What's your favorite Metal Gear game?

Posted by MiamiRedHawks (914 posts) -

So, I finally got a PS3 over Christmas, and beat MGS 4. I thought it was phenomenal, but I still think Metal Gear for the PSX is the best in the series. 
 
Which game in the series do you think is the best?

#1 Posted by MiamiRedHawks (914 posts) -

So, I finally got a PS3 over Christmas, and beat MGS 4. I thought it was phenomenal, but I still think Metal Gear for the PSX is the best in the series. 
 
Which game in the series do you think is the best?

#2 Edited by HitmanAgent47 (8576 posts) -

Mgs3 subsistance, I really didn't enjoy mgs4 at all, it's my least favorite because it's too cutscene heavy and could focus more on the actual game which I finished rather quickly skipping all of the cutscenes. Subsistance has a good camera angle for a change and everything is so low tech which makes it very down to earth and plausible, it was realistic compared to octacamo where I think anyone could spot you if you were lying there on the ground next to them. Subsistance or snake eater also had less cutscenes until the end, it was a good way to start the series, like an orgins story, it played better than mgs1 imo, that's why it gets my vote.

#3 Posted by Rhaknar (5939 posts) -

MGS4. I didnt play the third, and I didnt really like the second (and not because of Raiden). The first was awesome in its day tho

#4 Edited by Cerza (1653 posts) -

I think MGS 1 is the best. It balanced everything properly and did everything it needed to do right. They fucked up things with MGS 2 with Raiden and I didn't care for all the extra little mechanics they added in in the third one. Also, I remember thinking the third MGS felt very dated in terms of game play back when I played it, but that was just the original release. I haven't played MGS 3 Subsistence, which I hear is THE version of MGS 3 to play. MGS 4 is awesome though. That's definitely my second favorite. All the things they had in that were epic.

#5 Posted by Shirogane (3581 posts) -

Mgs3 
4 seemed short and lacking in content gameplay wise. Storywise, it was pretty good, and it was fairly conclusive, didn't really leave anything unanswered. 
Still, in terms of gameplay, the previous games were way more fun.
#6 Edited by EvilTwin (3324 posts) -

I think MGS3 tells the best story of any of the main four MGS games, but I prefer the characters in 1,2, and 4.  The gameplay in 3 (specifically Subsistence) isn't as good as MGS4, but it still feels much more modern than the previous two games and the level design is more consistent in 3 than 4, and since the boss battles in 3 are better than 4, I guess my final answer is 3. 

#7 Posted by MiamiRedHawks (914 posts) -

I think the original was the best simply because you didn't know what to expect playing through the game the first time. With the later iterations, you knew how the game would play before you even put the disc in.

#8 Posted by SJSchmidt93 (4899 posts) -

4, with 2 coming in next.

#9 Posted by Suicidal_SNiper (949 posts) -

MG3 and then the Original. MG3 is probably my 1st or 2nd favorite game of all time. Either that or the original Half Life (I beat it at least twice a year.)

#10 Posted by ArbitraryWater (12123 posts) -

As I just got the MGS trilogy for christmas from a friend, I can say with some conviction that 3 is my favorite. 1 is good but there are some janky mechanics that betray its age, 2 has Raiden (which is an automatic fail in my book) and an obnoxiously long escort sequence. 3 has a survival aspect that I enjoy, not to mention it acts as some sort of bizarre period piece and has a better camera. 
 
I have yet to play 4, and am almost considering saving up for a PS3 to play it (as well as other things. Like Demon's Souls)

#11 Posted by Emandudeguyperson (2501 posts) -

Metal Gear Solid 4>Metal Gear Solid 2>Metal Gear Solid>Metal Gear Solid 3

#12 Posted by AgentJ (8778 posts) -

I have still only played the first, even though I own 2 and 3. I can't make an informed decision until I at least play the ones I own.

#13 Posted by EVO (3941 posts) -
@HitmanAgent47 said:
"I really didn't enjoy mgs4 at all, it's my least favorite because it's too cutscene heavy and could focus more on the actual game which I finished rather quickly skipping all of the cutscenes."
Get outta here. That's like skipping the fries on the side and going straight for the burger.
#14 Edited by HitmanAgent47 (8576 posts) -
@EVO: Metaphors, well I didn't order three order of fries with my burger, that's how much ratio of cutscenes there are to gameplay, I can only take so much if I don't really care about the conclusion of the story over more gameplay. I would rather have a bigger burger and less fries metaphorically. 
 
