Added by Ryan on Nov. 17, 2008
60 comments
As anyone who has presided over an internet community can tell you, the key to success lies in moderation. Allowing people to express themselves is essentially what it's all about, but it needs to be within a reasonable limit, a precarious balance that can be difficult to strike. This has been a hard-learned lesson for Sony, which has been having a hell of a time in LittleBigPlanet with the copyright-infringing nature of Mario's Law--the rule which dictates that, whenever a game allows for user-created content, it will be used to recreate some portion of World 1-1 from Super Mario Bros.
I can't really fault Sony for being nervous about potential for litigation that's inherent to LittleBigPlanet's level editor, though it seems that someone has gotten a little overzealous with what's getting pulled.
Kotaku most recently reported that Sony has put the kibosh on the user-made level Azure Palace, a move that has stoked the fires of frustration within the LittleBigPlanet community. Here's a quick run-through of the level, which seems like one of the better showcases for LittleBigPlanet that I've seen. See if you can spot the problem, something I'm having a hard time doing.
It would seem to me that, even if there were some copyright issues with the Azure Palace level, it'd be worth gamble just to inspire other would-be level designers. The game itself is pretty smartly wired to allow the community some level of self-moderation, but I get the sense that Sony had no idea the amount of thoughtful post-release vigilance this game was going to require. It's really unfortunate that LittleBigPlanet has been so continuously tainted by disc recalls, connectivity failure, and content issues. This was supposed to be our big feel-good game of the season, something innocent and approachable that showcased some creative and inclusive technology, as well as the community's best intentions. Instead, it's turned into a high-profile internet forum dispute.
UPDATE: Sony has restored the Azure Palace level, bringing peace and balance back to our universe. Or, at least, it's a step in the right direction.
Salute: 1UP Acquired By UGO, Downsized; EGM Shuttered
Sony Issues Handy Chart, Giant Bomb Issues Handier Chart
Pre-Release Killzone 2 Demo Only For Pre-Orders in US
LittleBigRoll
Metal Gears of War?
Warning! Caution! Overload! Planned Downtime Tonight!
Ninja Blade Demo: We Cut Some Guys, Watch
1.5M Xbox Live Users Online, Bogging Us Down
Guides
on Nov. 17, 2008
on Nov. 17, 2008
on Nov. 17, 2008
on Nov. 17, 2008
on Nov. 18, 2008
on Nov. 18, 2008
on Nov. 18, 2008
on Nov. 18, 2008
I'm baffled at how Sony have the right to remove content from the level creators and get away with it. I can understand (to a certain extent) protection rights for others' intellectual property, but don't these user generated levels have a ceratin degree of their creator's own intellectual property in them?
I guess I'm just whining since this is an opportunity Sony missed for me to buy into the PS3. I'd be quite hacked off after spending hours (or days in the case of the level footage) on a level to get it deleted from my own console.
on Nov. 18, 2008
on Nov. 18, 2008
on Nov. 18, 2008
The recent Sony moderation over Little Big Planet is an amazing step, *ahem* leap backward in regarding to user generated content. While the PC has had it's run-ins with copyright issues regarding mods of popular properties, let's face it. LBP is ridiculously tame. I'm not seeing any highly produced, lavish, over the top remake of Fallout 3 in LBP. I'm sorry, it's not going to happen.
It's also worth mentioning that you can't eat your cake and have it too (mmm. cake.). Your giving a product that revolves around users generating their own content. Now your going to suppress all forms of what you deem is inappropriate from a copyright point of view. After watching the video for Azure Palace, I'm going to go out on a limb and say you're not ready to do that. Instead it seems you've unnecessarily frustrated your customers, (and future ones, which is double bad.) and I'm sure you have ticked off your rare supply of exclusive developers. This is just bad all the way around.
on Nov. 18, 2008
on Nov. 18, 2008
on Nov. 18, 2008
on Nov. 18, 2008
Azure Palace is back up Mr. Davis. Turns out it was just being "moderated" i.e checking to see if it was infringing on anything etc. So NOT pulled completely.
Although, World of Colour has been moderated...though probably will be back up soon like Azure Palace did.
One things for sure, Sony needs a better way of going about moderating levels.
on Nov. 18, 2008
on Nov. 18, 2008
on Nov. 18, 2008
Seriously WTF.
How Sony or MM handles this is gonna be an example of how we should think about either Sony or MM on these type of matters from now on.
Being optimistic, the case may just be that there is a code in play that if enough people report a level for whatever reason it just gets pulled for no reason. This would be the most cost effective way to have a moderating service in play without having people actually do much work(hence its cheap). If that is the case then they should obviously abandon this code by having another update of some kind.
BUT, that would only be true, if a new patch was released and shit like this stops happening. Or Sony/MM comes out with a statement saying my bad we wrote bad code.
However, if we start seeing levels similar to world of colors and azure palace offered as a DLC, then Fuckin Bullshit.
If the actual reason was some fake blood around or something, Fuckin Bullshit.
Seriously, Sony, why do you keep insisting on shooting yourself in the foot?
on Nov. 18, 2008
on Nov. 18, 2008
I haven't touched the game since this has started happening. I know Sony/MM are thinking they already bagged the sale so why not just lean towards the (overzealous) safe side with these things, but come on. This just breeds ill will with what could have been one of the most dedicated fan bases ever.
Login or Signup to comment.