Kinect Head Tracking

#1 Posted by theswoosh (164 posts) -

IMO this is most exciting feature Kinect will offer us hardcore gamers from what I've seen so far. 
Having played Arma 2 and used the slighty awkward but very cool 'alt + move mouse' to look around while running, the head tracking headset seems really useful...
If it works well this will be very useful in Forza 4, especially if you are using a racing wheel. But surprisingly no mention of head tracking in FPSs like Call of Duty. 
Any thoughts? 

#2 Posted by CptKnots94 (17 posts) -

I feel like Wii U would handle this better. With kinect, you would have to turn your head to look to the side window, but the tv would still be in front of you. With Wii U you could turn the controller with your head and look out the side while looking directly at a screen.

#3 Edited by theswoosh (164 posts) -

Yeah that sounds awkward in theory but looks very natural in the video link of Track IR^^^^ 
Wii U could implement it well on FPS's as long as the controller screen is your primary view but probably not so well on driving games where you are steering and moving left/right (to look around) at the same time.  
I hope we see more features like this that enhance the games we like to play already, rather than turn them all in to 'on rails' garbage. 

#4 Posted by niamahai (1409 posts) -

how does head tracking improves the FPS experience? in most FPS the players just want to shoot dudes in the face. Unless its more of an exploration/ puzzle (object hunt) game played from the First Person perspective.

i'm not some game design genius, but i'm always open to new concepts.

The WiiU (seriously, we need a better name) could get some crazy multi perspective camera going on.

eg: the tablet act as the sticky cam you place in-game so you can watch things going on

#5 Posted by theswoosh (164 posts) -
It's difficult to argue without having tried it my self with either kinect or Track IR. But from my point of view, I use a fanatec wheel on 360 and is awesome, but i cant look around, which is not awesome. So Kinect seems like the only solution to console players. 
And as for FPS's, this guy sells head tracking very well... 
For example; in COD, looking around while prone is a good way to get spotted. But if you could only move your head then you become far less noticeable.
#6 Posted by Sin4profit (3159 posts) -

@theswoosh: Head tracking works great in flight sims and maybe in cockpit racers (haven't tried them) but not really great for anything else.

Basically, if your virtual body isn't glued to a seat it tends to be awkward. I've tried it in ARMA 2 and while it makes flying in helicopters amazing, when i'm playing as infantry it's just cumbersome.

I'm sure they can make head tracking make sense in FPSs but more likely it will contextually activate; full head tracking when you're laying prone and movement is limited, or leaning to dynamically peer around corners.

#7 Posted by theswoosh (164 posts) -

Good points. Looking forward to trying this out in Forza 4 and hopefully Ace Combat. 
Let's just hope they give us some good meaningful implementations of kinect if this is what they are pushing the next couple years.

#8 Posted by iam3green (14368 posts) -

that video explained head tracking very well. i was thinking of actual looking off the screen to see stuff. forza 4 looks pretty good for the use of headtracking to see the side of your car windows. 
since that video, i am kind of into head tracking. i don't think i'm going to be buying kinect though.

#9 Posted by Sin4profit (3159 posts) -
@rebgav: problem with using the free look view to simulate head movement is the disconnect you get when looking in one direction and the adjustment to get back to center. 
the idea of head tracking is that it gives you an extra analog that, if implemented well, works naturally.
#10 Posted by theswoosh (164 posts) -
 isn't the idea that you are never locked to the centre? 
Its pretty easy to recentre your head on the screen after rotating your head, but the natural head bob and sway keeps it immersive. Imagine looking through iron sights on COD, you're still locked down the sights but the field of view sways slightly with the natural sway of your head. 
The hot key for re-centering is for when you get out your chair and sit back down. Since kinect 'accurately' maps your face, surely this shouldn't be a problem. 

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.