Subsistance was a two burgers and one super sized fries, which was the right amount of gameplay to cutscenes, it was well paced imo. I know ppl can't take critism of mgs4, I am aware of that, however I am only stating my opinion without any intent of an insult and I own every version of metal gear games on sony consoles. It's just i've moved onto splinter cell games lately and I finding the metal gear universe too unrealistic and I could careless about the story these days than before. I don't play a game for a story rather lots of gameplay over cutscenes. I have nothing futher to add to my opinion, it's all written out.
#15 Posted by mordukai (7185 posts) -

MGS 3. Mainly because it was my first going into this series. 

#16 Posted by Siris (432 posts) -

I played all the Metal Gear Solid games in order (the main ones anyways) and though I have very fond memories of the first Metal Gear Solid.. MGS4 is my favorite in the series by far. Its story, while perhaps the most complex in the series, explained a lot about the previous Metal Gear games to me and actually made me care about the story for once. MGS3 is another one that stands out to me, the story was so cool.. and I loved all the characters, the bosses especially.

#17 Posted by WitchHunter_Z (882 posts) -

MGS3, for me it had the most memorable characters and bosses; with a story that worked well on it's own as well as a prequel to the rest of the series.
 
Who can forget the hour+ long fight against the End? Or having to finish off The Boss by pulling the trigger yourself?

#18 Posted by MiamiRedHawks (914 posts) -
@WitchHunter_Z: The fight against The End has to be one of my favorite boss battles in the series.
#19 Posted by DanielJW (4915 posts) -

I loved MGS3. 

#20 Posted by fugie7 (1109 posts) -

Metal gear solid 3 snake eater. The reason i like the game was the different style of camouflages that you can use during any environment in the game. Also i like the way how they added environments elemental to heal you after the fight. I remeber when i was injure i always try to find the snake and always say ''were having snake tonight''.
#21 Posted by Steve_C (1757 posts) -
@MiamiRedHawks: The End is my favourite boss battle from any game.
 
MGS3 is my favourite. It's so deep. The number of gadgets and mechanics create so many ways to approach situations. It has the best collection of boss battles in any game i've played., and they were consistently great unlike MGS4. I also like the how the story stayed away from too much of the sci-fi stuff. There was less mindfuck, and more time spent on developing the characters and getting emotionally attached to them.
#22 Edited by erikj (53 posts) -

I've played all of the metal gear solid games for the playstation systems (ps1, ps2, ps3, but not psp)
MGS3 snake eater for ps2. My all time favorite game, great storyline very fun to play, and fun to play multiple times.

#23 Edited by handlas (2760 posts) -

Metal Gear Solid 3 easily.  Every single character was awesome (and there were a lot of them).  No Raiden or Octacon.  Great story and ending.  Cutscenes were long but never felt needlessly long like some of the other MGS games (4's ending for example).  Jungle setting was the best.  Swapping camo was fun (not as kewl as the suit in MGS4 tho).
 
Now of course going back to MGS3...the controls feel a bit clunky.  But still, best in the series imo.

#24 Edited by ProfessorEss (7523 posts) -

The first Metal Gear Solid by a wide margin. The only thing that is even in the same atmosphere as MGS1 would be the original Metal Gear for the NES. 
 
These two were trend-setting, genre-creating, mind-blowing games.
All others are merely sequels of varying production qualities.

#25 Posted by p00rdevil (158 posts) -

I just picked up MGS4. Only played the PSX Metal Gear Solid and Metal Gear Snake Eater on PS2. I didn't really fall in love with Metal Gear on Playstation. I didn't like the indoor environments so much and there was too much back and forth banter over the codex.

Metal Gear 3 was fantastic! Everything about that game was excellent; the pacing, the character development, the boss fights were the most exciting and original of any game I ever played, each one was exceptional. The environments were right up my alley. Crawling through the tall grass, wading through swamps, climbing trees, moving through dense forest and jungle, I can't think of another game that made use of the natural outdoor environments as well as MGS3. And it was consistently great from beginning to end. The game never faltered, never a misstep, no section of the game I can point to and say, that could have been done better.

So for me that is what MGS4 has to follow up on. One of the reasons I haven't played it until now is not having the confidence it could be any better than MGS3. But I went out this evening and picked the game up.

#26 Posted by Nightriff (5363 posts) -

MGS3 and 4 are tied for me. I love every game in the Solid series and even though I didn't really like 2 that much when I first played it, it has certainly grown on me and can't wait to play it again at some point Best franchise in gaming for me, without a doubt.

#27 Posted by ewok00p (16 posts) -

MGS4, it was just such an awesome way to put a close on this series. And it had great gameplay mechanics to boot.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.