crack_rabbit's Nier (Xbox 360) review

Nier - Far from perfect but still hermaphroditically awesome

Nier  may require you to suck up a few hours of nondescript scene-setting but it rewards with a dark and moving story that eclipses the few technical flaws. 

Set over a thousand years in the future after a cataclysmic event on earth,   Nier  is a third person action   RPG  that pit you against ethereal Shades as you strive to save your daughter from a fatal illness. 

Though it's easily described as a post-apocalyptic setting, this isn't some eastern version of Fallout 3 with an unlimited expanse of ruin and despair with wide eyed   pre-teens dressed provocatively. In this world the post-Apocalypse  has long gone and the painful slow decline of humanity is reaching its most  desperate  and final end. 

You wouldn't think this by looking at the  environments  though. Most are pastoral hills, a bright sea town and a scorching desert city. This serene  deception  masks the deep sadness that the game subtly works into the narrative. It doesn't  pull  any punches either with delivering quests that end bitterly or in great sadness. Yet there's no sappy lingering on people's grief like so many Japanese   RPGs  that we're used to. People die, their loved ones grieve and then have to move on and survive, or go insane. 

There's plenty of both in   Nier  and it helps to frame the experience in its own unique and melancholy setting which cocks most action   RPGs  into a dark and moody hat. Add to that a range of fascinating characters and you have a recipe that comes together better the further you progress.

The protagonist may look like a typical muscle-bound hero but his brutish looks conceal his passionate love for his daughter. This relationship is the core of the game's narrative as you find out what lengths he'll go to in order to save her from the cancerous Black Scrawl. Though this gives   Nier  a deep heart the real deal comes in the form of   Grimoire  Weiss - the patronising yet powerful magic book whose humour and wit give him more humanity than most   RPG  characters.

The relationship between the arrogant tome, the   Hermaprodite  Kaine, the boy Emil and the protagonist all feel oddly real. Yeah, the translation suffers a little when you get to the emotional parts but the humour and the friction between them all compensates for any kind of technical   jankiness  and awkward dialogue. The music is the last piece of the atmospheric puzzle and wraps   Nier  up in the kind of grade A ambiance you'd expect from a triple A Square title. 

It doesn't get away without tarnishing the extraordinary experience with some shaky voice acting and multiple fetch quests. These are enough to put a dampener on the narrative but if you're willing to overlook a few genre staples that have the 'generic' stamp put upon them then by god your in for a ride. Highs and lows punctuate each story quest and there's no doubt this is the darkest narrative to have been told in an action- rpg  for some while. 

Bad things happen to good people and just as you think a victory is within the characters grasp an horrific event swallows up hope and deals another blow to their journey. It's not all Japanese Straw Dogs as the humour and dialogue between the characters can be hilarious and moving at the same time. Kaine, the potty-mouthed hermaphrodite, blows a shit-hog-like fart into the game, lightening the mood but also offering the most meaningful   backstory  of the main cast should you wish to pursue it. 

But if you want melodramatic pathos then the character of Emil will fill your bleak heart with dark glee. That is, if you can block out the simpering voice acting his tragic story tries so hard to derail. Finally, the most awesome aspect of the entire game has to be the Forest of Myth. Here the   gameplay  changes so dramatically that you're either going to love it unconditionally like me or be perplexed into a stupor. Hopefully it'll astound you just as much as the inventive boss battles and the occasional perspective changes did to me.

With the possibility of multiple   playthroughs  revealing more about the characters and the origin of the apocalypse event,   Nier  offers nearly 60 hours of game should you wish to devote your mind and body to its existence. For those possessing more sanity a single   playthrough  will set you back 15 hours if you ignore   sidequests. It's short enough to disregard   Joystiq's  pathetic wet-eared moaning and if you just give   Nier  a chance to shine it can reward you with an understated and moving tale.

Alright I admit - the fishing   minigame  sucks like finding Kaine has boy bits even if her lace-up-from-behind panties instinctively give you a rise. But that's   Nier  down to a T. Full of bizarre, sometimes inspired, game design that gives falls into boring quests too easily yet resuscitates itself with an emotional journey that will cut you deep.
0 Comments

Other reviews for Nier (Xbox 360)

    An odd ball 0

    Nier is a hard game to qualify and quantify, because for all its successes it has its pitfalls, and depending of the player, the outcome of the experience might range from marvellous to horrific.   The graphics aren't generally worth praising, as they are simplistic and bland, yet coherent with the rest of style and imaginary presented. Although there are some interesting details from time to time, and the game is very smooth in terms of framerate.  The sound department is top notch, with a haun...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    Thoroughly mediocre 0

     Nier is one of the most inconsistent games I've ever played. It has a handful of good qualities and some design decisions so baffling that it's incredible the game was allowed to proceed to certification. It's technically a JRPG, but calling that is an awful stretch as it plays out much more like a God of War clone with fetch quests. And courier quests. I guess it has a fishing minigame, which is something that all JRPGs have too, but still. The story pits you as Nier, out to find a cure for hi...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.