If there was another voting competition without Peyton Hillis as an option, who should win?  I would say Aaron Rodgers, but i'm a packers fan so i Iill pick Mike Vick. He demonstrates resilience and is an explosive player. Who do you think should have got it?

This year?  Roger Goodell. 

Aaron Rodgers

ME!!!!

@TekZero said:

This year? Roger Goodell.

This vote is officially over, because that reply cannot be surpassed in sheer brilliance.

Edit: They should also just release Madden 12 as a contract negotiation simulator.

I have no issue with Hillis being on the cover

Ryan Davis

Tim Tebow?

@TekZero said:

This year? Roger Goodell.

Correct!

@bwooduhs said:

Aaron Rodgers

In truth it should have been Rodgers. But, I'm glad its not.

I am a Packers fan (lived my entire life in WI, not bandwagon) and I will be a home boy and pick Aaron Rodgers. I do think he deserves it though. I would say even though I hate the Vikings, Adrian Peterson should be on the cover once. Tom Brady and Payton Manning also has never been on a madden cover surprisingly.

No one, because sports are dumb.

I think most people agree Peyton Hillis should NOT be on the cover of this year's madden.

Ryan Davis

Joe Montana!!!!!!!!

@BlastProcessing: Well, actually people voted for him because he was the smallest named player on the list of players that they could vote for. It was down to him and Vick and after the top 2 were determined, and EA chose to go with Hillis only because of Vick's past.

Jamie Kennedy, just because he's famous and "ur not".

Micheal Vick wearing a Scooby Doo shirt would make this a day one purchase for me.

This year should have been Aaron Rodgers. However one of these years there should be a Peyton Manning one or just have both Peyton and Eli. Tom Brady should also be getting a cover some year. 

Paul Walker.

Captain Price. If anyone's deserved it, it's him.