MAJOR SPOILERS FOR MASS EFFECT 3
Many have written at length about the faults of the conclusion to the Mass Effect trilogy. Some have taken umbrage with the main conflict being resolved via the last-minute inclusion of a deus ex machina, some don't like how the story and characters play out in ways unlike what was previously established, some are upset with how certain elements of Mass Effect lore seem to be contradicted, and others are angry about promises made by the developers that may or may not have been kept. I won't reiterate any of those complaints here. I agree with some, and disagree with others.
My complaint is fairly simple. I don't like the fact that evil wins at the end of the game.
(What follows will be examples of dialogue with my Paragon Shepard.)
Shepard: "I need to stop the Reapers. Do you know how I can do that?"
Catalyst: "Perhaps. I control the Reapers. They are my solution."
Let's take this in for a minute. What do we know about the Reapers? From the previous games, we know that the Reapers are responsible for the annihilation of several species, in many different cycles. The exact numbers aren't revealed, but it could be trillions of lives that have been destroyed by them.
Catalyst: "We harvest advanced civilizations, leaving the younger ones alone. Just as we left your people alive the last time we were here."
Shepard: "But you killed the rest..."
Catalyst: "We helped them ascend so they could make way for new life, storing the old life in Reaper form."
Suspicions raised by the conclusion of Mass Effect 2 are confirmed by the Catalyst. We are taken by the Reapers, harvested, turned into mulch, and used to create new Reapers.
The Catalyst takes the form of a child, and speaks in a child's voice. It speaks calmly with intelligence and patience. But this doesn't change the fact that the Catalyst Child controls the Reapers. The Reapers kidnap and murder sentient beings for their own gain. Therefore, the Catalyst Child is responsible for those trillions of deaths. When you are responsible for the deaths of that many individuals, and you do so with full intent and without mercy, you are evil. Plainly and simply evil.
Shepard: "But you're taking away our future. Without a future, we have no hope. Without hope...we might as well be machines, programmed to do what we're told."
Notice what happens here. Shepard is face-to-face with the intelligence that is responsible for the murder of entire civilizations, including several thousands of human beings. Shepard does not confront the Catalyst Child nor does he/she denounce it's actions based upon a faulty premise of "Synthetics Always Turning on Organics," one that has been proven false within his/her own experiences.
Catalyst: "The Crucible changed me. Created...new possibilities. I know you've thought about destroying us. You can wipe out all synthetic life if you want. Including the Geth. Even you are partly synthetic."
Shepard: "But the Reapers will be destroyed?"
Catalyst: "Yes, but the peace won't last. Soon, your children will create synthetics, and then the chaos will come back."
Shepard: "Maybe..."
Catalyst: "Or do you think you can control us?"
Shepard: "Huh. So the Illusive Man was right after all."
Catalyst: "Yes. But he could never have taken control...because we already controlled him."
Shepard: "But I can..."
Catalyst: "You will die. You will control us, but you will lose everything you have."
Shepard: "But the Reapers will obey me?"
Catalyst: "Yes. There is another solution."
Shepard: "Yeah?"
Catalyst: "Synthesis."
Shepard: "And that is?"
Catalyst: "Add your energy to the Crucible's. Everything you are will be absorbed, and then sent out. The chain reaction will combine all synthetic and organic life into a new framework. A new...DNA."
Shepard: "I...don't know."
Catalyst: "Why not? Synthetics are already part of you. Can you imagine your life without them?"
Shepard: "And there will be peace?"
Catalyst: "The cycle will end. Synthesis is the final evolution of life. But we need each other to make it happen. You have a difficult decision. Releasing the energy of the Crucible will end the cycle, but it will also destroy the mass relays. The paths are open. But you have to choose."
No more is said. At this point, the player takes control and must choose one of the options laid before them to finish the game.
Despite these "choices" being offered by an evil intelligence, Shepard does not raise any objections. He/She asks questions here and there, but never challenges the merits of the options nor the arbitrary nature of their consequences. Shepard is even told about all of the choices resulting in the destruction of the mass relays, an action Shepard is all too aware of resulting in the deaths of hundreds of thousands in the wake, and doesn't say a single word. Nothing.
Remember what Shepard said before? "Without hope...we might as well be machines, programmed to do what we're told." How is what transpires any different than that? Shepard does not question the decisions nor does he/she attempt to formulate his/her own solution. In order to finish the game, the player must force Shepard to do the bidding of the Catalyst Child, arguably the most evil being in the universe.
This is the essence of my issue with the ending. Shepard may have stopped the Reapers, but it was at the behest of the same evil intelligence that created, enacted, and controlled them. It wasn't Shepard's actions or decisions that led to their demise. It wasn't the will of the organics nor the synthetics whose lives are at stake. It was the Catalyst Child. It decided to stop the Reaper Cycle, and instructs Shepard on how to wreak devastation upon the universe in order to reach his/her goal of stopping them for good.
This doesn't make Shepard a hero. This makes Shepard a henchman/ (henchwoman?).
Let me know how you guys feel about this. Whether you agree with me or you think I'm crazy, I want to discuss.
Log in to comment