After the game of the year deliberations, and the fact that I have played through Mass Effect 2 twice, including every piece of DLC except for Shadow Broker, which I will get done soon, well after I beat Brotherhood, Final Fantasy 13, Fable 3 and Borderlands GOTY edition.... so, let's just say before Mass Effect 3, I began to think about the first game and how I played that. I pretty much rushed through the first Mass Effect, didn't really do any of the side missions (I assume there were more than landing on various planets?), which has made me contemplate buying the game again, also because I would like to see how different decisions played out, if they carried over into Mass Effect 2 plus get another save file, and so on. But, after playing the more streamlined and "clean" Mass Effect 2 (changes I was initially disappointed to see) is it really possible to find enjoyment in the first game? When I played it the first time, I thought it was pretty good, although I found it clunky and a bit difficult as well, but again, after Mass Effect 2 the problems I had with the first game might be worsened, and what I like might not seem so good anymore. So, if anyone has gone back and played the original after beating Mass Effect 2, does it still hold up?
So, does this game still hold up?
The combat doesn't feel right, graphically there's a ton of issues, level design and even area design is a lot more unique in ME2, the Mako controls and areas flat out suck.
Now the story, character interactions and moments are better in that game but man....the gameplay
Depends on what you like. Mass effect is much more of an RPG than Mass Effect 2. So if you mainly play shooters I don't think you will enjoy the first Mass Effect. If you like RPG the first Mass Effect will hold up fine. I personally liked the story and character interactions much more in the first game.
Kind of? I mean, even though they are both part of the same franchise, they're both very different games, both tonally and in the way they play, as I found out when I replayed the first game after I finished the second. The problems people had with it 3 years ago are still there. The combat is still clunky, the inventory management is still bad, the elevators still take forever, and the Mako is still the worst part of any Bioware game ever.
However, the way story is told in games hasn't advanced far enough to make any of the story bits less impactful, but I personally was never a huge fan of Mass Effect's cast and Ashley is still terrible. So, if you do decide to play it, just go for broke and don't touch any of the planet exploration sidequests. Because those were the worst part, and are still the worst part.
1)It's still sort of an RPG
2) Loot. I don't understand why people didn't like this aspect of the game, it was fun.
3) The main story is much better than the second game, where as you actually care about what's going on rather than just being told where to go next by some asshole in a chair.
4) The weapons sound more appropriate for the setting.
5) Things are just generally more customizable, adding some re playability and variation.
Having just completed it a few days ago, I think it's a very good game. The storytelling and narrative was superb; the gameplay was alright, I enjoyed it but I know it's by far not a great third-person action game. All that said, I haven't played Mass Effect 2 yet so I can;t compare between the two.
Having just finished my latest Hardcore completionist playthrough last night, I can say that yeah it still does hold up. It's really hard to compare it to Mass Effect 2 because they changed so much. Everything gameplay-wise feels much slower and deliberate. It feels much more like an RPG first and a third person shooter second, whereas I think they tried to even those out with Mass Effect 2. It's also worth it for the story, which I think is great and introduces you to great characters like Wrex and Garrus (definitely squad of the year, all years.) I'd definitely suggest playing it, though if you have a decent computer and didn't care about transferring save files on 360 or anything (if that was your platform of choice), I'd think that PC would be the platform to go with since it gets rid of most of the technical problems with the game. The frame rate can get pretty awful under load.
I just played through it before x-mas and I thought it was really pretty good, that said I like what they did with ME2 alot more as far as gameplay goes, but as long as you keep in mind that ME1 is an older game it can still be quite good
It's actually a lot more of a grind. I'm playing it on Hardcore and man, you just have to sit there and pick apart enemies, even with really great weapons or skills. That and the Mako sections are my biggest complaints, though, the game's just fine from a storyline/dialog perspective.
"Yes. 1)It's still sort of an RPG 2) Loot. I don't understand why people didn't like this aspect of the game, it was fun. 3) The main story is much better than the second game, where as you actually care about what's going on rather than just being told where to go next by some asshole in a chair. 4) The weapons sound more appropriate for the setting. 5) Things are just generally more customizable, adding some re playability and variation. "
1) Mass Effect 2 is still an RPG, it just breaks the traditional RPG format (Much like Mass Effect 1 was trying to do).
2) The loot aspect was bad purely because there was so much downtime managing your equipment, largely because the UI was a pain when you had a large assortment of equipment to sort between 3-6 characters.
3) The main story was largely The Alliance/The Council telling you which planets to go to, and at certain plot points (in comparison to ME2) the dailogue was weaker (only my opinion).
4) Erm, never noticed (though how you would determine this without a Timemachine into a fictional future, I'm not sure).
5) Yeah, ME1 had more customization for your characters with loot & more skills.
My personal opinion (I'm currently replaying ME1 on the back of a ME2 play through), ME1's combat is largely inferior and hard to slip back into. After awhile I got used to it and just roll through most combat now, having lots of abilities to spam keeps it interesting.
Having to stop after doing afew missions to manage my loot is currently my biggest pet peeve. My other problems are planet exploration and side missions on planets. The missions mostly follow very unsubtle templates, and the level designers for certain overly-mountainous planets can kiss my mako. Also the game does feel janky. I mean ME2 wasn't technically perfect, but ME1 has more issues that seem to effect gameplay. A couple times I've had enemies not spawn/appear properly, FPS drops, squad members refusing to follow behind me until I transition to another area, etc.
As a whole, I am enjoying going back to it, but being a completionist and trying to do as much side stuff as possible has become very dull (pretty much done with the sidestuff, now though).
" Yes. 1)It's still sort of an RPG 2) Loot. I don't understand why people didn't like this aspect of the game, it was fun. 3) The main story is much better than the second game, where as you actually care about what's going on rather than just being told where to go next by some asshole in a chair. 4) The weapons sound more appropriate for the setting. 5) Things are just generally more customizable, adding some re playability and variation. "This, also the graphics are very good on the PC (if you have a descent computer), if not I remember the frame rate issue has been fixed on 360, at least late time I tried it on 360.
If you love the Mass Effect universe, than there is always something to go back to with the first game. I only played through it once, but I did every damn mission and mined all the planets I could in the 30-40 hours I dropped into that game. Although I had a lot of annoyances in that first game, it's still a great universe to explore and I don't think I've played a more fully realized universe like this one. Once I get through Red Dead and Alan Wake, I'm very excited to jump back into that shit!
Well it is definitely more... crazy. I mean, I played as a Vanguard and found myself running straight into every enemy and punching them in the face. This, only because the shooting kind of isn't that good. But with that said, the shotgun is awesome! I think that the game holds up just as good as it possibly could. It's hard to get the fact that this is a prequel out of your mind and every time something weird happens you think - Man, I'm really glad they'd fixed that.
This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.
Comment and Save
Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.