Are hamburgers sandwiches?

#1 Posted by Jeff (3626 posts) -

I think we can all agree that hamburgers and sandwiches are related, but would you consider "hamburger" to be a subset of "sandwich?


The debate rages on.
#2 Posted by Vinny (2011 posts) -

if you put roast beef between hamburger buns, would that be a sandwich?

Staff
#3 Posted by Jeff (3626 posts) -

Yeah, I think that would be considered a sandwich.

#4 Posted by GMan (471 posts) -

I wanna know why it's called a HAMburger when it's not ham.  Cowburger?

Moo?



#5 Edited by wafflestomp (250 posts) -

If there are at least 2 slices of bread with stuff between them, it be a sandwich, yo.

Damnit, I forgot about open-faced....

boo me.

Moderator
#6 Posted by suitteeth (50 posts) -

 Legend has it that what we know today as a hamburger was originally just a ground beef patty between two slices of white bread.

QED

#7 Edited by CitizenKane (10507 posts) -

Hamburgers are the best kind of sandwich, and I have Webster's Dictionary to back me up.  Not the part about it being the best kind of sandwich, but itself being a sandwich.  ;)

#8 Posted by Toriko (82 posts) -

It's obviously a sandwich, or is it?

It's in a special bun, I think Sandwiches can only be with bread.

#9 Posted by elliooo (293 posts) -

A Hamburger resides within the sandwhich family for sure, but is really it's own entity. Whilst a sandwhich usually entails sliced or cut meats, and a hamburger has its meat portion in burger-form, making it a different beast.

#10 Posted by Tom (12 posts) -

have you guys even considered what happens when a sandwhich gets toasted? What the hell is it then!!!

#11 Posted by SamFo (1535 posts) -
elliooo said:
"A Hamburger resides within the sandwhich family for sure, but is really it's own entity. Whilst a sandwhich usually entails sliced or cut meats, and a hamburger has its meat portion in burger-form, making it a different beast.
"
Going to have to agree with Elliott on this one, I'd like to see someone go to SubWay and order a burger or conversely, go to mcDonald's and order a sandwich. Not going to happen.
#12 Posted by MichaelScott (193 posts) -

They are a certain kind of sandwich that should not be compared to your average sandwich.

if that helps. <.<

#13 Posted by Soopy (46 posts) -

i believe a hamburger is a sandwich just because it sounds healthier.

#14 Posted by xplodedd (1316 posts) -

if a sloppy joe burger is considered a sandwich, then i think that burgers are sandwiches too.

#15 Posted by MetalicSand (10 posts) -

A Hamburger is not a sandwich! Thats just the way things need to be. No explanation needed.

#16 Posted by Demilich (2598 posts) -

I think to qualify as a hamburger you need roasted beef and 2 buns.

#17 Posted by FingDi (12 posts) -

Well dictionary.com defines a sandwich as "1.two or more slices of bread or the like with a layer of meat, fish, cheese, etc., between each pair." So it would appear that hamburgers do fall under the sandwich category. But at the same time I don't think that's fair. Because let's be honest here, HAMBURGER > SANDWICH.

#18 Posted by VitaminWaterYum (381 posts) -

It's a sandwich, but only by definition. Both have things inside two pieces of bread that you eat.

#19 Edited by Jensonb (1756 posts) -

Yeah, it's a sandwich, I submit as proof The Simpsons joke about the Krusty Burger being the "Official Meat-Flavoured patty sandwich" of the Olympic games.

#20 Posted by Relys (984 posts) -

Sadly, I wouldn't know. I was raised vegetarian. :(

#21 Posted by Joseppie (733 posts) -

Hamburger is a sandwich but it certainly does not transcend the sandwich category. You can't let hamburgers' egos run wild.

#22 Posted by Gambit (727 posts) -

Sub-way doesn't sell hamburgers so it's not a sandwich.

#23 Posted by Klesk (18 posts) -

Hamburgers are not sandwiches.

Sandwiches are hamburgers.

get some.

#24 Posted by Leroy (2 posts) -

Epic battle. too bad "Rolls" are getting caught right in the middle of all this.

#25 Posted by EightBitWarrior (591 posts) -

I can tell you exactly what they are: Delicious!

#26 Posted by LouChou (458 posts) -

The hamburger is like the Johnny Cash of sandwiches...

#27 Posted by MasterSplinter (636 posts) -

But does it really matter as long as it tastes good?

#28 Posted by dotxhideki (60 posts) -

Anything that is layered in between 2 slices of bread is a sandwich to me.

