As someone who has been frequenting Polygon this has destroyed the credibility of a lot of their editors for me.
I'm okay with editors being honest and giving their opinions, but when you're being an asshole about it your credibility has been flushed away.
I followed polygon for three reasons Brian Crecente Justin McElroy, and Arthur Gies. Arthur gave Dead Space 3 a 9 and I don't agree, but that's okay I still enjoy his writing and personality.
These guys being cynical assholes for two hours and at the end trying to make Justin look like someone without credibility because he enjoyed games that a majority of people didn't ruins their credibility more than it did his.
Ugh typing this on an iPad was a chore. These text boxes don't work very well atm.