cervin's Phantasy Star Online (Dreamcast) review

10 Years On, Looking Back At a Defining Dreamcast Game

Phantasy Star Online could have been the most influential piece of entertainment in console gaming history. Instead, Sonic Team's magnum opus  was dead on arrival; Peter Moore announced Sega's decision to become "platform agnostic" on January 31st, 2001 - the day  Phantasy Star Online  ver. 2  hit retail shelves. Considering the first PSO was a buggy mess on the scale of Battlecruiser A.D. 3000, how many had the  oppurtunity to sink 100+ hours into the first really good  PSO game? What a bummer that was.

Sega had the rather unfortunate proclivity to release their best games on hardware that was either dead or completely untenable to the requirements of the  gameplay. See Panzer Dragoon Saga, which many believed the best  RPG of the 32-bit era. This is nearly impossible to confirm, however, because Sega pressed maybe 10,000 copies of the game. Until I have at least $150 dollars to spend on a 13 year old Saturn game, I can only assume those hyperbolic GameFAQs  forumgoers who have devoted so much of their brain to loving Panzer Dragoon Saga that the basic tenants of the English language have been evicted are right.

See also: Phantasy Star Online I & II , regarded as the apogee in the Phantasy Star Online franchise, being released for the freaking  Gamecube  of all things.  An initial investment of, oh, $200+ dollars in modems, peripherals, subscription packages, and lord knows what else, to say nothing of the $50 for the game itself, got you an online game on the least online-friendly gaming system in the history of forever. Yeah, so maybe that's a bit too much scratch for the average human to spend.  Sega, you broke my heart.

This is depressing - let's get back to the  Dreamcast game in question. 

I believe  PSO was the first real time  Rougelike (to simplify for now, let's call it a Diablo clone) on a home console system worth a goddamn. Although I am sickeningly fond of the kind of mindless,  grindy loot gathering action- rpg, I never got into Diablo. I didn't enjoy spending a lot of time looking at a series of dank, stinky corridors. Also, it turns out, I find the act of hitting a button repeatedly more kinetically pleasing than I find the act of clicking a mouse repeatedly.

Diablo did not endear me like PSO did. Of course, I might have a little bit of a predisposition towards a game set in the Phantasy Star universe. After all, the Phantasy Star series is one of my favorites in all of gaming.

I'm still amazed at how well Sonic Team captured the spirit of  Tohru Yoshida's designs when  transferring them to a 3D environment; despite being a totally different style of game, it is still unmistakably Phantasy Star. The 80's  anime look served the game  extraordinarily well, both by looking awesome and by connecting the Algol star system's primitive Sega Master System & Genesis appearance to a contemporary system.

PSO lacked only the incredibly sophisticated, ambitious narrative of its namesake, which is a bit of a shame. Phantasy Star II was a remarkable first attempt at classical tragedy in the  videogame medium -- it's still one of the best stories ever told in an  RPG -- and to discover the most  perfunctory excuses to fetch-quest without any serious  overarching storyline in the  Phantasy Star universe was  disappointing, to say the least. Still, I had a lot of fun in the single player campaign. God knows I spent  sophomore year in high school doing little else but play though it, again and again.

Sadly, I didn't play online  PSO that often, because online gaming was a seriously  janky affair back in 2001, but I have vivid memories of the few time I did get the thing working. Like most slightly monotonous but oddly compelling game genres (the Final Fights and the,  erm,  Diablolikes of the world), playing cooperatively can exponentially improve the experience. However, the main benefit of co-op  gameplay rests largely in the  communal environment and in the communication options  available to you in said environment. Shit-talking with your friends at the  Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles  arcade  cabinet inside Chuck-e-Cheeses is an experience one can look back on in their twilight years with nostalgia; playing Final Fight on your  SNES (no co-op!) in the garage is just sad, man. 

Which makes  PSO's masterfully implemented symbol chat system so important, and so great. Using the tools within the game, you could create your own series of symbols or modify  pre-existing ones to articulate your thoughts to other players. The symbol chat is still amazingly versatile; given a little creativity, you can create a symbol to express some freakishly deep (usually disturbing, as was my wont) concepts. 

So yeah.  PSO was the last  Dreamcast game I bought and the one I feel most needs acknowledging. I demand you  acknowledge it. Now!

PS. The other  Dreamcast classic  Diablolike, Record of  Loddoss War, came out after the first version of  PSO (I think) -- in any case, I played Record of  Loddos War long, long after I got into  PSO.

0 Comments Refresh

Other reviews for Phantasy Star Online (Dreamcast)

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.