@alexander said:
@hailinel said:
The Cids of Final Fantasy are all different characters. That's why there's a Cid concept to denote that idea. An actual Chocobo character appears in the Chocobo's Dungeon/Final Fantasy Fables series. Though they might not necessarily be the exact same Chocobo, the difference between them is negligible.
There are numerous Satan characters that are all based on the same source; the figure of Judeo-Christian tradition. How that figure is represented through the various incarnations and interpretations doesn't really change that. And if we were to break up Satan into multiple pages, what of the two versions of Dante, whom by how the rules have been enforced up to this point are represented by the same page despite being two very different interpretations of the same character?
"There are numerous Satan characters that are all based on the same source; the figure of Judeo-Christian tradition."
I agree with you there, but where you say source & figure, you're essentially talking about a concept, the Judeo-Christian concept of Satan, the character differs widely between games as does the interpretation from faiths. At the very least it would seem a bit weird to combine this page with this one does it not? It would seem to me an example of two completely different characters from different franchises that could only deserve their own pages, it just so happens they share the same name and some tendencies.
Those links both lead to the same Satan page. It would be ridiculous to combine them because they're the same. :P
That there are different interpretations of Satan doesn't necessarily mean that they're different characters. Unless stated otherwise, they all presumably come from the same place, even if their depictions of personality, character, and demeanor aren't identical.
Silly me! I meant this one and this one. One page for these two? Come on, these are two separate characters. Where you say coming from the same "place" I'm reading "concept", give it a go, it makes complete sense.
It's not like Sam Fisher who keeps getting younger and with the upcoming title, appears to have a completely different personality etc. I wish they retired Fisher and kept him on as a mentor or something, instead they change the personality, physique and age. It bums me out but that's a case of the same (albeit butchered) character, whereas the Satans above are not.
Lou from GHIII again, he has more in common with the standard concept of Satan than the one in Umineko no Naku Koro ni (I don't have a clue what series this is but it's one of the examples linked above). Yet his name is not Satan, does the character page for Satan include Lou as an alias? Does Lou get his own page but the "servant to the Golden Witch" (Satan example above) not?
Log in to comment