@JasonR86: Patrick liked XCOM though! RDR was never going to win because the 4 of them liked ME2 and only 3 of them liked RDR. but I think everyone will like the top two games (xcom and walking dead) here.
Only thing I'm worried about is the new voices. Good thing I'm not attached to the original Chie voice so it might not affect me as much as some people. Teddie on the other hand I'm worried they might fuck up.... Have yet to play it because I'm currently on the last hours of the ER and want to finish that before I jump back into the game. Might also save it for Christmas/Holiday break and play it while there is down time. We shall see but I'm sure it is still the greatest game ever made.
If it's anything like P4A, his voice sounds eerily similar to the original Teddie; if you told me it was just the same VA with a mildly different cadence I would totes believe you.