2011 Wrap Ups: Now Loading's 2011 Best + Worst Awards: Winners
By alpha99 1 Comments
I've gathered up 16 categories for all the games I've played in 2011 to compete in; from the "highly coveted" 2011 Game of the Year, to best character(s), to best game mechanic, to terrible load/wait times, to most disappointing, they are all here. Today I will be revealing the WINNERS of all the categories.
2011 WORST AWARDS WINNERS – INTRO
These games are given the descriptor of worst, with that said, please keep in mind not all these games are bad, in fact, some of these games might be really great, but sometimes there are just things that don't work out. Things like bad design choices, bad product placement, underwhelming features or just flat out horrible games. Also some of these games have received these awards due to my negligence or just because I didn't end up liking them. Also take note that some of these categories / nominees are more "for fun" than others.
Word of Mouth Award
This award is given to the game which has received good review scores and/or good word of mouth, but when I ended up buying it, I found out it wasn't for me or I simply just didn't like what I played. This award is open to all games purchased in 2011.
WINNER: L.A. Noire - (X360, 2011)
L.A. Noire is the winner simply because it does NOT deserve all the positive word of mouth and excellent high scoring reviews it gets. Sometimes this award can go to a game that does deserve its positive word of mouth but turned out it just was not for me. That just isn't the case for LA Noire it gets praised for its excellent story, great voice acting and surreal facial animations, but that is not enough to drive a videogame and LA Noire's lame gun fights, stupid clue hunts and quiz like interrogations fail to bring the required gameplay.
Runners Up:
Dead Island (X360, 2011), Dark Souls (X360, 2011)
Worst Splurge Buy
There are times when you have money burning a hole in your pocket and you just have to spend it. It could be on a bad game, a game that isn't right for you or even a game you don't really need, but that money has to go before your pants catch fire. These are the games that I bought in 2011 that wished I hadn't seen during that particular day, if you know what I mean.
WINNER: Crackdown 2 - (X360, 2010)
Crackdown 2 takes the award simply because there is no need to own this game, at least the other two nominees were unique in concept, Crackdown 2 is the same game that was released back in 2007 except the city is a bit trashed and there are zombies; that's seriously it. If you don't own the first game then you just have a barely average open world 3rd person shooter not worth playing. Don't buy this, that's all there really is to say.
Runners Up: Bangai-O Spirits (DS, 2008), Splinter Cell: Conviction (X360, 2010)
Play or Not to Play?
These nominees have the dubious distinction of being titles that I bought in 2011 but never got into, never even played or played for only a really short time. This seems to happen far too often for me.
WINNER: Okamiden - (DS, 2011)
This year this award maybe should have been called "hand-held game that I bought but didn't feel like playing on said hand-held"... but that's a mouthful so Play or Not to Play? will work. Okamiden wins the award just because out of the three it is the one I actually wanted to play the most. Instead I got another 3-D game controlled by a d-pad, annoying FORCED AI partners that you have to utilize to clear dungeons and bosses (important AI partners in single player games are a serious pet peeve of mine), gimmicky boss fights and on top of that it is on hand-held and I hardly ever play my hand-held systems (I have a serious history of buying hand-helds and games and never playing them) and you have a disappointment that I put off playing.
Runners Up: Dragon Quest Monsters: Joker (DS, 2007), Dragon Quest IV: Realms of Revelation (DS, 2011)
Patience Is a Virtua (Longest Game Wait Time Award)
Loading times... Wait times... Ever since games began to use optical disc technology this has be a common fact of gaming. There might also be a few game mechanics that make you wait. These are the worst culprits of this from titles released in 2011.
WINNER: Bastion - (XBLA, 2011)
I only have experience with the Xbox 360 version of Bastion but when your loading times make the game feel a bit unpolished it really hurts. There isn't one loading screen that is less than 15 seconds with the longer loads nearing the 30 second mark. It's a fairly large blemish on a really excellent little game.
Runners Up: Back to the Future: The Game (WII, 2011), Deus Ex: Human Revolution (X360, 2011)
Worst Game Mechanic
You need good ideas to make a good game and while some ideas sound good on paper, these particular ideas should have stayed on the paper, then got tossed into the fire. What I am saying is that these mechanics actually made their respective games less enjoyable. These are the worst game mechanics of the 2011 released titles.
WINNER: Dead Island's Weapon Breaking - (X360, 2011)
While weapon / armor breaking and degradation could probably win Worst Game Mechanic every single year as it is in the same territory as Escort Missions, Forced Stealth Sections and Block Pushing Puzzles... no one honestly likes it. Dead Island takes this design taboo and makes it so prevalent that you need to carry even crappy white level loot just so you don't run out of weapons after a serious fight against a hoard or tough enemy. Add in the fact, this mechanic makes rare and powerful weapons of questionable use because it is cheaper to maintain and upgrade a crappy white drop than it is to try to keep your purple in good quality. DUMB, ANNOYING and most importantly NO FUN.
