Thin Crust or Deep Dish?

#1 Posted by Terra1909 (314 posts) -

Honestly, I don't get how hamburgers get all the glory on the top of the forum charts, while pizza is down here in the muck. I guess that's the Gerstmann Bump for ya. But alas, to the question at hand. I'm originally from New York, so I gotta go with the thin crust. Nothing better than a pie right out of the oven with a slight crunch to the crust. What about you guys? Thin Crust or Deep Dish? New York style or Chicago?

#2 Posted by Dolphin_Butter (1919 posts) -

Stuffed Crust.

#3 Posted by Termite (2398 posts) -

Yeah crunchy crust is great.

I used to like stuffed crust, but that stuff will kill you quick :P

#4 Posted by AtomicEdge (311 posts) -

Thin crust every time.

#5 Posted by McDazzle (544 posts) -

Deep Dish rules

#6 Posted by Hatori (6 posts) -

A thin crust traditional Italian pizza cooked in a woodfire oven is unbelievably sexay <3

#7 Posted by License_To_Bill (792 posts) -

So, it essentially is the arguement of New York or Chicago style?

The Food Network agrees: New York dominates your mouth.

#8 Posted by Terra1909 (314 posts) -
License_To_Bill said:
"So, it essentially is the arguement of New York or Chicago style?

The Food Network agrees: New York dominates your mouth.
I didn't know the Food Network had a competition. They are the experts.....
#9 Posted by McDazzle (544 posts) -
License_To_Bill said:
The Food Network agrees: New York dominates your mouth.
If your into that kind of thing :|
#10 Posted by DaveF (231 posts) -

I think it depends on the mood. If I just want to really taste the toppings, thin crust. If I'm hungry and just want something really greasy tasting, then thick crust is the way to go.

#11 Posted by License_To_Bill (792 posts) -
iplaygames said:
"License_To_Bill said:
"So, it essentially is the arguement of New York or Chicago style?

The Food Network agrees: New York dominates your mouth.
I didn't know the Food Network had a competition. They are the experts.....
New York wins damn-near every category. In fact, it may have won all of them.
#12 Posted by WizzyKid (259 posts) -

Thin but very cheesy base, stuffed crust.

#13 Posted by Dolphin_Butter (1919 posts) -
WizzyKid said:
"Thin but very cheesy base, stuffed crust."
Thank you!  Someone else finally said stuffed crust.
#14 Posted by nezze00 (144 posts) -

Thin Crust!! Fluffy crust ftl imo :[

#15 Posted by Binglejilly (7 posts) -

Stuffed crust all the way man

#16 Posted by Guild_Master (250 posts) -

Thin crust hands down, nothing beat a crispy pizza

#17 Posted by Orange_Pork (614 posts) -

The only place with really good thin crust is Donatos. If it's any other place, I gotta go with deep dish.

#18 Posted by DualReaver (3882 posts) -

Deeeep dish!!!

#19 Posted by Kevin (369 posts) -

Isn't there some medium between thin crust and deep dish. I vote whatever the hell Pizza Hut serves you when you say "I want a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza delivery."

#20 Posted by Dimsey (967 posts) -

Probably thin crust. It's what I have most often, anyway.

#21 Posted by epic_pets (1339 posts) -

deep dish

#22 Posted by banksrob (1126 posts) -

pepperoni deep dish Italian style, with a stuffed tomato sauce *drools at the thought of the pizza*

#23 Posted by c1337us (5751 posts) -

For me it depends what toppings are on the pizza. Different flavors suit different crusts

#24 Posted by lordofultima (6289 posts) -

What does OREO PIZZA fall under? Because that's it. That's what I pick. The end.

#25 Posted by Kush (8889 posts) -

I personally love thin crust pizza...deep dish isn't bad (I should know since I live in Chi), but I just really love thin, crispy crusts.

#26 Posted by John1912 (1998 posts) -

Thin crust, I really dont like deep dish pizzas, too much bread, detracts from the other flavors.  Hate the really greasy ones as well, like pizza hut.

#27 Posted by gersan93 (136 posts) -

A deep dish from Chicago.

#28 Posted by Clean (2359 posts) -

Thin Crust

#29 Posted by Shocker (2339 posts) -
gersan93 said:
"A deep dish from Chicago."
Yep, that's delicious.
#30 Posted by Wuffi (246 posts) -

deep dish all the way

#31 Posted by cjmhockey (244 posts) -

Thin Crust

#32 Posted by Vlademir (1029 posts) -

Deep dish with cheese stuffed in the crust.

#33 Posted by DRooPZ (82 posts) -

Thin Crust

#34 Posted by SSbabel (1141 posts) -

Thin and crispy all the way boooyah.

#35 Posted by TwoOneFive (9459 posts) -

pizza hut makes fake pizza. 

#36 Posted by clarke0 (1077 posts) -

Definitely thin crust.

#37 Posted by Manks (836 posts) -

Thin crust.

#38 Posted by WickedCobra03 (2128 posts) -

Deep Dish if I have to choose but either is amazing!

#39 Edited by banned8921 (1246 posts) -
I like Pan pizza.

Thin crust is for people on low carb diets.
#40 Posted by Tomzombie (401 posts) -

Deep dish

#41 Posted by Absurd (2934 posts) -


#42 Posted by Gamer_152 (14126 posts) -

Very tricky question, each has its own merits. I think I'm gonna have to settle on thin crust.

#43 Posted by GalvanizedNails (552 posts) -

thin crust. its just plain amazing. I love a nice crunch to my pizza

#44 Posted by Black_Raven (1759 posts) -

I like thin crust, I like real pizzas though not that shit you get from pizza hut and domino's 

#45 Posted by CynageN (1165 posts) -

I prefer thin but I can eat it either way.

#46 Posted by mouse5050 (35 posts) -

deep dish....

#47 Posted by m1k3 (1340 posts) -

I prefer stuffed crust, but if i had to choose between thin or deep, i would go with thin since i like it crunchy

#48 Posted by AURON570 (1680 posts) -

I say neither! I prefer soft crust --- Hard enough so that there's something to grab onto (yeah i know haha -.-...) but soft enough that it doesn't feel like breadsticks when I eat them.

#49 Posted by shadows_kill (3165 posts) -

it depends were. deep dish is better but i like a thin every once and a while

#50 Posted by LuckyWanderDude (929 posts) -

Deep dish

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.