#29 Posted by Batman (1016 posts) -

I like to think of the Hamburger as the king of sandwiches. 

#30 Posted by expanded (4 posts) -

Well, the next time we all eat a sandwhich or a hamburger.. we should ask ourselves. Why?
Why do we put this succulent perfect match of meat and bun straight into our mouths without wondering..What is this phenomenon we taste?
I believe .. it's a cheeseburger :o

#31 Posted by SullyBMF (4 posts) -

Its definatly a sub category of sandwhich, but its by no means a "sandwhich". If you ask your wife or girlfriend if they could make you sandwhich how many times have they ever come back with a cheeseburger? Idk about you guys but i have yet to recieve a buger out of that.

#32 Posted by p0tet (48 posts) -

well.. a sandwich is (according to wiki) "a food item made of two or more slices of bread"....

#33 Posted by TheBeast (1931 posts) -

I think if there was a family tree of food items, the sandwich and the burger would be sibling nodes - rather than descendants. They'd probably have a parent node called something like 'Breadius Containius'.
Although literally speaking - a hamburger is not the actual bap which surrounds the meaty substance. The hamburger is the actual meaty substance. So no. Unless you make sandwiches out of flesh, they are not the same.

#34 Posted by OlDrtyBstrd (112 posts) -

Yes they are...I mean no they aren't...I MEAN...AUGH!!!!!!! I DONT KNOW!!!!!

#35 Posted by Aleril (11 posts) -

Well, a sandwich defined by websters is a: two or more slices of bread or a split roll having a filling in between

So I guess it is.

(P.S., sorry for making those 2 blank posts, I didn't know it is quick reply.)

#36 Posted by Termite (2398 posts) -

Yeah, technically they are...but I wouldn't say they are

#37 Posted by JDUB_XL (460 posts) -

Yes, A hamburger is definitely a sandwich

Any food that involves a large amount of meat volume between two slices of bread is a sandwich. Except for a hotdog, that is indeed no type of sandwich

#38 Posted by Dan (143 posts) -

Hamburgers and sandwiches are synonymous, but they also coexist. You could make a strong argument that one could not exist without the other.

#39 Posted by XAMS (68 posts) -

Well, in some restaurants ive seen them list hamburgers under the "sandwiches" area in the menu. So I guess they are a kind of sandwich.

#40 Posted by Hamburger_Technology (23 posts) -
Tom said:
"have you guys even considered what happens when a sandwhich gets toasted? What the hell is it then!!!"
That would be a toasted sandwich. Also, a Hamburger is not a sandwich.
#41 Posted by ZenGaijin (125 posts) -

I don't consider a Hamburger a sandwich when I think of a sandwich I think of a combination of meats coming together to make something awesome. A Hamburger is one lone meat going it for the entire strength of the dish, I think for that reason Hamburgers need their own classification.

#42 Edited by Kibblez (702 posts) -
CaLe said:
"Well.. when I think of a sandwich I think of something that is cold. Hamburgers are supposed to be warm! Not cold darn it!"
 I think you're touching on preference more than anything. Without sounding like a pedantic jerk, DUDE UR WRONGGG!
#43 Posted by White (1377 posts) -

As long as it tastes good, who cares?

#44 Posted by Atlas (2454 posts) -

A sandwich is a sandwich.

A burger is a burger.

I'm happy to leave it at that.

#45 Posted by RoboRobb (1052 posts) -

What would a Hamburger Cake be like I wonder?? thats too trippy I guess. Maybe if there was such a thing it would be part of the cake family.

#46 Posted by NoRemnants (384 posts) -

Well Hotdogs are just pork between a bun. Are they sandwiches. Someone should make a Sandwich family tree.

#47 Posted by jangofett88 (324 posts) -

I would consider a hamburger to be a sandwich.

----------

"It's like ground up pills...at the bottom of it."

#48 Posted by Player1 (3874 posts) -
CaLe said:
"Well.. when I think of a sandwich I think of something that is cold. Hamburgers are supposed to be warm! Not cold darn it!
"

What about toasted subs? Those are most definatly warm, but still sandwichs. I think the burger shoud have a classification of its own. Its not a sandwhich, its a burger.
#49 Posted by Brocrates (2 posts) -

Anything between two slices of bread is a sandwich.

All buns are bread, but not all bread is buns.

Buns are required for hot dogs and hamburgers.

Therefore, a hamburger is not a sandwich.

#50 Posted by Leewow (118 posts) -

If The Meat Is In Between Two Buns Its A Burger If The Meats Between Two Slices Of Bread Its A Sandwich

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.