mr402's Madden NFL 11 (Xbox 360) review

Save yourself 65 bucks.


First off disregard every review you have read from sites such as these .   I've been playing Madden for many years,  I'm 34 and have played just about every version since the SNES and Genesis days.  That being said I'm also of the camp that believes that sim football should be represented more then over the top arcade gameplay especially when dealing with the NFL license.    Well if you feel the same as I do then avoid this game like the plague.  While there have been improvements such as crisper better visuals and a improved running game this cannot gloss over glaring issues which make this Madden one of the worst in the series.   I'll go over the biggest offenders in my mind to support my statement above.    
 
1st and formost is a complete lack of defense.   Games are complete shootouts you will simply score on each other at will.  This is due to the  defensive AI which is  completely incapable of defending the pass.  This is true even with shut down corners like Revis or Asomugha do not expect to blitz or run zone to create pressure because your dbs no matter there skill will get burned for deep routes or over the middle.  This happens way to often especially with TE streak routes which remain wide open 85 percent of the time.    
 
2nd is a complete lack of consecutive hit tackling.   From the biggest back to the smallest reciever everyone is breaking the 1st tackle no matter there rating's or momentum.   This causes pile ups where only the original player to make contact effects the outcome of the play many times resulting in the ball carrier squeaking through for a big gain or many times a touchdown.  This many years into this generation and they still have not implemented this at all.  PS2 version has and continues to have this option to this day.    I have seen small reciever's like DeSean Jackson who weighs in at about 175  pounds break tackles from linebackers like Ray Lewis or Patrick Willis this my friends simply does not happen in the NFL. 
 
3rd laggy online play.   With kids and a family getting the fellas over  is not the best option for me to get human to human competition so online is my main option.   Sadly this game has noticeable lag online which really hampers your timing.  Every snap on offense will hitch when your center snaps the ball.  Most troublesome is the new kicking meter which the lag completely breaks.  Resulting in missed field goals and kick off's flying out of bounds.     
 
4th is the Strategy pad EA mapped presnap controls to this new mechanic which simply broke what did not need to be fixed.  Before it was easy to set pesnap adjustments to your whole offense/defense or individual players.  Now what was intended to simplify has just been made more complicated.  This will be addressed in a later patch so that is good news.   
 
There are more issues that I won't list simply for wall of text reasons.  I'll just finish by saying that If you remember the glory years of Madden 04, 05 then look elsewhere.   This game is the least Sim of recent years especially with it's focus on offensive play over balance on both sides of the ball.   Which to me is a shame because if they gave defense equal footing in there priorities when creating this game it could have been the best in the series.  
1 Comments
Posted by JapTastic

I could not agree more. I've been playing Madden for over 20 years, and this is the worst one in recent memory. Everything you said are things that I have been complaining about. I have been playing online since the first online Madden on PS2('03?), and now I have to stop doing what I love because It simply doesn't work properly. Almost every pro review is done by someone that doesn't play Madden that much, so they don't really know what they are talking about. This game is TERRIBLE!

Other reviews for Madden NFL 11 (Xbox 360)

    Massive patch needed. 0

    This years version is a sloppy glitch filled cheating waste of $60.  The game will constantly cheat you by gliding players to make catches or block you.  It's all very apparent when you use the replay system.  How many times have you come around the offensive line to be magially held in place before an AI player will glide over to block you?  How many times have you seen an AI WR glide to a ball that they had no chance to make?  How many time have you seen the AI QB throw the ball the same time ...

    5 out of 6 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.