jeff and vinny would be much better for a persona game

Ryan repeatably tears the game a new one while Brad talks about how tired he is? :)
Could be funny I guess, but I think I'd stick with JG and VC for endurance runs.

" @Pixelzombie said:

" @FrankCanada97 said:

"Let's just wait until the existence of Persona 5 is revealed first? "

Here you go! "

Which means none of this really matters since Persona 5 in English probably won't be out before 2012. "

Yeah. Brad would die all the time and Ryan would put little to no attention to what's going on in the Social Links, or just go out after someone in the game breaks the barier of quirckiness, like he did in the Jurassic: The Hunted QL after "what the foxtrot" (ironically, Jeff used that sentence on the loading screen).

It's basicly Jeff and Vinny's idea and series. No one would want Drew on TANG, because that's Ryan's feature, so let's leave it at that.

Besides, just give us a FUCKING ENDURANCE RUN and Persona 5, then let's talk about a new ER cast.

ER needs Clooney and that bald dude.
 
Persona needs Vinny and Jeff.

I've said it before and I'll say it again: Jeff and Vinny should be the only ones to do it. It would be way funnier because they would be able to pick up the references that would be thrown in while it would just go over the heads of Ryan and Brad. I'd assume so at least.

No, it wouldn't make any sense.  Jeff and Vinny are already experienced with Persona games now, I wouldn't want to watch Brad and Ryan figure out the fusing and stuff when Jeff and Vinny already know pretty much what they're doing.  Ryan and Brad are cool and funny, but it only makes sense to have Jeff and Vinny do it - if there is one.

i think it would have to be Jeff and Vinny again. I'd love to see Brad and Ryan do something, but for persona it's gotta be Jeff and Vinny. They have the same background knowledge as the audience, so watching Brad and Ryan who don't have that same background knowledge just wouldn't feel right. then again, it will be a completely different story and i think it'd be fun to go through it with different people. and really, the points people are making about "Brad would suck and die all the time" are really illegit. if anything, Brad is just clumsy, and i can relate to that, but this is a game of thinking. Brad would have no problem playing this... well shoot i think i just changed my mind about this by thinking about it. Ryan and Brad! why not

Nope, Brad and Ryan should do something else. Persona series should remain Jeff and Vinnie's to comment.

One thing that I missed from ER1 was Jeff and Vinny missing the P3 references so I'm now looking forward to watching them spot P4 references in P5. Starting a new with Brad and Ryan would deny me that and I would not be pleased!

Hey, here's a crazy idea. How about Vinny and Jeff do it?

jeff and vinny would get totally jealous too and try and sneak into the recordings all the time.

Brad would die way to many times for it to be fun to watch.

I don't think Brad would last through Persona, the game tells a great story, but it like any J-RPG is very linear.   Judging from his reaction to Final Fantasy XIII Brad would get tired very quickly after several hours.

Add drew to the fun, he watches it with vinny and jeff!

Vinny and Jeff. I don't want Ryan to be a condescending dick every single day. Brad I'm all for, Ryan can come if he chills on the pompous attitude.

What about occasional guest appearances from the other folks?  If I recall, there were episode of the P4 endurance runs that other people sat in, at least for a little while. 
 
Nothing wrong with that, and leaving Jeff and VInny as the main folks.

Vinny, Jeff, and Dave would be the ultimate combo.

I'd rather just play Persona 5 myself?

" I'd rather just play Persona 5 myself? "

Jeff, Vinny and Ghoul would be the guys I want doing a P5 endurance Run.  Id be willing to drop Jeff in favour of Ghoul though if it came to it .

" Vinny, Jeff, and Dave would be the ultimate combo. "

No they shouldn't! As much as I like Brad and Ryan, if they do the next persona endurance run than fuck em. The Endurance run belongs to Jeff and Vinny.

I love Brad and Ryan, but I think it would just be a train wreck if they did an Endurance Run. Ryan would get pretty fed up with either the game or Brad way before they reached the end. As for Brad, I can see him doing more moaning then delivering the funnies, which would get tiresome after 100 hours. Neither are as naturally funny, nor as cheerful, as Jeff or Vinny.

