I love Red Dead and haven't played Dark Souls yet but completed Demon's Souls and if that game is as good or even better than Demon's Souls I feel it should win GOTG becuase is the videogamest-videogame of this generation.
I just really want to see a Mass Effect 2 vs Dark Souls in the finals.
@angeln7: In what way? They're not even close to the same genre, so what is your comparison based on?
As a game the mechanics and gameplay offer a lot more than Mario Galaxy that only has great level design and platforming as the core of it's gameplay, Fallout 3 is filled with different mechanics and I enjoyed almost all of them, it's hard to compare 2 games that don't really share anything but nothing that Mario Galaxy does for it's own genre exceeds what Fallout 3 did.
Persona 2 Innocent Sin for the PSP ... 12 hours in after a really tedious dungeon about some mirrow stuff that had you trapped in it or something... I guess I'll never finish that game I don't know, it has a strong start but I don't want to repeat that dungeon again.
I'd vote for Minecraft if we were talking about it in the Beta Days; everything post-release has just turned it into a disappointing, muddled mess with a complete lack of cohesion to the design. They just throw shit into a pot nowadays and it made me completely lose interest.
Yup I feel the same I don't even know how minecraft got this far... remember when Giantbomb or at least the Bombcast used to think this wasn't even a game? I feel the same after the "official" release.