Hotline or Isaac?

#1 Posted by bearklaw19 (65 posts) -

So I have been deciding to get one of these games ( Hotline Miami, or The Binding of Isaac) but I cant decide which one, my laptop is complete crap and its about all my computer can run, Hotline Miami is on for 5 dollars on Steam and so is Isaac, so give me your opinion, which one did you enjoy?, which one is more fun in your opinion?. I will prob end up buying both in the future but what should I purchase first?.

#2 Posted by MikeGosot (3227 posts) -

Isaac. More bang for the buck.

#3 Posted by Winternet (8006 posts) -

Let's jump the "well, it depends on what type of games you like most, blah blah blah" part. Go for Binding Of Isaac. If you end up enjoying it a lot, you'll spend countless hours in it.

#4 Posted by J12088 (437 posts) -

Isaac. Over 200 hours in that game. Miami is good but it doesn't have anywhere near the replay value that isaac does. Nor the sheer amount of content.

#5 Edited by leafhouse (133 posts) -

That depends on what means by bang. I'm gonna go ahead and say Hotline is the better game. You'll probably spend more time with Isaac though

#6 Posted by Ares42 (2581 posts) -

Well, sorta biased as I haven't even bought Hotline (as I don't really think it looks that fun), but objectively Isaac has way way more replayability. I put in over 80 hours in Isaac this summer, and I still go back to it regularly and have a good time.

#7 Posted by bearklaw19 (65 posts) -

Wow I did not think the votes would sway to much into Isaac's favor, I have looked at the quick look at that game is WIERD, but lots of items and like you have all stated replay value.

#8 Posted by Skytylz (4030 posts) -

Hotline, it's actually good.

I didn't like Binding if you couldn't tell.

#9 Posted by Andorski (5197 posts) -

Never played The Binding of Isaac, but Hotline Miami is the shit. Even after you get over how pumped the soundtrack is, the actual game is addictive. Imagine the slight endorphin rush when you do an assassination in Assassin's Creed, get a no-scope headshot in Halo, or a chainsaw kill in Gears of War. It's like that in rapid succession when going through a level in Hotline Miami.

#10 Posted by Redbullet685 (6027 posts) -

I like them both, but I would definitely say Hotline Miami. Its just such a unique experience.

#11 Edited by Indiana_Jenkins (381 posts) -

Hotline Miami.

While it might not have as much as Binding of Isaac, Hotline Miami has a decent amount of replay value.

And it's a kick-ass game that should be experienced.

#12 Posted by gaminghooligan (1418 posts) -

I LOVE Hotline Miami. However, duder, Binding of Issac is way more game. Grab Hotline later though, that music is worth the entry price alone

#13 Posted by Winternet (8006 posts) -

@bearklaw19: Hotline Miami is much more likable though. Isaac is not for everyone, but if you get into it, man, you really get into it. It takes so much out of you but it also gives so much back.

#14 Posted by BoG (5181 posts) -

Hotline Miami is fantastic. Isaac is ok.

#15 Posted by beeftothetaco (420 posts) -

Hotline. Isaac's gameplay didn't really appeal to me that much.

#16 Posted by TheHT (10904 posts) -

ISaac was fun for a bit, and the replayability is inherently there, but hotline miami was just so damn cool.

#17 Posted by TruthTellah (8552 posts) -

FTL: Faster Than Light.

#18 Posted by ch3burashka (5017 posts) -

You said you'll get both, but... get both. It doesn't matter which you get first, as long as you get them within 7 days of each other.

Also, GET HYPE for BoI:Rebirth.

#19 Posted by IAmADwagon (49 posts) -

Isaac was 75 cents at one point during the Steam summer sale, and I wouldn't be surprised to see it happen again in the winter sale. Therefore, although I haven't played either, I would recommend getting Miami now and pick up Isaac then.

#20 Posted by tkalsey (153 posts) -

yes

#21 Posted by Winternet (8006 posts) -
#22 Posted by BeachThunder (11705 posts) -

Isaac is always the answer.

