sgthalka's Halo 3 (Legendary Edition) (Xbox 360) review

Amazing level design and gameplay, despite the bleh fiction.

 When the original Halo first debuted on Xbox in 2001, one of the most frequent compliments you heard was, “OMG THESE LEVELS ARE HUGE!” At the time, many shooters were confined to the claustrophobic spaceship corridors seen in the game’s opening level. Once you landed on the surface of Halo, those wide-open fields of battle make a huge impression. Since that time, all games have grown incrementally larger and grander, and it becomes more and more difficult to be impressed by scale (e.g. Resistance 2.) 

Once you start Halo 3, however, it quickly becomes obvious Bungie have outdone themselves and nearly every other FPS developer on the market. The scenes and landscapes you fight through in Halo 3’s single-player campaign are amongst the most epic in the genre. Not just in terms of scale, but in terms of immersion and playability. Navigation has become so bad in games that many developers shove floating arrows on top of your avatar just so you know where the heck to go. Halo 3’s levels feel like authentic environments, but Bungie has done a superb job of signposting progress so it’s never a pain to simply move around. These are iconic, memorable levels -- storming through the mechanical and organic guts of the Flood’s base ship, sneaking through a jungle in the game’s opening mission, an epic finale in the sky. The single-player campaign is nearly like a Greatest Hits package, filled with a batch of replayable levels you’ll want to dive into again and again.

As good as the gameplay mechanics, art direction and level design are, it’s disappointing that Bungie hasn’t invested as much time or resources (or talent?) into really developing Halo’s fiction or characters to the level seen in other AAA series like Grand Theft Auto or Bioshock. At its heart, Halo is still a homage to Aliens or Predator or any of the dozens of Hollywood sci-fi action films that have endlessly been copied and re-copied over the decades. It’s partly a criticism of games, in general -- story and character nearly always take a back seat to graphics and gameplay, even in single-player focused games. But with a franchise this famous and a developer this well-financed, you’d hope they could up their game. The fiction of Halo, to me, is science fiction at its worst. Shooting invaders, flying spaceships, saving the world. It’s Saturday-morning-cartoon science fiction. Even lesser-known games like Dead Space are doing more interesting things with storytelling and character in a space-themed shooter. That’s not to say Halo 3’s campaign is terrible. It’s not, and it’s the best in the series so far.

I’m not a big multiplayer guy, so for better or worse, I won’t touch on Bungie’s genre-defining work. It’s obviously among the best in the business, if you’re so inclined.    

Other reviews for Halo 3 (Legendary Edition) (Xbox 360)

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.