As the title of the thread implies, I was just wondering whether there are any MMO Champion or Thottbot-style websites for Guild Wars 2. I used to use these a whole lot back in the day when I played WoW and I found them very useful. They are usually more useful than wikis in that they have their own pages on everything with areas for users to comment as well.
MMO Champion/Thottbot-style Website for Guild Wars 2?
That website seems pretty good, but I didn't see any comments anywhere. The user comments are the best part of those community-run websites. I will say, though, that it is interesting to see how far those kinds of websites have come in the last several years. Those interactive maps would have been really useful in WoW several years ago.
http://www.gw2db.com/ is generally the one for GW. The wiki is still pretty good, but limited to the formatting that all wikis are. GW2db has things like trading post prices and interactive maps.
I always use the wiki when I can. Hoping to see it eventually reach the incredible standard that the first game's did as a resource/guide/reference manual. Something I discovered years ago on that site was to always click the "Discussion" tab at the top of any page for... well... more in-depth and opinionated discussion. A few examples.
Unfortunately there doesn't seem to be a de facto site for this yet which means the comments and such are spread across the two sites instead of focused on one. Personally I think guildhead is way better though, in terms of usability, accuracy & update speed.
http://dulfy.net/ is pretty good about getting up quick updates with good guides. Has videos of all jumping puzzles, lots of armor previews, and other useful info. Had Scavenger hunt guides up day they were released and made them tons easier (since I suck at lore hints).
Guildhead seems to have the more active community, with more comments to look through, while GW2DB has a easier-to-use interface (especially for calculating mats needed for crafting recipes). I switch between those two sites and the Guild Wars 2 wiki when looking for very specific information.
Dulfy's website has some great event guides and a series of easy-to-view weapon/armor skin guides, but not much in the way of discussion. The lack of a central hub for the community is really aggravating, especially since some of discussions on Guild Wars 2 Guru and the official forums aren't very helpful when you're trying to find an answer to a question.
The lack of a central hub for the community is really aggravating, especially since some of discussions on Guild Wars 2 Guru and the official forums aren't very helpful when you're trying to find an answer to a question.
On the contrary, it means that when one community starts getting too gross you can just hop on over to another resource, where hopefully they're being more reasonable.
This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.