#23 Posted by bearklaw19 (65 posts) -

@Winternet: thanks for the advice, so correct me if im wrong but im guessing Binding of Isaac is a dungeon crawler?, with items and different classes?

#24 Posted by J12088 (437 posts) -

@bearklaw19 said:

@Winternet: thanks for the advice, so correct me if im wrong but im guessing Binding of Isaac is a dungeon crawler?, with items and different classes?

It's like zelda dungeoneyish. You have different characters that have different stats/starting items. And you get a new item every floor up untill the womb.

#25 Posted by envane (1159 posts) -

while hotline is great and more immediately fun than the punishing nature of isaac , isaac is a million times more replayable , if its your kind of thing

#26 Posted by ajamafalous (11857 posts) -

I'd say there's probably a greater chance that you won't like Isaac, since you need to like the genre for it to catch you. If you're a fan of roguelikes then you'll probably enjoy Isaac, but I'd say Hotline Miami is probably the safer bet.

#27 Posted by Butano (1728 posts) -

I thought Hotline Miami was "ok" at best. I don't really understand the high praises and reviews for the game after playing it, though the music is pretty rad at some points in the game. Might be because I've only played the 1st playable character and was kinda already burned out by it to continue to play more as the biker dude.

Isaac, however, was a surprise hit for me when it first came out. Put about a dozen or so hours into it and really enjoyed how replayable it was. Still turn it on from time to time. Basically, it's the dungeon design of the old 2D Zelda games, with the randomness and permadeath of Roguelikes.

#28 Posted by Winternet (8006 posts) -

@bearklaw19 said:

@Winternet: thanks for the advice, so correct me if im wrong but im guessing Binding of Isaac is a dungeon crawler?, with items and different classes?

Check the page for more info, I'd say. The different "classes" differ in their initial stats, but they play exactly the same. It's a "rogue-like" game. There are different levels to be played, in each one there's a boss at the end and after you defeat it you get access to the stairs that lead you to the next level. The levels are divided into rooms. There are many kinds of rooms, but normally you enter in a room, kill everyone inside and then go to another room. On your way through the rooms and levels, you find items, power-ups, health, bombs, keys, chests, cards and so on. Your appearance will chance accordingly to the items and power-ups you pick. If you die, you lose everything and start over in the first level with the initial stats and items.

#29 Posted by BeachThunder (11705 posts) -

Hm, should I just get Miami, since it's now 50% off, even if I don't think I really like the 'vibe' of the game. However, everyone seems to be going apeship about the game...

#30 Posted by Meltac (1999 posts) -

Both? It's only like 10 bucks.

#31 Posted by Ravenlight (8040 posts) -

@TruthTellah said:

FTL: Faster Than Light.

Tellin' truths.

#32 Posted by BisonHero (6213 posts) -
@Butano

I thought Hotline Miami was "ok" at best. I don't really understand the high praises and reviews for the game after playing it, though the music is pretty rad at some points in the game. Might be because I've only played the 1st playable character and was kinda already burned out by it to continue to play more as the biker dude.

Isaac, however, was a surprise hit for me when it first came out. Put about a dozen or so hours into it and really enjoyed how replayable it was. Still turn it on from time to time. Basically, it's the dungeon design of the old 2D Zelda games, with the randomness and permadeath of Roguelikes.

The biker dude is the epilogue. You only do 2 missions where you kill guys, then one story mission that's like 3 minutes long that is unfailable. You were very close to the end.
#33 Posted by BisonHero (6213 posts) -

Binding of Isaac is certainly the game that will last you longer to do everything. But which experience is more worth your time? Hard to say. Did you watch the Quick Looks for both? The QL for Hotline Miami is pretty indicative of the game overall, whereas the QL for BoI only scratches the surface; they died within 5 minutes, but once you get a little better, you start to live long enough to see more enemies and crazier items/item combinations.

#34 Posted by Whitlock (5 posts) -

If you really like rouge games, get Issac. I personally can't spend the hours that others can on a rogue game so i subsequently spend more time and enjoyed my time more with Hotline Miami. In my opinion, Hotline Miami is on a whole other level of awesome.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.