When I heard about it at E3 I was very excited about it. I really liked the premise, but I suppose I was expecting more of an Alan Wake sort of game. Something that focused heavily on atmosphere to the point of it being a survival horror game but with water instead of monsters. Watching the reviews and video of the game has dissapointed me, but I might still check it out. Eventually.

Jim Sterling not liking it doesn't mean anything at all of course - as he's just an attention seeking fuckwit - but if Edge are calling it shitty then it's probably shitty.