Well written piece Matty. I can see you've managed to convince a few to go and give the game a shot, so kudos to ya for that!
It's silly really, a lot of popular VNs that are actually quite popular have got 'eroge' as a label for them, and a lot of people end up dismissing them entirely because they figure it's a hentai game with sex being the primary content. When, in fact, those games would be nowhere near as popular as they are if it was sex that was the primary content. Heck, there's a VN that sounded great on Wikipedia, but the page omitted it was also an eroge. And I'm glad they did, or I would have probably ended up avoiding it. That game ended up having one of the more memorable stories I've ever read >.>
@MattyFTM said:
Of course, Katawa Shojou isn't perfect. For a start, I greatly disliked the sex scenes. Two of them were OK. They were believable and seemed like situations that Hisao and Emi could find themselves in, and were reasonably tasteful. It still felt creepy to me. While the game insists that all the girls are over 18, Emi looks really young. But I could believe the situations and it wasn't too explicit, so it wasn't that bad. But there was another sex scene. The middle sex scene. It featured... lemon scented lube. It was totally weird and extremely out of place. Everything from the reasoning why they were doing it, to where they were doing it and their reaction during and after was downright weird. There was nothing "sexy" about the scene at all. I get that they are young and don't know what they're doing. It's supposed to be clumsy and mechanical. But it's not supposed to be like that.
I should note that it is possible to these scenes off in the settings if you wish. That seems like it might be a good option, although they didn't detract from my overall experience with the game. They are all short and certainly not the focus of the game. The other annoying thing in the game is Kenji, a comic relief character who lives in the dorm room next door to Hisao. Simply put, he's a complete nutter who keeps going on about a "feminist conspiracy" he believes in. At the best of times it's a bit annoying, and when you're emotionally invested in the story and you want to continue with it, Kenji showing up is the last thing you want. I found myself saying "fuck off Kenji" aloud during the game once or twice, and then frantically clicking past his dialogue, barely reading a word.
Yeah, totally agree with you there. Kenji is an annoying character and some of the sex scenes are pretty out of place, despite their efforts to integrate it to the overall meaning and direction of the plot.
@PixelPrinny said:
Not gonna lie, jumped to the same "oh its a disabled chick banging sim" conclusion you did and haven't considered it since... Great read, but your caveats involving the sex scenes don't really sell me on your point that "nothing could be farther from the truth".... But I gave Dark Souls a go, so hell, I'll give this a shot, too.
@AhmadMetallic said:
Fucking hentai. Since you and Swoxx wouldn't stop talking about it, eh, I'll try it :P Fucking hentai.
Haha yeah pretty much this.
A lot of popular VNs have shoehorned nudity and sex scenes which earn them the label of 'eroge'. The key word being 'shoehorned', because they wouldn't end up being anywhere near as popular as they are if they focused on being hentai. Heck, Fate/Stay Night originated as an eroge, with nudity and sex scenes with characters that have become popular by now, but at this point in time most of those familiar with the franchise don't really have 'hentai' cross their minds when they're told about Fate/Stay Night. It's moved on from that, because it never was the primary substance to begin with.
I mean I was discouraged by that 'eroge' label too, but the 2 popular VNs with that label that I've played, Kawata Shoujo included, proved me otherwise. It's funny because most of the time eroge VNs with meaningful plot and dialogue have got sex scenes that are shoehorned in garbage just for the sake of putting sex appeal in the game, which lead to some people believing it's simply a hentai game -- when, as Matty pointed out, things couldn't be further from the truth. In fact, the sex is usually the worst part of those stories, because it feels out of place and like gratuitous forced nonsense most of the time.
Katawa Shoujo is less guilty of that, although it still has its share of nonsense. But hey, at least its minimal.
Log in to comment