Now the Nominees: Bejeweled 3 - Quest Mode Missions + Randomness, L.A. Noire - Interrogations
Most Disappointing Now Loading In-Depth Game of 2011
Not every game I choose to play on NLID will be a winner, in fact, some of them might just be not-so-good games to begin with. This award goes to the NLID game in 2011 that bummed me out the most after COMPLETING it.
WINNER: Secret of Mana - (SNES, 1993)
Sure, BioShock is a crappy game and Majora's Mask's time gimmick didn't do anything for me... but finally taking the time to play a game that you've been hearing nothing but great things about since you were 12 years-old and then finding out almost 19 years later that it is one of the most overrated games in the history of gaming could not bum one out more. Shoddy hit detection that can't register simultaneous hits, a grindy magic system, clunky over done menus, stupid AI partners, non-exsistant story, zero exploration... I could go on, but I will just say this, one of the worst games on the SNES.
Runners Up: BioShock (X360, 2007) (NLID #24 - #26), The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask (N64, 2000) (NLID #3 - #7)
Most Disappointing of 2011
Since I don't intentionally play bad games this award goes to the game that just didn't meet whatever expectations that I had for it. Whether if that was because of poor gameplay, because it was a rehash or just because I couldn't get in to it like I hoped I would. This is award is only open to games published in 2011.
WINNER: Saints Row: The Thrid - (X360)
This is a strange one. It's pretty ironic to have enjoyed your most disappointing game of the year so much. I won't lie to you, Saints Row 3 is a really fun game with some cool missions, some hilarious moments... but it just doesn't work for me. Saints Row 1 and 2 were parodies set somewhat in reality with silly humor but with some occasionally gritty storylines and interesting characters that you loved or you hated. Saints Row 3 puts the Saints in to a parody of a parody and loses all the character and story had built in the first two games. They start the game by killing off the best character 10 minutes in and ditch everything else for telephone conversations to begin missions for the rest of the game. Then of course there is the fact that this game just lacks many of the features that Saints Row 2 helped build up with less clothes customization and fewer missions and activities that almost all of which lost their introductions which gave them context. I'd say Saints Row: The Third was rushed but it was development for 3 years instead of 2 like the bigger and better Saints Row 2. Saints Row: The Third is a soul-less oversimplified game that non-Saints Row fans go on about because they can laugh at sex jokes and blow stuff up.
Runners Up: Shift 2 Unleashed (X360, 2011), L.A. Noire (X360, 2011)
2011 BEST AWARDS WINNERS – INTRO
These games are given the title of best in their cIass, there is nothing better than these games or aspects of these games. You can't go wrong with any of them; in fact you should play them all.
Best Downloadable Game (WiiWare/XBLA)
This award is given out to the best downloadable game game that I played this year. Open to ONLY 2011 released Xbox Live Arcade (XBLA) or WiiWare titles.
WINNER: Torchlight - (XBLA)
This was probably the closest award this year. Both Torchlight and Bastion were pretty much tied. I decided to go with Torchlight because it just has more hours of gameplay than Bastion's 3 or 4 hours. Plus, Torchlight is the game I thought Bastion was going to be so it gave me the gameplay I wanted. Of course Bastion trumps it in story, mood and setting. Downloadable games like these two keep getting better every year and soon they might just blow me away enough to put them up for Game of the Year honors one of these days. NOTE: The XBLA version of Torchlight was released in March 2011, whereas the PC download version was released in 2009 with a retail release in 2010.
Runners Up: Bastion (XBLA, 2011), Bejeweled 3 (X360, 2011)
Best Character in 2011
This award goes to my personal favorite hero/heroine or main character(s) from any game I played in the year of 2011.
WINNER: Wheatley - (Portal 2, 2011)
As you can see Wheatley isn't much to look at which is why his voice actor Stephen Merchant is the real winner of this award. He just plays this dopey character so well and as I said brings him to life hilariously. As noted previously talking too much about Wheatley's role in Portal 2 would be major spoilers.
Runners Up: The Kid (Bastion, 2011), Sam Gideon (Vanquish, 2010)
Best Surprise in 2011
This award is given to a game purchased in 2011 (any year published) that surprised me that it was so good or turned out that was even better than I thought it was going to be.
WINNER: Half-Life 2 - (X360, 2007)
What better a surprise than to find out you owned a really great game this whole time and all you needed to do was to play it for more than 3 hours!? That's what happened with me and Half-Life 2 the first time I tried to play it I didn't really like what I played around 3 hours in, lots of running away and piloting an air boat. If I just would have played a bit longer I would have discovered the GRAVITY GUN, a CIassic shotgun and some great pacing and really well designed levels. Not to mention some great characters and story. SURPRISE!