" I love Brad and Ryan, but I think it would just be a train wreck if they did an Endurance Run. Ryan would get pretty fed up with either the game or Brad way before they reached the end. As for Brad, I can see him doing more moaning then delivering the funnies, which would get tiresome after 100 hours. Neither are as naturally funny, nor as cheerful, as Jeff or Vinny. "

That would suck.  Ryan's too lazy to be the one playing it while Brad watches, and Brad would keep dying.  They'd give up after a few episodes, and half the scenes would be skipped through after the first five minutes of actually reading the dialogue.

" I don't think Brad would last through Persona, the game tells a great story, but it like any J-RPG is very linear.   Judging from his reaction to Final Fantasy XIII Brad would get tired very quickly after several hours. "

I don't want Brad anywhere near Bufu.

" I don't want Brad anywhere near Bufu. "

Here's a thought why not pull a Deadly Premonition and have TWO P5 ERs

It seems like they are all interested in the Atlus legacy (hence them doing a 4-man QL for Catherine, Jeff talking about importing the Japanese version), I'm sure IF IF IF IF IF iF iF IF IF they decided to do an ER, i'm sure they will do jeff and Vinny, just to keep the legacy going.

" It seems like they are all interested in the Atlus legacy (hence them doing a 4-man QL for Catherine, Jeff talking about importing the Japanese version), I'm sure IF IF IF IF IF iF iF IF IF they decided to do an ER, i'm sure they will do jeff and Vinny, just to keep the legacy going. "

I just want a P5 for 360 in the USA....is that a lot to ask for?

Jeff and Vinny. Ryan and Brad is like watching Laurel and Hardy do a QL. A lot of synical remarks and bumbling. Vinny isn't straight up the best player ever, but he jokes about his mistakes and has fun. Brad gets frustrated a lot. Jeff just rides along, but Ryan would get kind of snippy. The Jeff and Vinny combo works well because they play off each other, and they can put up with a lot more crap.

" @OneManX said:

" It seems like they are all interested in the Atlus legacy (hence them doing a 4-man QL for Catherine, Jeff talking about importing the Japanese version), I'm sure IF IF IF IF IF iF iF IF IF they decided to do an ER, i'm sure they will do jeff and Vinny, just to keep the legacy going. "

Why would you bump this? "

" @OneManX said:

" It seems like they are all interested in the Atlus legacy (hence them doing a 4-man QL for Catherine, Jeff talking about importing the Japanese version), I'm sure IF IF IF IF IF iF iF IF IF they decided to do an ER, i'm sure they will do jeff and Vinny, just to keep the legacy going. "

Why would you bump this? "

I would skip a BR endurance run, so no thanks.

I don't want that- Ryan and Brad are awesome, but Jeff and Vinny are the ones who know how to put on a good show, at least that's how I see it after watching the Deadly Premonition ER. Oh, also, They're not gonna do it!

I wouldn't be against it, but I don't think it's a good idea. 
 
It has to be something new... somewhere along the lines of a Persona and Deadly Premonition in terms of quirkiness, but not Persona 5. When that game arrives, we'll know.

Even if we see another Endurance Run from Giant Bomb, I would imagine we will never see another Atlus game done; especially anything involving SMT. The series has become well known enough that I think they would be stepping on Atlus' toes if they did a P5 run. If, and that's a pretty big if, we see another ER, it'll be another title that falls into that quirky and not well-known area of gaming. Frankly, I'm not holding my breath for another ER. It would be great if they did, but I think we'll have to relive the ER magic through P4 and DP.

" Even if we see another Endurance Run from Giant Bomb, I would imagine we will never see another Atlus game done; especially anything involving SMT"

" Even if we see another Endurance Run from Giant Bomb, I would imagine we will never see another Atlus game done; especially anything involving SMT. The series has become well known enough that I think they would be stepping on Atlus' toes if they did a P5 run. If, and that's a pretty big if, we see another ER, it'll be another title that falls into that quirky and not well-known area of gaming. Frankly, I'm not holding my breath for another ER. It would be great if they did, but I think we'll have to relive the ER magic through P4 and DP. "

Exacly. Most GB people didn't know about the SMT series, nor DP. Although I love seeing this site give Atlus respect, I don't see another Atlus ER...  I will be playing P5 though!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! "

You people believing Jeff saying they'll never do another Atlus game... jesus christ you're gullible. 
 
There will be a Catherine ER. I'm calling it.

" You people believing Jeff saying they'll never do another Atlus game... jesus christ you're gullible.