I could see Patrick in the game pretty easily.

@Centimani said:

Drew, but only if he gets a space submarine.

I was going to say Vinny, but you just sold me on Drew.

Congratulations!

Vinny would be an awesome field engineer with a shotgun and some sort of assault rifle. You'd keep him in your party just for the banter. Potential romantic interest???? I'm just saying

Bob the janitor, he cleans the Whiskey Media HQ after everyone leaves at night http://j.mp/wgIhgu

Brad would make an excellent voice for a Krogan. I can see it.

Dave should be the co-pilot of the Normandy.
 
Joker: Commander, we can't take this kind of Reaper fire!
Shepard: Snider, sitrep!
Dave: Ohhh, we'll be fine, it's fine.

Vinny, Drew, and Dave and they all need to have bad russian accents.

Mr. Dave Snider so he can teach Joker about the "Crazy Snider" Evasive Maneuver.... They probably would've survived the beginning of Mass Effect 2 =X

Clearly space Egypt Jeff :)

Ryan Davis...

As a Hanar...

Using his Final Fantasy, New York style Moogle voice.

@gla55jAw said:

I believe Hardcore Dave is the answer to this.

Amen

Drew, he's already an actor after all.

Ryan Davis for sure

Why won't people understand that if Vinny is in a poll(positive) he will win it...

VINNY!