to King Andre. Guybrush is able to escape after the candle is blown out.
Leave the beach and watch the cutscene. Go to the shipwreck. Try to pick up the slippery greasy hand lotion next to Haggis. He wont let you pick it up, so talk to him about the lotion. He explains that he needs something similiar to tar, and would give you the whole bottle of lotion if you find something like it. Exit to the left.

The Cannibal's volcano
Go to the village near the volcano. Pick up the block of tofu from the long table, and the auger from the small table. Combine these two items in your inventory to create a mask. Use the tofu mask and walk up the path to the volcano. Talk to the islander and he'll take you to the sacrifice. Use the un-melted hunk of nacho cheese with the massive seething cauldron (the lava) and the volcano will erupt.
Return to the Goodsoup hotel, but do not enter. Instead, walk across to the right and use the rest of your un-melted hunk of nacho cheese with the cooking pot sitting on the barbecue. Pick up the cooking pot and Guybrush will drag it down to Haggis. In exchange, you can now pick up the lotion.
Go to Elaine. Open your inventory and use the the enormous diamond with the engagement ring. Now use the slippery greasy hand lotion on the cursed ring on Elaine's finger. Pull the cursed diamond ring and it will explode. Now use the completed diamond ring from your inventory with Elaine's left ring finger. Watch the cutscene of her springing back to life.