Something went wrong. Try again later

ArbitraryWater

Internet man with questionable sense of priorities

16104 5585 171 655
Forum Posts Wiki Points Following Followers

Ye Old Skoole Resident Evil games rated in a numerical fashion

When it comes down to it, there are only a few games and franchises that really incite the kind of mad, salivating fervor that I display on the internet. Fire Emblem is one of them. Resident Evil is another. Since I have played every single main-series Resident Evil game, I figure it fair to rate them in a numerical order to show how much I like each one. The newer games aren't on this list because they're different kinds of games and I'm really not sure where I would put them in the hierarchy of the series. 4 is obviously a game that holds up for not-crazy people, I liked 5 more than most people seemed to, and 6? Well, I sorta enjoyed RE6, but I'm not going to pretend it's a good video game in any sense of the word.

List items

  • If there was a gold standard for how to remake a game, REmake would be that standard. In addition to being hard, it's really the best game in the series for showcasing what "Survival Horror" is actually about. Killing Zombies without decapitating or burning them is a bad idea, and ammunition is scarce enough that avoidance is usually the best policy anyways. It also succeeds at having clever puzzles, a gloomy atmosphere and messes with your expectations if you've played the first one. Truly best in its class.

  • Has the much vaunted A/B system, though if we really want to be fair the differences between the 4 scenarios aren't that numerous. Still incredibly solid, albeit incredibly easy by your 4th or so time through.

  • Nails the B-horror movie tone (unintentional as it is) that the other two don't quite do as much. Sure, they play better and are a bit more clever, but the voice acting isn't as laughably terrible and that's really what makes this a classic, more than anything else.

  • Nemesis is pants-crappingly terrifying, though the game itself throws absurd amounts of ammunition at you via the gunpowder system and by the end you have like 40 freeze rounds regardless of whatever else you've done.

  • After a quick replay, this game fell a decent amount in my personal estimation. Not without its merits, but definitely one of the weaker games in the series as a whole. Still better than Code Veronica.

  • Has a severe issue of pacing, easily twice as long as the rest of the games on this list, and is also surprisingly hard for the first part and surprisingly not hard for the second part. Also invalidates any need for inventory management because both characters have 10 inventory slots. Does get props for having a knife that isn't totally worthless, for what that's worth.

1 Comments

Avatar image for yummylee
Yummylee

24646

Forum Posts

193025

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 88

User Lists: 24

Edited By Yummylee

I've wanted to make such a list for a long while... but then the dreaded laziness took a hold. Plus I wanted to encompass every Resident Evil game I had played at that, and the idea was a little daunting. Anywhoo I can agree to a large extent with the ordering. As I've said before, even though I still like Veronica to an extent, it's undoubtedly the weakest of the classic RE games.

In any case my order of the 6 from best to worst would resemble something like this, sans commentary:

  • Resident Evil 2
  • Resident Evil REmake (which also looks so damn stupid, which is kind of the appeal I imagine)
  • Resident Evil 3
  • Resident Evil Zero
  • Resident Evil
  • Resident Evil: Code: Veronica X

And I agree with you at the utmost when it comes to the remake, especially at how it completely twists the expectations and perceptions for players who have gone through the original. Stuff like the possibility of Richard surviving the poison (but then funnily enough still dying later one), Forest Speyer reanimating as a zombie (which I recently discovered was actually first introduced in the Director's Cut of the original), the addition of the yellow gem 'tiger eye' alongside the red & blue, completely remixed puzzles, Lisa Trevor (who is potentially even more frightening than Nemesis, if not more disturbing), and Neptune... just, fffffffffffffff - undoubtedly one of the most legitimately terrifying moments across the entire franchise.

The remake is assuredly the better survival horror game and the primary reason as to why it loses out to RE2 for me is because of the relevance it has in my childhood.