So their reply on the ending explained about just as much as the ending did :P He's completely ignoring the actual ending and just talking about how "the game is the ending". And then pulling some random qoutes as if they in any way described the ending of the game. Oh well, the Bioware brand means about as much as any other decent developer at this point. While that's still fine, it's sad to see yet another monument of game development crumble.
@Drace said:
Can anyone point me in the direction of threads that have proposed good ways to wrap up this trilogy? I'd love to read what the Mass Effect community thinks would constitute a good ending.
Btw, this is not me being snarky and saying, "If you're so smart, then, how would you end it?" Simply, I've read a few articles on why people are upset (and understand, though, don't totally agree with all points) but I don't really know how you make it better.
They needed to do one of two things. Either change ME3 to be all about building and discovering what the crucible is, taking time to actually build the story up to the conclusion we have now (and then maybe just make some minor changes to the ending cinematics), or they needed to make an ending that involved the fleet and army you built actually winning/losing in a fight against the reapers. While you do get the cutscene as you move into the end-game when they're approaching the earth, it's not really telling much of a story other than "look at all these spaceships" and it's not really diverse enough.
If you ask me a good ending would be Shepard failing, then cutting into a cutscene where you see several different cuts in space and on ground of different races (and some familiar faces) fighting reapers that eventually just pull back, into a sad clip of the rest of Shepards team finding his corpse (or maybe even finding "Reaper Shepard") , into a clip of your team uniting and continuing the fight (or more cuts on different plants of the universe continuing the fight). This would close the door on Shepard, yet still keeping the franchise open for more content with the world in mayhem. Maybe the battle of Earth was big enough to cripple the reapers to the point that it's not over, or to go a bit crazy it could go all starcraft and have you fight the new Shepard Reaper army.
I'm by no means a great writer, but at least that would be an ending that would give closure, pay-off and keep the franchise alive. Sure it's probably not that original, but isn't this the kinda stuff we actually want ? Hell, they could've even just gone with cuts of Reapers ravaging all the home-planets and then showing some of the new races flourish and it would've been fine.
Log in to comment