Runners Up: Two Worlds II (X360, 2010), Enslaved: Journey to the West (X360, 2010)
Best Game Mechanic
Awarded to those game design ideas that REALLY worked out. These ideas worked to perfection and added just that much more to their respective games. This category is open to ONLY 2011 releases.
WINNER: Dragon Language Shouts - (The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, X360)
FUS-RO-DAH! *watches dumb bandit fly off a mountain* Actually my favorite is IIZ-SLEN-NUS which turns your enemies into living Popsicles. The shouts provide a nice middle ground between straight up magic and simple techniques, giving your warrior or thief a little trick up their sleeve.
Runners Up: Batman Arkham City - Grapple Boost Gliding, Portal 2 - Gels
Best 2010 Game Played In 2011
You can only play one game at a time and often you fall behind the release curve. This Award goes to the best 2010 game that I played during the calendar year of 2011.
WINNER: Vanquish - (X360, 2010)
There isn't too much that is needed to be said as to why I chose Vanquish as my best 2010 game played in 2011. It is a great fast paced third person shooter that excels in all areas, gameplay, characters, level design and art design. With that said, I will leave you with this... if I had played it in 2010, it would have been my Game of the Year.
Runners Up: Donkey Kong Country Returns (Wii, 2010), Enslaved: Journey to the West (X360, 2010)
Best Nintendo Wii Game Played in 2011
The poor old Nintendo Wii is showing its age and with lack of releases this is the award that goes to the best Wii game that I played in 2011.
WINNER: Super Paper Mario - (2007)
None of the Paper Mario series games have let me down and Super Paper Mario is no exception. Fun platforming gameplay, quirky characters and a neat world flipping gimmick make for a fun departure from the first two game's RPG mechanics.
Runners Up: Donkey Kong Country Retruns (Wii, 2010), The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword (WII, 2011)
Best Xbox 360
This is the award that goes to the best 2011 published Xbox 360 game.
WINNER: The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
There wasn't a single game that I played more on my Xbox 360 than Skyrim. I have spent over 120 hours with my first character and will probably spend 100 more before I am done. My first 100 hours was done without even barely touching the main questline which is still one of the most impressive things about Bethesda's games. The more in your face combat and the fun Dragon Shouts add just enough to complete the package.
Runners Up: Portal 2, Batman Arkham City
Favorite Now Loading In-Depth Game of 2011
This game is my personal favorite NLID game that I COMPLETED in 2011.
WINNER: Resident Evil 4 - (Gamecube, 2005) (NLID #40 - #42)
I loved Vanquish, adored Half-Life 2, but Resident Evil 4 had me on the edge of my seat trying to survive its intense and challenging gameplay for only the second ever time since I completed it back in 2005. This was another of the close awards where I had trouble choosing and all three games are worth playing and deserved of the award.
Runners Up: Vanquish (X360, 2011) (NLID #36 - #37), Half-Life 2 (X360, 2007) (NLID #16 - #18)
Game of the Year 2010
This is the big one, the Game of the Year. Of course it goes to my PERSONAL FAVORITE game that I played that was published in the calendar year of 2011, not necessarily the best overall.
WINNER: Portal 2 - (X360, 2011)
As the description for this award says: it goes to my PERSONAL FAVORITE of the year, not the best overall. That's why Skyrim won X360 and Portal 2 is my Game of the Year for 2011. I really enjoyed Portal 2's great puzzles which are expertly designed with neat training puzzle that train you on a puzzle element so you can employ it later on more difficult puzzles. This keeps you in the head of the puzzle designer almost insuring that you won't get stuck for too long. That's not say of course the puzzles are easy, but it eliminates one of the frustrations of puzzle games where you just have no clue how to win because no one explained it to you. This is all wrapped up with some great humor and great characters that will have you laughing out loud when you aren't straining your brain on the puzzles. As an added bonus there is a really fun 2 player co-op mode where you need to not only have cooperation but good communication and timing to get through the tricky puzzles. Congratulations to Portal 2, Now Loading's Game of the Year for 2011!
Runners Up: Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim (X360), Batman Arkham City (X360)
Thank you for reading all about the winners of my 2011 Best + Worst Awards, I'm sure you probably guessed some, but were you surprised by any of my choices? Also thank you for joining me for my 2011 Wrap Ups Super Special and I will do all again next year. With that coming to a close I will talk to you next on Monday, January 16th when Now Loading In-Depth returns for Season 2! Happy New Year! Loading Complete!
Log in to comment