The first impressions are not that bad:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JTYOZLP_tDQ

It's quite interesting how could you use it in a First Person Shooter for example... 

I don't know how wise it is to review something that isn't out yet for a couple of months.

I thought it was kind of surprising how the Microsoft PR guy seemed to be suggesting that 'controller games' were for the 'hardcore', or did I read too much into that? Or maybe I've just failed to realise how far away I am from being in the target demographic for kinect? :s

"I don't know how wise it is to review something that isn't out yet for a couple of months. "

Just read the first impressions from the biggest Danish review site. And they are very mixed.
 
 http://www.gamereactor.dk/artikler/79518/Redaktionen+spiller+Kinect/
 
Some are very impressed, some call it eye toy 1,5. 
 
They all think the Adventure game is great, but none of them can see themselves playing kinect on their own. 
 
 If you guys are very interested, I can dig out further impressions.

Calling that a review is deceitful.